Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
NZ NZ

Let's ban talking about Brian O'Driscoll's shoulder for the next two months

By Jamie Wall
BOD (Photo: Getty Images)

Please can everybody – including Brian O’Driscoll – stop going on about Brian O’Driscoll this Lions tour, pleads Jamie Wall.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Lions tour of New Zealand is still a couple of weeks away, but we’re already getting kind of sick of hearing about one of the players – and he’s not even in the touring squad. It’s not so much Brian O’Driscoll himself, just the one thing that continually gets brought up every time his name gets mentioned in these parts.

There’s a lot of good stuff to remember about BOD. Like when he was a show-off at training:

Or this courageous effort when he stopped the floodgates from truly opening at Eden Park:

And this classic try, because it was against the Aussies back when they were good (believe it or not, many years ago this was true):

But we don’t hear about any of this. We don’t hear about how Brian O’Driscoll is the most capped and widely regarded as the best Irish player of all time. All we ever hear about is his goddamned shoulder and what Tana Umaga and Keven Mealamu did to it at Lancaster Park in 2005.

Rugby is certainly a game that has a history of bringing up past grievances. In New Zealand people still debate whether Bob Deans scored a try against Wales in 1905. The Scots will probably be poking pins into Craig Joubert voodoo dolls till the end of time. Meanwhile, South Africans are convinced the Springboks would’ve won the first two World Cups – although I think we can all agree that not sending them an invite was pretty justifiable.

Brian O’Driscoll’s shoulder injury in the first test of the 2005 series is a little bit different, though. Had it never happened, it’s highly unlikely that his presence would’ve had any influence on the outcome of the game, series or subsequent tour legacy. The Lions were hopelessly outclassed in the test matches, despite getting off to a brilliant start in the second. The Dan Carter-led backlash showed that even O’Driscoll’s talents weren’t going to do anything other than perhaps delay the inevitable.

ADVERTISEMENT

[rugbypass-ad-banner id=”1473306980″]

So the incident doesn’t even have any real merit as a turning point at all. But that’s not stopping the media, who are more than happy to regurgitate the same story whenever the All Blacks and Lions share the same column space. Yes, I’m definitely including the kiwi media in that too, who are just as quick to parry and riposte any allegations of wrongdoing.

This fixation just isn’t doing anyone any good. O’Driscoll is making himself look like a whingeing baby, a reputation that wasn’t helped by his outspoken views on getting dropped in the next Lions tour. Fast forward to Irish anger at the All Blacks’ perceived roughness during their win over the men in green in Dublin late last year, and it was all too easy for NZ fans to crown the Irish as sore losers – made easier by the fact that O’Driscoll had set that precedent.

As for the media, it’s just so damn lazy. If the hype is to be believed and this tour is the pinnacle of a lot of these players’ careers, surely there are better things to talk about than a ruck cleanout from 12 years ago?

ADVERTISEMENT

Join free

Fresh Starts | Episode 1 | Will Skelton

ABBIE WARD: A BUMP IN THE ROAD

Aotearoa Rugby Podcast | Episode 8

James Cook | The Big Jim Show | Full Episode

New Zealand victorious in TENSE final | Cathay/HSBC Sevens Day Three Men's Highlights

New Zealand crowned BACK-TO-BACK champions | Cathay/HSBC Sevens Day Three Women's Highlights

Japan Rugby League One | Steelers v Sungoliath | Full Match Replay

Rugby Europe Women's Championship | Netherlands v Spain

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

M
Mzilikazi 38 minutes ago
Swashbuckling Hurricanes and Harlequins show scrum still matters

I always enjoy a good scrum based article. Thanks, Nick. The Hurricanes are looking more and more the team to beat down here in Australasia. They are a very well balanced team. And though there are far fewer scrums in the game these days, destructive power in that area is a serious weapon, especially an attacking scrum within in the red zone. Aumua looked very good as a young first year player, but then seemed to fade. He sure is back now right in the picture for the AB’s. And I would judge that Taukei’aho is in a bit of a slump currently. Watching him at Suncorp a few weeks ago, I thought he was not as dominant in the game as I would have expected. I am going to raise an issue in that scrum at around the 13 min mark. I see a high level of danger there for the TH lifted off the ground. He is trapped between the opposition LH and his own powerful SR. His neck is being put under potentially dangerous pressure. The LH has, in law , no right to use his superior scrummaging skill….getting his head right in on the breastbone of the TH…..to force him up and off the ground. Had the TH popped out of the scrum, head up and free, there is no danger, that is a clear penalty to the dominant scrum. The law is quite clear on this issue: Law 37 Dangerous play and restricted practices in a scrum. C:Intentionally lifting an opponent off their feet or forcing them upwards out of the scrum. Sanction: Penalty. Few ,if any, referees seem to be aware of this law, and/or the dangers of the situation. Matthew Carly, refereeing Clermont v Munster in 2021, penalised the Munster scrum, when LH Wycherly was lifted very high, and in my view very dangerously, by TH Slimani. Lifting was coached in the late ‘60’s/70’s. Both Lions props, Ray McLouglin, and “Mighty Mouse” McLauchlan, were expert and highly successful at this technique. I have seen a photo, which I can’t find online atm, of MM with a NZ TH(not an AB) on his head, MM standing upright as the scrum disintegrates.

3 Go to comments
FEATURE
FEATURE How are Australian sides faring in Super Rugby Pacific? How are Australian sides faring in Super Rugby Pacific?
Search