Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global

'It's a disgrace to the game of rugby that a player can behave like that'

By Ian Cameron
Referee Paul Williams talks to Faf de Klerk of the Springboks during The Rugby Championship match between the Australian Wallabies and the South African Springboks at Adelaide Oval on August 27, 2022 in Adelaide, Australia. (Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

Former Springboks flyhalf Butch James has gone in hard on Wallabies scrumhalf Nic White following South Africa’s Rugby Championship loss to Australia.


The Wallabies’ 25-17 victory at the Adelaide Oval has blown the tournament open once again, but there was more than one incident that left a sour taste in South African mouths.

One moment in particular set tongues wagging.

In the 39th minute Wallabies No.9 White ‘earned’ Australia a yellow card after he received a glancing blow to the moustache from opposite number Faf de Klerk.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

White appeared to look up to the referee and then drop to the ground following the minor collision, leading many to believe that he had made the most of the contact to eke out a penalty.

Faf looked perplexed when Referee Paul Williams awarded him a yellow card for the incident and needless to say, it didn’t go down well with Boks’ fans or indeed the panel of experts on Super Sport in SA, who didn’t see the funny side of it.

Well-known South African sports pundit Mark Keohane said White should have been sent off, not de Klerk. “Nic White should have been carded for that Oscar … his most embarrassing moment as a professional.”

Reacting to the incident after the game, James told the panel on Super Sport that: “It’s a disgrace to the game of rugby that a player [Nic White] can behave like that.”


Fellow panelist Nick Mallett pointed out that De Klerk has set himself for a fall by making contact in the first place. “It’s stupid enough to have a swinging arm, he opened himself up to it,” said Mallett.

The incident of course became a talking point on Twitter, where many did see the funny side of it.

Former Scotland lock Jim Hamilton wrote: “Some men would rather be stripped naked in -40 degree temperatures live on tv than have their moustache slapped off.”


Squidge Rugby described it as a classic piece of scrumhalf skullduggery. “That’s an all-time bit of scrum-half play by Nic White. Turns an absolutely nothing moment into a yellow card by milking it so vigorously they now serve that moment in vegan cafes.”


Join free



Trending on RugbyPass


pele 659 days ago

Faffy also tackled Oscar winner white he was on the ground.

burt 661 days ago

you swing a closed fist ,you pay with yellow card

Noel 662 days ago

What about the red card the Wallabies nr 11 should of got for the no arms tackle that he made on Mpimpi on the try line??
The referee didn't even refer it.

mark 662 days ago

Swinging arm face slaps and hair pulling dont belong in the game

lot 662 days ago

Bokke fans have become the whingy whiny club everytime they lost. LOL. too embarrassing and very unworldcup winner like.. being hit on the nose is one very painful spot. just hit yourself there and check your response..

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

FEATURE Why Joe Schmidt cannot rely on the Brumbies' creaking tight five Why Joe Schmidt cannot rely on the Brumbies' creaking tight five