1
Galthie opens old wound with rebuke of RWC referee and one Springbok
By Josh Raisey
Five months after France crashed out of their own World Cup at the hands of eventual winners South Africa, Fabien Galthie has revisited the fateful quarter-final match in Paris to take aim at the refereeing performance of Ben O’Keeffe.
ADVERTISEMENT
Speaking at a review of France’s recent Guinness Six Nations campaign in Marcoussis, the head coach of Les Bleus addressed the 29-28 loss to the Springboks, something that many believe had an impact on their recent form.
While France captain Antoine Dupont was forthright in his excoriation of the officiating in the aftermath of the loss, Galthie was much more reserved. However, he took the opportunity this week to discuss the topic.
“We lost the quarter-final for rugby reasons but also for refereeing decisions,” he said, as reported by French outlet Midi Olympique (translated by Google).
“We also spoke about it with Ben O’Keeffe during a recent meeting at World Rugby.
“The decision is part of the match and we accept it. You will never see me react directly to an arbitration decision. But we can discuss it coldly.
“In a World Rugby committee, I therefore had the opportunity to speak with Ben O’Keeffe.
“At one point in the meeting there was a discussion about the behaviour of the selectors. I took the floor and said that we had a major role as educators and that we must behave with respect towards the referees. This is fundamental.
“I told him that my players had been strongly impacted by questionable decisions. Everyone agreed on the fact that some decisions weren’t the right ones. He wasn’t at all happy with his performance either.”
ADVERTISEMENT
The South Africa players themselves were not out of the firing line of the former scrumhalf’s rebuke, with flanker Kwagga Smith being singled out.
“There is a ball stolen with elbows on the ground by Kwagga Smith which gives three points to the Springboks, for example.
“We today we want to count on the work of regulation and rules undertaken in these World Rugby committees. We must make our voice heard.”
France finished second in this year’s Six Nations, beating Wales and England in the final two rounds of the Championship.
ADVERTISEMENT
Following a dismal loss to Ireland in the opening round, Galthie’s side scraped to a win over Scotland in round two before drawing to Italy in Lille- a result whereby they were saved by Paolo Garbisi’s infamous late penalty miss.
Galthie and his coaching staff were under serious pressure heading into the final two rounds, but he may well have saved his job with two markedly improved performances, capped by an epic 33-31 win over England in Lyon.
To be fair - Galthie has the right to complain about the refereeing of BoK at the World Cup.
But he should get a 12 month ban for doing so.
Ban him and just give him a bib, doesnt need the mic then.
The issue in this match was not that O’Keefe made bad calls - in every match referees make bad calls and the teams must be prepared for that - but rather that its refereeing was not in line with the 2023 World Rugby guidelines regarding the breakdown. Before 2023 Galthie’s France was happy to play without the ball and focused on kicking and a strong game at the breakdown to recover the ball and score points/flash counter-attack. That changed with the new regulations and the France/Italy 6N match, from which their strategy had to evolve to a game including more possession. In this quater-final the refereeing was very lenient regarding ground play and the boks took advantage of that, something that their opponents failed to do as their were just waiting for the whistle.
Actually I believe the issues the springboks had with refereeing consistency the years before served them well for this world cup as they manage to adapt in most situations (and perhaps playing in both hemisphere helped as well). For instance in the semi-final against England, BoK was way more strict regarding what player could do in the ground, and that gave a lot of troubles to the south africans in the beginning of the match, however they managed to adapt and recover in time.
having a laws consultant (Jaco Peyper) in the team is a good example of how the boks adapt to the game - including its many (and often bewildering) rules changes.
France needs to learn to win without Dupont. Calls will always go with you and away from you - don’t put yourself in a position where the ref wins/loses you the game
If you’re a dominant team, dominate. The 1st game in 6 Nations showed how underprepared France was for a good team. Inconsistency always costs France so I think it’s a flaw in the drilling / approach
Well said. Unfortunately for me, the French have gone over to the SH side with huge forwards (plus Dupont) but forgotten how to run the ball like they used to. And of course now the Boks are adding the running rugby with some incredible backs but couldn't demonstrate that in the autumn wet weather. Wait till 2027!
Must admit Galthie needs to move on now. He should feel better at least that his side are the second best in the world after Ireland now. England much improved and are now third in the World. Reading all the opinions of the media and commentators thoughts, it appears world rugby strength is now firmly north of the equator. Thanks heavens there is no WC this year, as the Boks and ABs would have no chance, and Australia really no hope. If I was Galthie, and Borthwick, and Farrell, and Townsend, I would stop reading and listening to all the bullshit and get ready to face the south. The Aussies will be a totally different beast under Schmidt, and their sides already show massive improvement in SR. The ABs will be slightly in transition, but Razor is there. And Rassie has changed up his coaching ticket and will experiment a bit and test new players as well as tactics. I wonder the odds on a Southern Hemisphere whitewash?
I remember when I had my first beer.
Issues need to be brought up in the cold after a few months not in the immediate aftermath. Foster’s behaviour targetting Barnes and the TMO resulted in death threats. I assume he is still whinging wherever he is.
Outside the dodgy draws and shceduling of world cups, SH sides have tended to lose against the top NH sides in recent years.
based on actual RWC winners to date your thinking is out of the past 10 world cups the NH has won 1 but if it was held this year things would be different. Probably find you are correct, imaginary cups are easier to win
I’m proudly a French citizen but sadly the national malaise - complaining about almost every bloody thing - is evidently alive and well. There is a sense of entitlement in this country that would make even the most ardent BLM activist blush.
“…..make even the most ardent BLM activist blush”.
Black people aren’t entitled in France. Far from it. It’s a bit cowardly to use a rugby situation to get a slur like that in. Whatever you are, you’re no French patriot. French patriots are Republicans. Petainists are neither.
Bok supporters and their ‘50/50 calls’ and they went ‘both ways’ and ‘move on’. Theyre just priceless. Its OK, but only if its SA benefitting from it. Its OK for Rassie ‘The Waterboy’ Erasmus, he’s a genius for his ‘leaked’ Video nasties and blatant attack on the referees, no ‘50/50 calls’ on his edited highlights. Bryce Lawrence was victimised for years (and still is). A lifetime of referee whinging tells us all we need to know. Galthie is right. France were robbed. Cheaty Kolbe and his chargedown. That’s not a ‘50/50’, that should have been reviewed. Etzebeth and his 1-handed zero-attempt at an intercept was cynical and a YC and Pen Try. Unequivocally. But no, France have ‘only got themselves to blame’. Bok fans -> priceless. Or ‘sore loser’, worse winners.
Exactly how stupid are you, anyway?
I love it!! I sit here and smile to myself because we have 4 WC’s in the bag. It has to be so painful to be a sore loser but the bottom line is “Frankly my friend, we don’t give a damn!” It will take about 30 to 40 years for either Ireland, England or France to equal our record. Nice man!!
You obviously have had as much education in the English language usage as you have had about rugby.
Red and White Shyte your excessive use of single quotes is an indication of ignorance and dim wit. Ask any of the desperate hacks showboating on RP
Not agreeing with you. But look at Ardense’s push on Fickou (pushed him into two French players clearing a straight run to the line) for try number one.
I don’t think you know what the word ‘unequivocally’ means. Certainly, you can debate if it was the right decision but you can’t say 100% it was penalty try - unless you have an axe to grind with Bok supporters. Even Nigel Owens has said he agrees with the referee’s decision because there is no clear evidence that the ball went forward from Etzebeth’s hand. So if O’Keeffe saw it going backwards then the decision should stand. But, hey, don’t let facts get in the way of a good anti-SA rant, hey? Priceless.
Red and White, the game is played mostly in the NH, the rules are decided by WR which in reality is a European old boys club, the refs are elected and decided for each game by WR( same old boys club) and the results seem to stay the same. Winning a WC needs a squad to win 7 games. In the modern era, the Boks have played all the WCs away from home, and a big % in the NH. It is far fetched to say they have managed to influence every game and every ref during all 3 their WC wins abroad. Really? No Red/White, they won because they were tough, resilient, determined and bloody minded and in the key moments managed to do the right thing. This has f…all to do with refs and all the bull you go on about. If France, Ireland or England had displayed just a bit of this toughness and resilience they would have reached finals and possibly won. The ABs understand that and bested Ireland last WC and nearly beat Boks. They understand what it takes.
Like it or not, that Bryce Lawrence incident was a blight on the game but also a turning point for the good.
Before the Bryce Lawrence incident WR did not have any procedures in place to prevent match officials from influencing the outcome of a match or prevent approaches from outside to affect a predetermined result.
This is also what triggered SANZAAR to lead the way in developing and implementing the Referee Assessment Process that WR has today.
Is France still crying months after World cup…So sad to hear and see..
At this rate we can expect the crying about the 6N to start shortly.
It’s as bad as ever. Maybe worse. We expected to walk over everybody in the Six Nations, particularly because we were playing Ireland and England at home, but since the debacle against Ireland, the dark cloud has reappeared. Quite pathetic really.
He’s not wrong. But Barnes was also terrible too. But apparently you’re not allowed to point that obvious fact out to world rugby or the refs. They’re soft like soccer players it seems
So if Rassie gets sanctioned by World Rugby, why is Galtie let off without a mention?
Oh well. There’s always 4 years from now.
The World cup with its dodgy draw and scheduling isn’t everything. Tests in between matter also.