Northern | US

'Tough one': All Blacks winger dissects what's behind high-ball struggles


New Zealand's wing Caleb Clarke jumps for the ball with Shark's South African fullback Zekhethelo Siyaya during a rugby union tour match between The Sharks and New Zealand at Kings Park Stadium in Durban on August 11, 2026. (Photo by PHILL MAGAKOE / AFP via Getty Images)
Comments
7 Comments

One of the All Blacks‘ best under the high ball, Caleb Clarke, has addressed his side’s ongoing struggles in the aerial battle and how they are trying to fix it.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dave Rennie’s side has struggled to dominate the air since he took over at the start of the 2026 international season, continuing the All Blacks’ struggles from 2025.

They have, though, tried to implement a new, improved strategy for the winger to retreat and take the catch facing their own dead-ball line, but Rassie Erasmus’ Springboks managed to combat Rennie’s plan over the course of Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry.

VIDEO

The Springboks chasers would often race ahead of the play to get between the winger and the ball, to gain a better chance of retaining the in-play contestable kick.

Clarke, whose aerial game is among the best in the country, discussed what the All Blacks are currently working on in that space.

“Yeah, it’s a tough one, honestly. And I’ll tell you, with these new rules, it’s been slow for us to adjust, especially when it comes to that one-on-one competing in the air,” Clarke told The Breakdown on Sky Sport.

“It’s literally just what we’re talking about all the time around, just catching it cleanly. For myself, like it’s a part that I really enjoy in competing, especially chasing after it, because I know I just got a free jump to the ball, and it’s a one-on-one matchup with someone else.

ADVERTISEMENT

“So, you know, we tried different things. We tried hitting back and trying to catch it on the run, trying to come forward and catching it as well. But credit to the Springboks who just really put pressure on the catcher, and everyone else was picking up those scraps.”

Related

Clarke pinpoints a training stint with the Sydney Swans in the AFL to explain the different ways you can take the ball in the air.

“I remember when I went over with the Swans, they were all wondering why I kept catching like this, and they’re like, aren’t you putting your hands up? And I had to explain to them, if I put my hands up and I drop it forward, the ball goes to the other team, and that’s sort of the different stuff.

“But the fundamentals of jumping and, like, timing your jump, catching at the max height of your jump is what they were really trying to teach me, and what I try to bring back to rugby. And so, yeah, we were practising it in the All Blacks environment.

ADVERTISEMENT

“But again, it’s just coming down to that day and how well you execute.”

If there was any doubt that the All Blacks aren’t trying to rectify the constant mistakes in the aerial battle, Clarke guarantees fans and pundits around the world that it’s a work in progress.

“It’s a touch and go. We do go live against each other, but at the same time, we want to protect each other as well. As I said before, we’re competing for these spots, and also we want to make sure the boys that get out there on the night are making sure they’re in good health as well.

“We use different techniques if we can’t go live against each other, but we’re putting in the work, and that’s sort of the disappointing part. When it comes down to the day, it just doesn’t stick. But people just need to know that we are putting in that work.”


Relive the drama, intensity, and history — all the iconic British & Irish Lions documentaries from 2001-2021, available now on RugbyPass TV.


ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

7 Comments
D
DarstedlyDan 15 days ago

We’ve always struggled with the aerial side of things, and it takes us a season or two to learn.


The boks in 2009 beat us 3-zip because of our lack of aerial game.


It took us a couple of seasons to figure out the escort when that was a thing. We didn’t really solve it until end 2022.


And now the anti-escort full competition era. And we are a couple of seasons in with no solution - yet.


It is because we have a tendency to undervalue kick-catch as a way to regain possession and create chaos, and view the kick only as a way to relieve pressure when running it out isn’t working, or a chip over the rush D because nothing else is on. We view it as a negative action, not a positive one - even though it is a chaos-creator - and is made for creating attacking opportunities that rely on similar skills to the counter attack.


Let’s hope the historical pattern holds and a solution is just round the corner!

D
DarstedlyDan 15 days ago

The ABs are no good at it because contestable kicking is not common in NZ domestic rugby and SRP. So it’s not practiced in game situations.


We had a couple of years where halfbacks were box kicking, but typically deep, and few challengers. Almost like they were embarrassed to be doing it. Lots of great running rugby, not much aerial work.


We fans are partly to blame, continually complaining about kicking and box kicks ruining the spectacle. We’re the running rugby kings, you know. But rugby is multifaceted, and focus on one to the detriment of the others means you get less good at the others.


The lack of variety of playing style in SR is also part of the problem. No one comes up against a team that kicks well, that builds their game around a dominant scrum and lineout. Its all the same.


This works against teams 5 to 25 in the test arena. Teams in the top 4 will have something else that we are not used to. And the best of those teams - the Boks and possibly France - are good enough that the ABs, as good as their running rugby is, will lose to them more often than not.


I suspect this is what Razor was trying to fix - but at the cost of the bit we were good at. I don’t think we can do more than paper over these deficiencies until the «other» elements of the game - kicking, high ball work, dominant scrums, etc - are viable and winning in SR.

S
SC 15 days ago

This is a very good post with lots of excellent points.


I would just add that the NZ print and tv media are also to blame, especially The Breakdown (Wilson, Muliaina, and Donald this season and Kirwin in previous) who are ruthlessly complaining constantly about scummaging taking too long to set, driving mauls being obstruction, and too much boxkicking.


The Crusaders have been the franchise that has historically been the only one of the NZ franchises to emphasis the importance of these three, along with field position and defence, and surprise have won 15 Super Rugby championships.


Winning rugby is not actually running rugby and playing to “Kiwis DNA”.


The McCaw- Carter era (2005-2015) dominated rugby scrummaging for penalties when inside their own 22m, driving mauls inside their opponents 22m, and kicking penalty goals- thus Carter being World Rugby’s all-time leading points scorer. The All Blacks in this era dominated up front and THEN released their world class backline. They did not run it from everywhere as some pundits claim. Carter was the king of controlling territory and attacking in the right areas of the pitch.

T
Tk 15 days ago

It was really noticeable in the RGR tests how much more contestable the Boks kicks were. Most kick offs the AB catcher was getting clobbered, the Boks catcher had an easy day often without a chaser with 5m.

S
Steppin 15 days ago

It’s funny because you have couch coaches saying “what are they practicing at training?” “How come they didn’t prepare for this?” as if the coaches weren’t aware that the Boks were going to use an aerial game plan. It’s just the Boks are the best in the world at it!

r
rs 15 days ago

I think another thing is that in super rugby a lot of 9s don’t box kick as well as the Boks, an inaccurate kick means little high ball contention. The Aussie teams got some big blockers in the back line, but how many of their 9s can put up a big high contestable box kick.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close