Northern | US

All Blacks’ defeat to Wales is unfortunate but not a disaster

Leicester Fainga'anuku of New Zealand looks dejected after the Nations Championship 2026 match between Wales and New Zealand at Principality Stadium on November 14, 2026 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by Dan Istitene/Getty Images)
Comments
Comment

South Africa’s lost three times already this year.

I’m trying to remember that as I look at what happened when the All Blacks met Wales over the weekend. In a two-horse race you can lose and even the best teams, i.e. the Springboks, do it on semi-regular occasions.

ADVERTISEMENT

I was all in on this All Blacks group. I loved that Dave Rennie and Neil Barnes had come in to coach, I was ecstatic that Graham Henry was given a selectorial role and that sports psychologist Gilbert Enoka had returned to the fold.

These are serious men with impressive bodies of work. Winners, whose methods have been honed and proven over decades.

VIDEO

The All Blacks were beaten 35-28 in Cardiff, on Sunday morning (NZ time), but they lost that game in Sydney on October 17. That 43-21 result against Australia instilled a level of complacency and even delusion that I didn’t think was possible under the watch of Rennie, Barnes, Henry and Enoka.

Put simply, I thought they were better than that.

I’ll go back to what I said at the top. Teams lose sometimes and, in isolation, the All Blacks’ defeat to Wales is unfortunate but not a disaster. The Welsh were magnificent, but the All Blacks still top the Southern Hemisphere portion of the Nations Championship standings and a few of the first-stringers sat the match out.

You can mount that argument as an All Blacks supporter and with a degree of validity too.

But, to my mind, Rennie’s tenure took a significant turn for the worse the moment New Zealand went to halftime leading Australia 36-7 at Accor Stadium.

That was the moment when the All Blacks ceased wanting to be a serious test rugby team and was content to play like the Chiefs.

ADVERTISEMENT

They got away with it against Scotland, in part because Damian McKenzie is such a brilliant footballer. With him in the stands in Cardiff, the All Blacks actually looked like a rabble.

Rugby wasn’t always better in my day. Players had jobs and spent a good chunk of their year playing club rugby. When they did assemble with the All Blacks, it was for a day or two before they kicked off a series against whoever they were playing.

Performances were patchy and combinations clunky. It often took them a game or two to work their way into a series in which their opponents had warmed up by playing New Zealand provincial sides.

These All Blacks have no such excuses for their dismal showing at the Principality Stadium.

ADVERTISEMENT

They did what our national team has done for years now. They shovelled the ball from side to side in the hope a defender would make a bad decision or fall off a tackle.

Only the Welsh didn’t and the All Blacks made error upon error and were punished for it on the scoreboard.

Then, having seen that tactic not work, New Zealand just carted the ball up. It honestly wasn’t unlike watching the 2007 Rugby World Cup quarterfinal loss to France at the same venue.

Highly-paid, highly-coached, highly-praised, apparently highly-talented men bereft of ideas and the ability to execute basic skills.

The All Blacks are a team with nothing to fall back on. They’ve decided that keeping the ball alive at all costs is their only route to victory and, when that doesn’t work, they’re stuffed.

They don’t kick for goal or the corner, they don’t maul or give the ball to the opponent and back their defence to win turnovers and create counterattacking opportunities. They play high-tempo, high-risk rugby of the sort that wins the Chiefs any number of round-robin games, but rarely a final.

Rennie’s come out and said the right things since Cardiff, but I honestly cannot fathom what they’re doing and talking about within the camp and I’ll conclude by giving one example.

To my eye, Rieko Ioane is the ultimate rugby athlete. Big, fast, strong and nimble he should just about be the All Blacks’ greatest attacking weapon.

Related

He’s been injected off the bench in the games against Scotland and Wales and barely touched the ball. What plan has he been given? What plays are being devised to put him in space? What has he learned, in his almost 100 test appearances, about manipulating and breaching defensive lines? What’s the point of bringing him on if he’s not in a position to contribute?

That’s not a criticism of the man, more an illustration of the overall incoherence of this team.

They’re not playing under-10s anymore. There has to be more nuance than just giving the ball to D-Mac and hoping for the best.

1 YEAR TO GO - RWC27

1 YEAR TO GO 

The countdown is on until the biggest Men’s Rugby World Cup ever kicks off in Australia. Go All Out and secure your seats with tickets now available! 

BUY TICKETS NOW

HSBC SVNS returns to Cape Town this December!

Don't miss your chance to see the world’s best rugby teams take centre stage 5-6 December in Cape Town.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close