Wales’ resounding 35-28 triumph over the All Blacks to break a 73-year drought has offered Rennie and his staff an unfiltered view of the depth within the squad.
We already knew that there are positions that are thin within the All Blacks, and then there are those who are outright irreplaceable. The short list of Cam Roigard, Jordie Barrett, Will Jordan and Ardie Savea.
Cortez Ratima is a handy player, but the gulf in status between Roigard and the next best No.9 is as large as it has ever been within the All Blacks.
When the All Blacks defeated a very capable French B unit in July in Christchurch, it was Jordie Barrett and Cam Roigard orchestrating a lot of the tries to do so.
Of the five scored, Roigard finished two of them and Jordie Barrett assisted on two of them.
Dissecting Wales’ triesin their win, the chiefs architects of Tomas Williams and Louis Rees-Zammit had a similar impact. If they don’t have the class of those two, perhaps two or three of the opportunities go begging.
From the All Blacks late second half red zone visits inside Wales’ 22, the All Blacks spent an eternity playing crash & bash rugby for no reward. Not for a lack of opportunities, on multiple occasions you can see runners in gaps screaming for the pass for would-be walk-ins when they shifted more than one pass off the ruck.
Anton Lienert-Brown opting not to pass and then getting caught short in a miraculous tackle of centre Eddie James summed up the second half up in a nutshell.
You can bet your bottom dollar that Jordie Barrett and Cam Roigard would have come up with the plays needed. Or Damian McKenzie for that matter.
McKenzie, regarded as a free-wheeling cavalier, for all the errors that come once in awhile, actually has delivered a lot in attack. He creates a lot of line break assists and that was sorely needed when peppering the Welsh goal line. He would have likely put a runner or two over.
That raises question marks around the core game drivers, Richie Mo’unga, Beauden Barrett and Cortez Ratima who just didn’t get on the same script. The shape inside the redzone didn’t deliver with so many one-off runners it was basically telegraphed in.
The Mo’unga-Barrett combination has been tried and tried again, it feels like a broken record. Surely it can’t go to a third Rugby World Cup in a row? It had it’s time, with missed opportunities at both.
Ratima does need more time in the saddle and this will be a good game to learn from. He scored a well taken try early by sniping the blindside from the maul. He needs to back himself more to create, after all, that’s what Roigard does.
On Lienert-Brown, we keep getting sold the veteran by Rennie on how good he is. He’s a Chiefs player and he played under Rennie at Kobe. He’s nearing 100 caps and had 10 years at the top level. Yet Scott Robertson barely picked him. He couldn’t get a look in. Is he really that good or is he just from the right franchise?
There is a huge reluctance these days by the All Blacks to use players at Test level in their athletic prime. We saw with Ruben Love sitting on the sidelines for two years before finally getting the starting role this year at age 25. Now it seems the same with Josh Jacomb, with a desire to coddle him all the way to his eventual debut.
Mo’unga is not in form, has sat two months with a calf injury, why can’t we trust and back 25-year-old Josh Jacomb to deliver? Have we forgotten that Dan Carter destroyed the British & Irish Lions at 23?
We doubled down on experience and lost anyway, and now where does Jacomb even get a cap? Against England, or in a potential final if they win next week, against France? Unlikely.
Richie Mo’unga just didn’t need to be picked this year at all. Built up as the saviour by former head coach Robertson and media pressuring NZR to bend the rules for him, his elevated expectations have fallen flat.
His injury hasn’t helped, but he was far below the standard in Baltimore as the Springboks just sent blitzers out of the line to hit him late. In Cardiff you’d have to assume the calf has kept him below his best.
Mo’unga had a great run of Test rugby from mid-2022 into the 2023 Rugby World Cup. It might take awhile to get that player back, and he could do with a full pre-season and Super Rugby season.
The Welsh outplayed the All Blacks but the game was still available, with over half an hour to take control and build a lead. They couldn’t do it.
And that’s why the value of Cam Roigard, Jordie Barrett, and Will Jordan just went up. If you were negotiating a contract right now on their behalf, you’d bump up the ask.
The true game breakers who will make the right play weren’t on the field. And the reality for the All Blacks is they just don’t have more waiting to take their position.
1 YEAR TO GO
The countdown is on until the biggest Men’s Rugby World Cup ever kicks off in Australia. Go All Out and secure your seats with tickets now available!
