Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Wayne Barnes on what football can learn from rugby amid VAR controversy

A VAR possible foul decision on the LED screen during the Premier League match between Newcastle United and Arsenal FC at St. James Park on November 4, 2023 in Newcastle upon Tyne, England. (Photo by Robbie Jay Barratt - AMA/Getty Images)

Wayne Barnes has said that football is currently in an “evolutionary period” with its video assistant referee (VAR), but has insisted the sport should not do away with the process.

ADVERTISEMENT

The scrutiny over the VAR only increased this week after the latest round of Premier League action, whether that is due to unsatisfactory decisions being reached or how long it is taking to reach those decisions.

Barnes, who retired from professional refereeing last week after taking charge of South Africa’s World Cup final victory over the All Blacks, has said that football is in the process of working out what decisions they are trying to reach. Rugby has had a television match official (TMO) for over two decades now, the entirety of Barnes’ professional career, and while that has not been a smooth process necessarily, particularly with the TMO’s influence growing in recent years, it is an established part of the game now.

Video Spacer

Lions’ scrum coach Julian Redelinghuys on that South African physicality

Video Spacer

Lions’ scrum coach Julian Redelinghuys on that South African physicality

In an interview with the BBC recently, where the 111-Test referee discussed the abuse officials receive in all sports, he also explained what football can learn from rugby as it goes through its teething period using video assistants.

“I hate to chuck grenades at other sports because I think that’s really unfair,” the 44-year-old said.

“Remember football has only had VAR in play for two or three years now, so they’re still on that evolutionary period. Rugby has been using the TMO for over 20 years, and the more expanded TMO for at least ten now.

“What football is still playing with and evolving is trying to work out what are those decision they are trying to get. It’s not about getting rid of the whole VAR process, but it’s working out ‘what do we mean by getting the big stuff- the clear and obvious stuff.’

ADVERTISEMENT

“I want people to understand what a difficult job it is, but I also want make sure officials are protected, not just within rugby, but in different sports.”

Related

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

4 Comments
Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

H
Hellhound 1 hour ago
Pat Lam blasts 'archaic' process that lost the All Blacks Tony Brown

Now you are just being a woke, jealous fool. With the way things are run in NZ, no wonder he couldn't make a success there. Now that he is out shining any other New Zealanders, including their star players, now he is bitter and resentful and all sorts of hate speeches against him. That is what the fans like you do. Those in NZ who does have enough sense not to let pride cloud their vision, is all saying the same thing. NZ needs TB. Razor was made out to be a rugby coaching God by the fans, so much so that Foz was treated like the worst piece of shitte. Especially after the Twickenham disaster right before the WC. Ad then he nearly won the WC too with 14 players. As a Saffa the way he handled the media and the pressure leading up to the WC, was just extraordinary and I have gained a lot of respect for that man. Now your so called rugby coaching God managed to lose by an even bigger margin, IN NZ. All Razor does is overplay his players and he will never get the best out of those players, and let's face it, the current crop is good enough to be the best. However, they need an coach they can believe in completely. I don't think the players have bought into his coaching gig. TB was lucky to shake the dust of his boots when he left NZ, because only when he did that, did his career go from strength to strength. He got a WC medal to his name. Might get another if the Boks can keep up the good work. New exciting young talent is set to join soon after the WC as dangerous as SFM and Kolbe. Trust me, he doesn't want the AB's job. He is very happy in SA with the Boks. We score, you lose a great coach. We know quality when we see it, we don't chuck it in the bin like NZRU likes to do. Your coaching God is hanging on by a thread to keep his job🤣🤣🤣🤣

38 Go to comments
Close
ADVERTISEMENT