Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Tony Brown: 'I talked to Razor a couple of months ago about joining the All Blacks'

PARIS, FRANCE - NOVEMBER 08: Tony Brown, the South Africa assistant coach, looks on during the Autumn Nations Series 2025 match between France and South Africa at the Stade de France on November 08, 2025 in Paris, France. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

Tony Brown has shared some candid insights into his All Blacks ambitions and how the All Blacks’ 2023 head coach appointment process played out, even revealing that he was approached by Scott Robertson a matter of months ago to join the All Blacks coaching ticket.

ADVERTISEMENT

Brown and Robertson’s friendship dates back to the New Zealand age-grade teams of the ’90s, where they were both regular selections, before becoming teammates in the All Blacks by the decade’s end.

While the pair have never coached together, their Super Rugby rivalry – Brown with the Highlanders and Robertson with the Crusaders – was elevated to the Test arena in 2023 when Robertson landed the All Blacks’ top job, and Brown moved to South Africa to head Rassie Erasmus’s attack.

VIDEO

Brown was understood to be a name involved in Jamie Joseph’s bid to become the All Blacks head coach in the 2023 race, but appears to have been left feeling a touch sour about how things played out.

“It was definitely the Scott Robertson team versus the Jamie Joseph team, that was the process that New Zealand Rugby set up,” Brown reflected, speaking with Mike Hosking on Newstalk ZB.

“So I think with me being with Jamie, then Scott potentially didn’t want to take me as well. He had quality coaches in Jason Holland and Leon MacDonald, Scott Hansen and Jason Ryan, so they had a strong coaching team. Jamie put his team together and I was part of that, and New Zealand Rugby went with Scott. 100 per cent, he probably deserved the job with his success.

“So it was just the way it was, and then I was stuck, either looking at going back to Japan, there was a little opportunity with Argentina, and then Rassie gave me a call about South Africa. I played under Rassie for the Stormers and knew him as a coach and knew that he’d obviously done some amazing things with South Africa over the last two World Cups, and I just thought, oh well, what an opportunity to go and learn off him.”

Related

Brown signed a four-year deal with the Springboks and intends to see that period through, despite the All Blacks’ recent advances.

“I’ve even talked to Razor a couple of months ago about potentially joining the All Blacks, but it’s like I said to him, my commitment to South Africa was four years, and I’ve always wanted to honour that.

“I said I’m just so frustrated that no one talked to me two years ago. But that’s rugby, and that’s coaching. He had his coaches, and I just had to go and find another job.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Were that not the case, Brown says he “100 per cent would have” put his name in the hat for the now vacant All Blacks job.

“Two years ago as well, and in the future. It’s definitely something I want to do. The timing just hasn’t worked.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

73 Comments
S
SM 45 days ago

He needed to have a clean out and for whatever reason didn't, now we can watch the player's association and rugby union finish turning the ABS into the Warriors.

B
B 45 days ago

Tony Brown has the opportunity to be part of SAR and RWC history in 2027…

He won't be coming back to NZRU unless SA lose and he's sacked??...or not..

N
Nigel Nicholas 46 days ago

After all these comments new Zealand still hasn't gotten any better

J
JH 46 days ago

Loved the way Tony played, and that he's bringing that to the bok backline. Long may he stay on! But when you look at what the best northern hemisphere club teams are doing to Sa’s provincial sides in the Champions Cup, I don't think SA should get ahead of ourselves. NZ, we went through numerous dark patches in coaching pre 2018. NZ needs an NZ head coach, but needs to allow ABs to play overseas and needs to bring in international specialists…asap, but Tony's not for hire

J
JW 46 days ago

Otago where a great side for sure.


South Africa (lets just say in general) had to make amends for apartheid, big difference in why you’ve had dark times.


Not yet JH! I don’t know if it needs a HC man, even Tony is in the same boat comparing to NH example, it’s not like he’s done a lot of been extremely successful, or more so than other coaches. South Africa just lack that particular part of their game and are making really easy strides under Tony, but remember it could be anyone, any of the tricky NH coachs that are organizing their teams styles so well.


Remember Tonyball has still only clicked for a couple of games, you basically did without it on the end of year tour with the RC every game on yours had. Still a lot of work and effort from him to put in. If he chooses to say with you ;)

M
MDL 46 days ago

NZR what a dysfunctional place it has become - good riddance Robinson

P
PB 45 days ago

Yeah? And to be replaced by who or what? AB fans are fickle for sure. Read my lips! NZR is going to rue this decision.


The thing is most AB fans refuse to accept that times have changed and NZ no longer have generational players in their squad. Regular losses against the top 5 are likely.

D
DP 46 days ago

What Tony has with the Boks is a cohesive group where the very notion of player power doesn’t exist and wouldn’t be allowed to exist under Rassie. Rassie subs Siya at 40 mins on his 100th test match - no problem. Rassie tells Duane and Eben to sort out their differences during the last WC -no problem. These are merely two examples of how the Boks operate. Now contrast this with the shambles in that AB dressing room… laughable.

J
JW 46 days ago

So youre saying we should really be after Rassie? We’ve got enough millions in the bank to make that happen I’m sure!


I know you’re only trying to help, but its actually amusing how that’s not actually the case in the All Blacks. There is no problem with the selections (from your example), but maybe a blunt Rassie approach might have done the trick!

D
DP 46 days ago

So Razor blatantly looked at destabilising the Boks by approaching Brown.. nice.

J
JW 46 days ago

Only South Africans could be so insecure.

J
Jen 46 days ago

Rubbish. Razor would have been trying to strengthen his own position and improve the ABs because some of his coaches have left. And how do you think coaches move around teams? You think noone ever talks to another coach while they’re contracted to someone else?

P
PB 46 days ago

Oh what nonsense! Nothing wrong with asking the question. TB is afterall a Kiwi, with ambitions to coach the AB’s one day. No harm done. TB could say Yay or Nay, no nefarious stuff at all.

T
TokoRFC 46 days ago

Is that so surprising? I would a lot of that goes on. Same way Rassie would have approached Felix Jones when he was at England?

r
rs 46 days ago

Robertson’s major failing was going for “loyalty”, instead of quality. Crusaders team over better coached & players. That should’ve been a red flag right from the start that this guy doesn’t have what it takes to lead the AB’s. Unfortunately, the Mark Robinson was equally incompetent

P
PickOllieMathisYeowRazorYouCoward 46 days ago

You wouldn’t select a tighthead prop based on who else they could get to be in the front row.

You just pick the 3 best guys.

J
JW 46 days ago

Are you saying Razor rated him as a top 3 guy?

j
johnz 46 days ago

Tony Brown confirms what many of us suspected.


TB was ready and willing to join the AB setup for two consecutive tenures. But NZR fluffed around with competitive processes and corporate waffle, with their dithering resulting in weak coaching teams being appointed each time.


While NZ snoozed, SA swooped and signed our precious IP. I feel for Razor being the fall guy in many ways. While it’s probably the right decision, the buck stops with NZR for signing off on an obviously inexperienced coaching team in the first place. Twice.


There’s only one thing for it. TB has made it clear he’s still keen. Sign him up for 2028 now. Don’t bloody wait.


Appoint JJ, and send an SOS to Wayne Smith to fill in for TB. Assuming they haven’t damaged that relationship too much as well. It sounds like the latest saga well and truly blindsided him.


Over to you NZR, the fan base, and no doubt your commercial partners, are watching for you to take some decisive action this time.

J
JW 46 days ago

TB was ready and willing to join the AB setup for two consecutive tenures. But NZR fluffed around with competitive processes and corporate waffle, with their dithering resulting in weak coaching teams being appointed each time.

Not really. First, I suspect TB dropped down the pecking order after his failure at the the Highlanders. Second, they wanted a world wide search, and as we can expect again now, that is probably going to take a few months. TB made himself unavailable (JJ couldn’t stall for the Japan job anylonger) in 2019, and was also unavailable when Razor had his team lined up in 2022.


Trying to think anything else about last minute change of hearts etc is just fairytale searching. I didn’t hear anything going on that (well we went on a bit in 2019 about the delay) that things shouldn’t have been done any different at the timel.

r
rs 46 days ago

Also seems like Robertson didn’t want him. He seems to be a little controlling, or at least Hansen his main deputy. Under this group, I don’t think Tony Brown would’ve got the freedom he gets at SA. Perhaps why so many of Razor’s coaches left mid-term or before

T
TokoRFC 46 days ago

Egg on NZRs face.


If no-one even called him then he has reason to be frustrated. Now we all want him after his new team has pantsed us, looks a bit silly doesn’t it…

J
JW 46 days ago

Not even a curtesy call or anything, part of multiple teams over the seasons and leaves NZR with egg on their face as far as concerns there statements about searching far and wide.


Yes funny how he’s receiving calls now (not trying to crap on Razor, he had to do it).

J
Jean Joubert 46 days ago

It is expected that Tony would like to coach the ABs he wore the jersey with pride and will do the same as the coach.


His a true rugby man and this is how LEGENDS are made!!!!

H
Hammer Head 47 days ago

While Tony learns from Rassie, Rassie learns from Tony. Nice one!


Tony winning a WC with SA will be the highlight of his career before and after joining the ABs.


As we speak Rassie is already working on his coaching ticket to 2031 which may or may not include Tony, but will include any attack coach from anywhere in the world.


NZ, take notes on how it’s done.

P
PB 46 days ago

I would rope Franco Smith in. They share similar rugby philosophies and Franco can be groomed to take over after 2031


I know everyone goes on about Stick and Davids, both of which have a smidgen of Franco’s experience and expertise

j
johnz 46 days ago

As Rassie works on his 2031 coaching plans, NZ don’t even have a plan for 2027. Two unions in very different places.

H
Hammer Head 47 days ago

I rest my case.

J
JW 47 days ago

As I have said numerous times, this goes back to the players in 2022 who campaigned to keep Foster. Has Razors team been put together then, as the should have, he would have been a lot further ahead in this cycle than he was.

H
Hammer Head 46 days ago

Agreed

S
SB 47 days ago

NZR paying for their decision making yet again.

p
pc 47 days ago

All in hindsight. Razor had the better super rugby credentials. He knew the core players so they would have been backing him too.

My plan is let England topple SA to avoid their 3 peat and then the Jamie and Tony show takes over. SA won’t repeat their 23 effort. They have to beat nz, France and then England. They scrapped in by 3 points over 3 games. Their luck is done

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close
ADVERTISEMENT