Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Scotland heartbreak as DMac saves day for shaky All Blacks

By PA
New Zealand's Damian McKenzie (C) celebrates scoring a try during the Autumn Nations Series international rugby union match between Scotland and New Zealand at Murrayfield in Edinburgh on November 8, 2025. (Photo by ANDY BUCHANAN / AFP) (Photo by ANDY BUCHANAN/AFP via Getty Images)

Scotland’s search for a first-ever win over New Zealand continues after their spirited second-half fightback ultimately proved fruitless in a 25-17 defeat at Murrayfield.

ADVERTISEMENT

Gregor Townsend’s side went in 17-0 down at the break despite being twice held up over the line.

The Scots roared back to make it 17-17 by the hour mark after tries from Ewan Ashman and Kyle Steyn, and they looked the likelier winners as the match moved into the fourth quarter.

But the All Blacks – who had three players yellow-carded – regained their composure in the closing stages, with a try and a long-range penalty from substitute Damian McKenzie taking the game away from the hosts, who have now failed to win this fixture in 33 attempts over 120 years.

The visitors silenced the home support by taking the lead within three minutes. Second-rower Josh Lord produced a magnificent one-handed pick and go off the back of a ruck on the halfway line and drove forward before releasing Cam Roigard through a gap to score on the left. Beauden Barrett duly converted.

<a href=
Scotland All Blacks” width=”1920″ height=”1205″ /> Will Jordan celebrates his try – PA

The Scots responded strongly and asked questions of their visitors without showing the conviction to get themselves on the scoreboard.

Shortly after Scotland wing Darcy Graham was held up over the line by some brilliant All Blacks defending, the visitors stretched their advantage to 10 points with a close-range penalty from Barrett in the 29th minute.

The hosts were given an opportunity to crank up the pressure when All Blacks wing Leroy Carter was sin-binned in the 33rd minute for cynically tripping Graham as he hacked through to try to get on the end of his own kick.

ADVERTISEMENT

But the Scots failed to make the numerical advantage count. After Rory Hutchinson became the second Scottish player to be held up over the line, the Kiwis increased their lead to 17 points in the last action of the half when Will Jordan finished on the left after being set up by Wallace Sititi, with Barrett kicking the conversion.

The Scots started the second half strongly, however. Hooker Ashman scored off the back of a lineout maul in the 46th minute, with Finn Russell adding the extras.

The resurgent hosts were further buoyed by the sight of All Blacks captain Ardie Savea being yellow-carded for trying to pull the maul down.

Scotland All Blacks
Scotland strike through Kyle Steyn – PA
ADVERTISEMENT

This time the Scots made the extra man count as Steyn bounded over on the left after being set up by Blair Kinghorn’s pass in the 51st minute. Russell was again on point with the conversion.

The Scots’ tails were up and they looked set to go ahead in the 56th minute, only for Roigard to make a brilliant tackle to stop Graham grounding the ball on the right.

Russell then levelled a pulsating encounter with a penalty on the hour mark, setting up a grandstand finale. It looked like the pendulum was swinging in the Scots’ favour, particularly when Sititi became the third New Zealand player to be yellow-carded for a deliberate knock-on in the 61st minute.

But the visitors weathered the Scottish storm and got their noses back in front in the 73rd minute when McKenzie produced a brilliant finish on the left.

The try-scorer slightly blotted his copy-book by making a mess of his conversion attempt, but he made no mistake six minutes later when launching a penalty from 45 metres between the posts to put the outcome beyond doubt.

Related

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

16 Comments
M
Mike Gibson 35 days ago

Just some context. If Scotland had prevailed it would have likely meant a straight shoot out next Sunday with Argentina for a top 6 and #1 RWC seeding

R
RV 36 days ago

So Japan v Ireland- no try.

New Zealand v Scotland- try.

Exactly the same ruck situation.

Which TMO was correct?

J
JW 35 days ago

Did they have something behind the ball in the first game?

c
cw 36 days ago

Scots play a great brand of rugby and showed what they are capable of. 17 second half points against an AB team on the rise reflects great intensity and good structure. Have them beating both Ireland and England on what I have seen this autumn (including Englands win over Fiji - which was flattering). Have not seen France or Italy yet but this Scots team is looking good after just two games.

J
JJ 36 days ago

I think its a first win for us under an old foe ref. No wonder he’s regarded by Rassie as one of the poorest.

O
Over the sideline 35 days ago

Nic Berry loves showing NZ that he is in charge and he doesn't like NZ. A garranteed card every game.

P
PickOllieMathisYeowRazorYouCoward 36 days ago

ABs results aside I’ve always liked Nic Berry, let’s the game flow a lot more than others.

E
Ed the Duck 36 days ago

Nic berry, he’s right up there with some of the very best in the business like Brousett…🤪🤣

H
Hammer Head 36 days ago

My unmentionables live another day

E
Ed the Duck 36 days ago

Good day for you all round really H, hopefully the missus enjoyed it too and your night is still young…

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close
ADVERTISEMENT