Northern | US

'Not the greatest decision': Rennie weighs in on Luke Jacobson's yellow card

Luke Jacobson of New Zealand and his teammates looks dejected during the Nations Championship match between New Zealand All Blacks and Ireland at Eden Park on July 18, 2026 in Auckland, New Zealand. (Photo by Joe Allison - Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images)
Comments
10 Comments

The All Blacks had the foot on the throttle against Ireland early with a 14-0 lead and were searching for more before a dangerous cleanout by Luke Jacobson turned the momentum at Eden Park.

ADVERTISEMENT

With Ireland camped on their own goal line and the All Blacks holding a penalty advantage, the openside flanker got a low cleanout wrong, colliding with his opposite Josh van der Flier too high with his shoulder cocked.

The incident was picked up by the TMO, reversing a penalty to the All Blacks with the chance to go up 21-0 begging, while Jacobson was sent to the bin.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

Dave Rennie refrained from labelling the clean out a “brain explosion” but conceded that his No.7 got it wrong at a key moment.

“Oh, not a brain explosion,” Rennie told media post-match.

“It’s probably not the greatest decision. I mean, there’s a threat over the ball, and he’s got to try and clean them out. He hasn’t quite got that right, so yeah.

“And obviously we had a penalty. I think score was the score then 14 nil, wasn’t it? So we’re in a position to maybe add to that, and unfortunately, yeah, that happens.

“So it’s look, he’s just got to be technically better in those situations.”

The incident was reviewed by the foul play review committee for a potential red card offence, but the yellow card stood and Jacobson was able to return to the field after 10 minutes.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ireland head coach Andy Farrell remained coy on the issue, preferring to bypass talk of the decision to not upgrade to a red card.

“There’s incidents all over the field tonight that you could talk about and we’re not able to do that, so I’ll pass on that one,” he said.

Ireland captain Dan Sheehan revealed he protested the call not to send centre Quinn Tupaea to the bin after an attempted one-handed intercept. Tupaea knocked the ball backward with one hand, attempting to catch it with both before it bounced off his head forwards.

“It was tricky at the time to see it. You’re watching the big screen like everyone else. There’s not much I can do,” he said.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I’m trying to make sure I put the question to the ref at the right times. I felt like I was there in the conversations a good bit. I’m just a player on the pitch. I have to try to highlight these issues. There’s not much I can do other than that.”

In the end Farrell conceded his team was below the standard they strive for, with a host of errors from halfback Jamison Gibson-Park and flyhalf Sam Prendergast contributing to an uncharacteristic performance from Ireland.

“It wasn’t just the wrong side of the result – they won pretty comfortably in the end,” he said.

“I suppose the overriding feeling is we’ve got to use it in the right manner for what’s happening in the next 15 months.

“If you look back on it, some of our best ballplayers [had errors], that’s why I say uncharacteristic really because it’s something you don’t see on a daily basis or on a weekend either. But that’s what big matches do to you and that’s a lesson that’s got to be learned, that’s for sure.”

 

Register your interest to receive priority updates on RWC27 ticket releases. Don't miss out, stay in the loop!


ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

10 Comments
B
BH 29 days ago

There was clear mitigation, so the yellow card was the correct call.


O’Brien was lucky not to get yellow carded for tackling Love mid-air, and same with Prendergast with a blatant knock-down in front of his posts.


It’s all fish and chips paper now! NZ dominated the game and deserved to win.

M
Max Imus 29 days ago

No mitigation, dived in like a spear and made direct contact with the head. As usual nz get all the breaks from the sycophantic officials. So a win is guaranteed and their fans don’t consider the reality. A correct red card there and a yellow for the ridiculous dive towards the ball would have made a difference to the scoreline, but the nz fans bury their heads in the sand and refuse to see what's clear and obvious. Which is why this comment section is full of people denying reality. Wake up and be honest. You're only fooling yourselves.

P
PL 30 days ago

Looked from the replays like he actually made contact with VDF’s head with his upper arm, not his shoulder. I think a yellow was sufficient penalty. I agree they need to keep working to eradicate shoulder hits to people's heads but didn't look in this case like that was what happened

u
unknown 30 days ago

Dan Sheehan obviously didn’t do ‘all he could’. He could’ve concentrated on playing rugby instead of griping and whining to the referee. That might have helped your team a bit more Dan !

B
B 30 days ago

Jacobsons clean out was lacking in the thinking department…

The height and position of Van der Flier's body was clear that he wasn't supporting his body weight and was leaning on top of the ruck with no rights to the ball…

After Luke clipped him, Josh put on a Hollywood act to indicate the head contact…PUSSY…

Cam Roigard coped an Italian head butt, no Hollywood act and played on…that’s what being an All Black is all about…Legend…

P
PickOllieMathisOrKeepLosing,Rob. 30 days ago

I thought he was getting red for sure.

M
Mzilikazi 30 days ago

Jacobson was lucky enough there not to have the YC upgraded. It was a wild dive in over the breakdown.


I did think at the time, seeing the replays, that it would remain a YC as the force of the hit was not very hard, and VDF was not required to go off for an HIA. But so often that kind of incident does result in a 20 min RC.

H
Hammer Head 30 days ago

I feel like it’s a slippery slope if we factor in how hard the hit was and whether or not the player on the receiving end had an HIA.


Even this call. A straight shoulder to a head should be a red if we’re really serious about protecting players brains.

S
Superignazzio 30 days ago

Coaches talking about the ref? watch out guys! ah wait

they speak english 😂

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close