Northern | US

Nienaber explains his latest Bok replacements bench surprise


South Africa's Faf de Klerk at the 2023 Rugby World Cup in France (Photo by Christian Liewig/Corbis via Getty Images)
Comments
6 Comments

South Africa head coach Jacques Nianaber has explained an apparent return to normality on the Springboks replacement bench for their Rugby World Cup quarter-final with France on Sunday, as the 7-1 split experiment gets shelved – for the time being at least.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Boks have gone for a traditional 5-3 split instead of the more unorthodox 6-2 and 7-1 split that they’ve been using of late.

Nienaber didn’t expand too much on his thinking, despite being quizzed on the arrangement at a Springboks press conference in Paris.

Video Spacer

The Big Jim Show Live – RWC Semi Finals

Join Big Jim & special guests for the special live shows before and after each Semi Final live on Rugbypass TV

Watch Free

Video Spacer

The Big Jim Show Live – RWC Semi Finals

Join Big Jim & special guests for the special live shows before and after each Semi Final live on Rugbypass TV

Watch Free

“If it’s 8-0, 7-1, 6-2, 5-3, it falls under team selection. We have selected a team, irrespective of the bench, that we think will give us the best opportunity of a victory on Sunday,” said Nienaber, who has chosen to bench Faf de Klerk in favour of Cobus Reinach, who starts at scrumhalf.

“If we select Cobus [Reinach] or Faf [de Klerk], I don’t think there would be a lot of raised eyebrows. France have got a very interesting kicking game and we feel using those two guys will give us the best opportunity. For this specific game, we feel Duane [Vermeulen] is the guy we will need, but that doesn’t mean Jasper [Wiese] won’t play in the semi-final. It is based on what we feel we need to get a victory on Sunday.

“If you look at a guy like Cobus, he is playing exceptional rugby, and Faf for that matter. It’s the same with Manie [Libbok]. Handre [Pollard] is a bit different, when you look at the cumulative number of minutes he has played for us this year. It is probably one game altogether, so he is slowly building up his minutes. And Manie is probably our in-form fly-half. I think we have lost one game this year when he has started at 10. The team performs when he starts at 10, it is as simple as that.

“The whole team selection was quite tough. If you look at the squad and the way we have managed the load over the last few games and the 10 tests we have played this season, the majority of our group has had between four and six games of exposure. The World Cup is spread over two months so we need to manage the squad so they go into knockout stages as fresh as possible.

ADVERTISEMENT

“The beauty of our squad is we had the ability to rotate and rest and manage their load. Hopefully that will carry us through. Lukhanyo [Am] has not had much exposure because of his injury, but he looks good in training. It’s the same with Jasper [Wiese], there is no reason why they might not get selected in a semi-final. We believe we have a team to match the strengths and expose the weaknesses of France, although there are not a lot of weaknesses there.

“I know Handre came back and kicked 100% in the last game, but I think Manie did too. Any player can have an off day but when you play knockout games, you are not going to get many opportunities. So when we get them, we must use them.

“Since we started in 2020, our aim was to win the World Cup. Otherwise, why are you in it? Our aim was always to do that. Since the draw was made, we knew the quarter-final would probably boil down to France or New Zealand. It didn’t matter which team we played. It will be a tough quarter-final, the same with Ireland and New Zealand. I think all the quarter-finals will be really close. All the teams are preparing to be in the semi-finals and we go on from there.”

View the team in the link below:

Related

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

6 Comments
Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

T
TL 1 hour ago
Joe Schmidt bows out on a high - but can the Wallabies escape 'the twilight zone'?

It’s hard to see how any coach could have done much better and that coaches can only shift the dial so much in Australia, we’ve had some of the best in the world and the trajectory has been the same. The win/loss record is obviously an important metric, but it is only one metric, and not necessarily the best to assess a team that is really still in a building phase (2024 was recovery!). You could look at something like average losing margin, and the trajectory there is much better, with the 2025/2026 results close to half the losing margin in 2024 and during Eddie’s reign (roughly 10, compared to closer to 20). Much has been made of the so called merry-go-round at 10 (really sick of that phrase but here I am using it), but losing Noah, Lygnah and Dono between Fiji and SA games in 2025, and Carter then Dono in 2026 had nothing to do with Joe. He consistently backed his first choices and backed youth at 10 when he could. The injuries led to a massive increase in uncertainty around whether to risk players who weren’t ready or back experience but lose the future benefit. In that situation I think we need to permit our coaches a greater degree of experimentation and error. Much has been made of the LSL situation, but what about how Joe’s selections at lock have led to some real depth of capability there, with players that weren’t as conspicuously impressive (e.g. Williams, Canham). Joe has made his mistakes, but he righted the trend that was heading sharply down, and I suspect that as with what he left in Ireland and as with Stuart Lancaster your old mate, the true test of his time will be what happens in the wake.

245 Go to comments
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close