Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'I won't repeat your word': Andy Farrell defends Ireland after defeat to Boks

By Ian Cameron at Aviva Stadium, Dublin
Ireland head coach Andy Farrell before the Quilter Nations Series 2025 match between Ireland and South Africa at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin. (Photo By Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile via Getty Images)

Ireland head coach Andy Farrell has defended his players after their “chaotic” 24-13 Quilter Nations Series defeat to South Africa at the Aviva Stadium.

ADVERTISEMENT

It was the Boks’ first win in Dublin in 13 years and one in which Ireland suffered a raft of yellow cards, at one point being reduced to 12 men for a short period.

It was a match in which Ireland struggled to gain a foothold, largely down indiscipline, a faltering scrum and a shaky lineout.

VIDEO

However, they fought back bravely in the second half, with a number of rearguard defensive efforts repelling South African attacks from their try line in a second forty which Ireland won 6-5 on the scoreboard.

When it was suggested to Farrell that it was a “shambolic” performance from the home side, he bristled.

Points Flow Chart

South Africa win +11
Time in lead
0
Mins in lead
80
0%
% Of Game In Lead
96%
78%
Possession Last 10 min
22%
0
Points Last 10 min
0

“I’d say chaotic. I won’t repeat your word, because I think you’re wrong,” said Farrell. “I’ve never seen a game like that, ever.

“I suppose, first and foremost, you need to look at yourself and why it’s happened. We’ll do that and make sure we learn the lessons from that.

ADVERTISEMENT

“My overriding thoughts on it are that I’m unbelievably proud and for you to start the conversation off like that doesn’t sit well.”

Farrell believes Ireland can take a lot from the defeat, which ended a long run of home wins for the men in green.

“If you can’t learn from that [defeat], you’re in the wrong place really.

“Going down to 12 men, how the lads came out and showed the bottle for their country. Certainly the first ten minutes of the second half was amazing, and you could see from the crowd, the amount of effort they put in, the crowd recognised that and supported them.”

Farrell implied he felt the scrums – an area in which the Boks enjoyed near total domination – could have been refereed better.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Obviously, you can talk about all sorts of stuff that you’ve talked to the referees beforehand during the week and say those are the same type of pictures etc. But you’ve got to look at yourself first.

“You’ve got to give the referee the access to see you in whatever type of light that he was, obviously, seeing us in. And he saw a dominant scrum. And whether there’s illegalities within all that, we’ve got to see past that and be better than that.”

Due to a multitude of cards, Ireland were forced to mix and match players’ positions. Replacement fly-half Jack Crowley played much of the match in the back three, while centre Bundee Aki was at one stage packed down in the back row.

“People are covering obviously two, three positions. Different positions in attack and different positions in defence, so you’re just trying to get a bit of order and let the lads understand who’s coming back at what time and how we need to manage the game in that period.

“To be able to win a second half 6-5 under those circumstances, I know it doesn’t tell a full story of the second half, but it’s actually amazing, really, that that happened, or that occurred.

“The lessons to learn are, when you fight so hard to give yourself a chance, and you’re at 72 minutes, trying to overplay probably in your own 22, you’ve still got time on the clock to put ourselves back in the right field positions.”

Related


To be first in line for Rugby World Cup 2027 Australia tickets, register your interest here 

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

104 Comments
S
SR 19 days ago

Ooo! Andy, that's not like you. Ireland losing must be getting to him which is a shame as he’s had a great run since being stupidly sacked by England.

D
DS 19 days ago

“Farrell implied he felt the scrums – an area in which the Boks enjoyed near total domination – could have been refereed better.”


Nope, as Nick Mallett said afterwards while Carley had a reasonable game, he chickened out in the second half and let the Irish get away with a hell of a lot, and there could have been even more yellow cards for their fouling near their tryline - and I reckon a couple more penalty tries.


I also wonder what the clowns at WR are going to attempt to negate the amazing power of the Bok scrum - cancel the set pieces?

M
Mike Gibson 20 days ago

A scrum is supposed to be a mechanism to restart the match. In theory a dominant team can use the scrum/penalty/scrum/penalty/scrum loophole to spend an entire half of rugby scrummaging with no restart.

A penalty is plenty of reward for winning a scrum. There should be no option to scrummage again when the intention is clearly not to restart the match.

F
FH 20 days ago

I take it your team don’t have a proper scrum….. 😃

P
PMcD 20 days ago

Well done SA, you beat the best of the Southern Hemisphere in The Rugby Championship and then came to the Northern Hemisphere and beat them all as well.


Well done - best team in the world by some margin. 👏👏👏

P
PMcD 20 days ago

Well, for all those people that were writing off the SB’s before The Rugby Championship as past it, too old and waining . . . . I think you may need to wait a little while longer.


Rassie has evolved the squad, proven they are the best in the world by some margin and I actually think this is potentially his best team ever. What a job this year! 👏👏👏

P
PMcD 20 days ago

Look, for SA to come over here and beat the quality of teams they have in continuous AWAY fixtures, is incredibly impressive and very rare.


It’s actually better than a GRAND SLAM, as they are doing it all on the road and they have been convincing winners in each game.


They control the game through the forwards and they have the backs to light up the game when they are given a chance.


All this tour has done is proven how much better they are than anyone else. This current SB team are shaping up to be very, very special and will be very hard to beat.


I think teams have to go 7|1 against them to give them a chance and if I was someone like SCO or WAL, I’d even consider going 8|0 bench strength to give you a chance. For a one off game, it’s probably worth the risk.

S
SR 19 days ago

No one denies that SA are a superbly coached, highly skilful team and should triumph in 2027 so a siege mentality is hardly appropriate. We get it….you’re good.

M
Mike Gibson 20 days ago

The option to call a scrum from a penalty needs to be removed. Otherwise a dominant scrum can win a match from one knock on or penalty by looping the scrum indefininately and eliciting yellows.


The scrum is to restart the match. The scrum half is clearly making no effort to restart the match. A penalty is an adequate reward and a mechanism for restarting itself.


There should be no option to choose a scrum when awarded a penalty.

M
Matt Perry 17 days ago

A dominant [insert any aspect of the game here] can win the game. That’s how the game works. The fact that the IRFU has never prioritised scrummaging is not the fault of the laws.


What I do think is that yellow cards for scrum offences are a bit silly. You shouldn’t be able to get sent off for just being crap at your job. Instead of a yellow, simply move the scrum 10 metres up the field. If you’re within 10 metres of the line and infringe at the scrum, penalty try.

S
SR 19 days ago

Unless your team has the dominant scrum of course. Mike, this smells of sour grapes.

F
FH 20 days ago

So Mike, if Ireland did not infringe SA would have scored a pushover try……but people whos teams do not have a proper scrum don't get that…do you?

u
unknown 20 days ago

A comment from the fan of a team with a weak scrum….that was totally dominated…nobody cares what you think….go and play league!

D
D 20 days ago

Ireland have been cheating in the scrum for YEARS, with the loosehead aiming for the opposition hooker. It's about time they were penalised for it, Farrell is insulting rugby fans by claiming otherwise.

M
Matt Perry 17 days ago

Not sure I agree with the “it’s about time” when the main thing I think of re: Porter’s scrummaging is “penalty machine”. It cost them the 2023 RWC QF and has cost them other games, too. He and Furlong are valued for their play in the loose and scrums have never been a huge priority for Ireland.

F
FH 20 days ago

@andyfarryl. I have more respect for the Irish team than I have ever had as a South African. The fight the showed was impressive. Massive respect for that. But you complaining that the Boks scrum was illegal….what a joke you are. 3 of the 4 nominees in World rugby’s player of the year comes out of South Africa’s pack. Man up man. There was 11kg’s difference between the packs. Maybe it's time you find someone who can work on their technique.

J
JW 20 days ago

50kgs between the two packs. What made you think 11?

J
JW 20 days ago

What a contest, man you gotta love the Irish attitude to struggle vainly, they fought like they were really in that match all game, and the crowd gave them every chance.


The other two games were great as well, good to see that 6N fire come out against the South, can say I’ve ever felt such optimism as a group before on these tours. Lets hope they can keep that fire in the belly despite the scorelines because it made for great viewing.


Note to the Welsh while I’m here too, you could see that was group of players that knew how to player rugby like the best of them, not a whole lot of talent on show but made up for it in attitude and understanding.

U
Uncle D 20 days ago

Well we have quitend France and Ireland now just to put arrogant England and windgat Pollock their place,and teach them some respect

S
SR 19 days ago

Don’t think that England have been especially arrogant. Very pleased to remain unbeaten…just…what's wrong with that? Presume that windgat is an insult?

D
Divan Joubert 20 days ago

Carley allowed Irish negative play for far too long at the goal line before reaching for his pocket. If it were the Boks who offended, well they would have been punished immediately by the AR's and the Ref. Always been this way.Just another observation, Irish were very slow to get off the deck after a breakdown obstructing the Boks no 9 and 10 to distribute the ball quickly and effectively and nothing was said or done about it. The 20 min red card, definitely a permanent red card violation by the Irish tackler.

u
unknown 20 days ago

Despite all the talk of Irish grit it’s clear they played a deeply cynical & indisciplined game. Anti-rugby. The scoreboard flattered Ireland. 4 tries to 1. Enough said.

J
JW 20 days ago

Yeah it really hindered there performance, need to try and cut it out. The block of chasers and not bringing people off the field for head checks was shocking.

E
Ed the Duck 20 days ago

All the hallmarks of an Ireland team that wanted it so desperately they would go to almost any lengths but didn’t have the ability to deliver it.

P
PMcD 20 days ago

Good post ED - in truth they were just well beaten.

P
PickOllieMathisYeowRazorYouCoward 20 days ago

Wtf did I just watch???

J
JW 20 days ago

Mark Hunt vs Brock Lesnar?

u
unknown 20 days ago

Great escape for Ireland to lose by only 11.

Completely dominated by the Boks and, if there ever was a permanent red card, Ryan should have been given it. He is an inveterate cheat and foul player. Broke Malcolm Marx’s leg last year with his famous “croc tackle”. What a tool

D
DC 19 days ago

Would you like to cry a bit more, lad. Go get yourself a tissue and head back to the soccer pitch. A game more your intellect level undoubtedly

P
Phaladi 20 days ago

100%!

IIreland spoiled the game by resorting to dirty play, so they can have excuses. It is a game they knew they were going to lose fair and square, and they therefore deliberately tampered with its integrity. Probably by instruction. You can tell from Farrel's (thinly-veilled) sour utterances. If he cannot be sportsmanly, what should we expect from his players. They are just Green with envy

J
JW 20 days ago

@Bull Shark thoughts??

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close
ADVERTISEMENT