Northern | US

Selections aside, Dave Rennie is pushing the right buttons with All Blacks

WELLINGTON, NEW ZEALAND - JUNE 22: Coach Dave Rennie speaks to media during the New Zealand All Blacks Squad Announcement at Feilding Yellows Rugby Club on June 22, 2026 in Feilding, New Zealand. (Photo by Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images)
Comments
54 Comments

The All Blacks’ 1987 Rugby World Cup-winning squad consisted of 26 players.

ADVERTISEMENT

It’s hard not to think of that when you see an initial squad of 34 picked to play the first three Tests of this season and contemplate that 44 players will then tour South Africa.

Everyone wants winners and losers out of any team naming. Frankly, when the net’s cast this wide, those kinds of categories are redundant.

VIDEO

Forty-five men played Test rugby for New Zealand in 2025. So, if you missed the 34 to play France, Italy and Ireland, there’s every chance you’ll be in the 44 that goes to South Africa.

Throw in the guys currently unavailable due to injury, and the others who’ll inevitably get hurt during the 2026 campaign, and as many as 50 blokes will probably pull the jumper on this year.

That’s a lot of All Blacks.

New players are always exciting. I feel for Anton Segner, who potentially won’t play a lot and whose greatest moment in rugby is having the shine taken off it due to the unnecessary disquiet about Du’Plessis Kirifi’s omission.

Xavier Numia is a very admirable player, but could be a bit of a placeholder while Tamaiti Williams recovers from his back issue. And then there’s the wings.

ADVERTISEMENT

Fehi Fineanganogo and Josh Moorby are worthy of their selections, but the All Blacks haven’t been average in recent seasons because there’s been no one to play on the wing. I hope all the new boys go well, but I doubt any are going to make a material difference to the team’s fortunes.

Making Ardie Savea captain might, as could giving Rieko Ioane a spell.

Savea’s started to resemble a guy that you need inside the tent. He gave the distinct impression of not enjoying being an All Black under the previous coaching regime, and I imagine he’s a man whose opinions and actions influence others.

He wouldn’t be captain now if they didn’t.

It will help the harmony of the team if Savea is fully invested in the cause.

ADVERTISEMENT

Related

As for Ioane, I assume we haven’t seen the last of him. But his temporary exclusion is overdue on a couple of fronts.

People can’t be picked on reputation or past deeds forever. Ioane has been an ineffective All Black for some time, and it’s right that he’s been left out.

More broadly, though, this is a lesson for others. If a big player, a name player and an experienced and feted player such as Ioane can be surplus to requirements, then you can too.

I hope some other stalwarts of the All Black backline recognise they don’t belong as of right either.

You want players to feel a sense of belonging within the team, but never to lose the fear that they’re only ever a couple of bad games away from being dropped. There’s been too few consequences for underwhelming performances in recent seasons.

Every team looks all right on paper, and this 34-man squad is no exception, but its performances that matter.

That said, I continue to be encouraged by what I’m seeing and hearing. Head coach Dave Rennie cut a commanding figure at Monday’s team announcement and combated questions with ease.

There’s sound reasoning to who’s in the squad and who’s not. It’s obvious that he knows how he wants the team to play and which players he believes are capable of achieving it.

Whether they’re in the squad or out of it, no player will be left confused about what his job is or where he stands. The communication is clear and concise and should inspire confidence from everyone.

We can talk about winners and losers once we’ve seen how Rennie’s team goes at next year’s World Cup.

RugbyPass App Download

News, stats, live rugby and more! Download the new RugbyPass app on the App Store (iOS) and Google Play (Android) now!


Whether you’re looking for somewhere to track upcoming fixtures, a place to watch live rugby or an app that shows you all of the latest news and analysis, the RugbyPass rugby app is perfect.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

54 Comments
J
JW 40 days ago

I was just referencing Rassies struggles last year, going expansive then losing to Aussie and going back to traditional strengths before unleashing again against the ABs, then also havening to tussle it out with France etc.


The England games would be a very interesting case, even with Beauden last years team went up by two scores before the injuries. That first game was two scores total, and that was with Dmac who credited with providing much momentum.

E
Emery 43 days ago

Think it’s a good solid team to start, he can give debutants a go around experienced players, those older out of form can gradually hand that jersey to the form players over the next few weeks.

Rennie will give a more clear game plan to run and alternatives compared to Razors “get the ball and play what’s in front of you”

B
Blackmania 44 days ago

We’re now eagerly waiting for the first team sheet. I can imagine a surprise inclusion of Anton Lienert-Brown. Nothing suggests that Rennie sees Tupaea as a No. 13. Razor did, but that doesn’t necessarily mean Rennie will. In any case, I see ALB at the very least making the bench.

With so few days to prepare for this match, Rennie will likely focus on selecting players who are familiar with each other from their clubs, alongside experienced players.

Perhaps a backline of Fineanganofo, J. Barrett, Lienert-Brown, Moorby, and Jordan or DMK.

J
JB 44 days ago

Bidwell says “People can’t be picked on reputation or past deeds forever”. That is exactly how BB has been selected for a number of years.

J
James P 43 days ago

I don’t think BB was selected on reputation. If Jordan gets injured, who plays FB? Having only 3 players (i.e., DMac, Love, Jordan) covering 10 and 15 is way too light. Can’t think of anyone better, and with the experience, who can slot in.

The interesting selection will occur when Mo'unga becomes available.

What a great headache to have, lol

B
Bazzallina 44 days ago

When I take the pulse of the nation and the comments section popular opinion in my opinion with Dupes aside from the versatility stuff it’s a Luke J selection not a Segner one

J
JW 44 days ago

Sorry what’s a LJ selection Baz?

J
James P 44 days ago

What I like is, I believe Rens has the ability to see the big picture, execute the details at the micro level and then throw in a “think outside the box” - new perspective.

E.g., Ted as a selector, Steven Adams as a contributor on Captaincy Leadership, and implementing the best game plan based on our available player base and strengths.

And how good would it be to have Brodie in the selection mix - depending on form, for the RWC 2027? He would be the only coach to be able to get Brodie to lace up again.

J
JW 44 days ago

Yes you have to think theres going to be more involvement in the detail from him, and that this increases cohesion and attitude.


Not quite sold on the big picture vs Razors, though like the start, personally. I get a feeling Rennie is far less likely to change his big picture too, unlike Razor, he really has to stick to his guns and back himself with such a short turnaround anyway.


How good.

G
GodOfFriedChicken 44 days ago

Hard to properly judge till they’re on the field, but other than Dups (which is more of a positional issue) and maybe Hotham, doesn’t feel like as many controversial omissions. Do agree with ALB and Beaudy being controversial, though from what little I’ve managed to see online, ALB looked good in Japan. Beauden I’m assuming is there for versatility’s sake and while his form fell off a cliff in the second half of the season, I’m wondering if a more open game plan than what he had under Razor and Cotter would help him get back to what he’s good at.


Given the thing that sold NZR on Rennie was that he apparently presented something like 100 video clips explaining how he would’ve fixed last year’s All Blacks, be interesting to see just how different they are in 2026 to the last two years.

J
JW 44 days ago

Really did he lol I’d love to see a debate panel with him presenting those as a valid job application creditials and the AB coaching panel on the rebuttal panel. That would be jizz worthy.

B
Blackmania 44 days ago

Yes, Rennie is doing things the right way. His communication is clear. Now we need to see this first squad and this first game.

And whatever the result, we shouldn’t draw too many conclusions after only 8 days of training. We’ll assess everything at the end of the season.

J
JW 44 days ago

His communication is clear

Clearly BS?

C
Cantab 45 days ago

This initial squad is not the finished article but merely the interim pending the recovery of several currently injured players and the return of overseas players. Rennie has named the best squad he could and there are players within that are on trial and may or may not be successful in the final analysis. There is of course always the spectre of future injuries to consider as well.

G
GM 44 days ago

Agreed - France and Ireland’s packs will be a tough ask without Tamaiti, Scooter and Fabian. That’s a lot of muscle, experience and resilience right there.

K
Karlos G 45 days ago

Beauden Barrett belongs as of right, years of sub par performances and he still gets picked - NZ Rugby royalty!

S
Skinny Pins 45 days ago

Rennie is a likeable guy, but so far it's all the same as Razor and Foster before that. Same nucleus of players, same “be fit, play fast" rhetoric. So let's see. Surprised Hamish, who has been around a while, is getting all giddy about Rennie. Rennie looks so far like Razor 2.0, which, after all, was just Foster 2.0.

d
d 45 days ago

While I agree that its too early to name Rennie the new messiah, I can’t agree that he is the same as Razor. Rennie already has a vision that he articulates clearly; we never got that from Razor. Whether he has the skills to impose this “NZ” style of rugby on some tough opposition, we will find out pretty quickly.

J
JW 45 days ago

It’s hard not to think of that when you see an initial squad of 34 picked to play the first three Tests of this season and contemplate that 44 players will then tour South Africa.

No.


No. It’s hard to think about a smaller squad. It’s hard not to think that the biggest naming day of the year, the equivalent of footballs closing transfer window day, or the NFL draft day, should be more than 34 players. It should contain ALL the players that the All Blacks will use through the int season. Combine all the excitement of the squad namings from all 3 int windows into one. Give it time to cook and actually consider whats happened in the Finals series. Then create a new method of selecting a small match week squad (when at home).


Rassies 3 test July squad was 46.

B
Bazzallina 44 days ago

Chur to that JW

D
DH 45 days ago

Well…I suppose that our country being only about 4 million population combatants…whole population..

Reckon we'll come out o.k…

Wee will c

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

U
Utiku Old Boy 58 minutes ago
All Blacks dig deep to deny Stormers in ill-disciplined RGR opener

Good perspective Graham. That is the value of this tour for this AB touring group. Being exposed to the traditional SA style of aggressive, skilled big men who can dominate the set piece - and now adding an attacking dimension through the Rassie/Brown influence. IF Rennie can get the ABs playing their historical game, or at least growing back into it, he/they cannot ignore having to deal with a highly efficient and dominant set-piece team who have added dimensions to their game. In the development phase, we are some distance from the Boks, but because we are trying to play our high tempo, ruthless “AB” game - as well as cope with strong opponents (SA, France, Argentina, England, Ireland) we have a lot of work-ons. What has been admirable about Rassie developing his team is his willingness to test players and systems with an occasional loss seeming to be “acceptable” as part of the process. NZ fans are not so understanding and expectations of winning - even in development - are always high. I think the “trajectory” rationale for changing our HC was necessary because the previous group with an “okay” winning percentage was not seen as AB rugby - the game plan was not integral to the NZ game. Getting that re-established - and then (like Rassie) adding dimensions to that AB game is a long process and the timelines are not favorable. The SA fan base crowing about how the ABs will get dealt with in the tests (if they play like the team facing the Stormers) might be missing the value of these games for re-establishing the AB game so they can also add to their traditional strengths the required steel and techniques to handle any opposition. The AB squad gained a lot from that exposure. Will that exposure result in a series win? Highly unlikely. But the overall project will benefit greatly.

170 Go to comments
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close