Northern | US

LONG READ Six Ireland squad takeaways - a 'specimen' and spicy competition but Munster may be miffed

Six Ireland squad takeaways - a 'specimen' and spicy competition but Munster may be miffed
3 weeks ago

Andy Farrell likes to sprinkle the occasional uncapped player into his squads. For a bit of flavour. To give them a taste of the big boy environment.

Official World Rankings in the App 📱

You can now check the official International World Rankings in the RugbyPass App!

Download Here
On Apple IOS, Android, and Tablet.

Only once in Farrell’s tenure did he go wild, calling up 11 uncapped players. For that one, back in the summer of 2021, it was because several senior stars were on British & Irish Lion duty in South Africa. For the 2022 tour to New Zealand, with five games on a tight schedule, five rookies got the call. Supporters, and media, usually get two uncapped players to focus on. Every now and then, like the summer tour, it is three.

His squad announcements are just exciting enough to get due coverage, but there is not much to extend into two- and three-day news cycles. Social media meltdowns are spared. No-one is banging tables in podcast studios. You could confidently name 27 of Farrell’s World Cup squad. The scrap for the six remaining spots is where the drama is.

‘Some specimen of a man’

Farrell named Ulster duo Jamie Benson and James McNabney in his 36-man squad, then revealed both have already been in camp, to get up to speed with plays and players. Benson, signed from Harlequins earlier this year, was brought in to train with the senior squad before summer games against Australia, Japan and New Zealand. “It was great to get to know him and see what he was all about,” said Farrell. “He has started the season really well, in a few different positions, for Ulster. That shows his versatility.”

Jamie Benson evades a tackle for Harlequins
Benson has already played at 10, 12 and 13 for Ulster and also featured at full-back for Harlequins (Photo Warren Little/Getty Images)

McNabney was set for his Ireland debut in the summer of 2025 after being named by interim head coach Paul O’Connell for the tour to Georgia and Portugal. Then only 22, McNabney suffered an anterior cruciate ligament injury and was replaced in the squad by Munster’s Brian Gleeson. The back-row, who was part of Ireland’s U20 Six Nations Grand Slam wins in 2022 and 2023, missed all of last season as he recovered and rehabbed his knee. He returned this season to start at No.8 against Edinburgh, before coming off the bench in draws with Glasgow and Munster.

Farrell confirmed McNabney, coming in at 19-stone and measuring 6ft 5in, had been invited in for an Irish alignment camp in late August. “That just goes to show that we have been interested in him for a while,” Farrell added. “He’s some specimen of a man and he certainly runs his weight. So we’re excited to have him and Jamie in.”

More fire for Munster bellies

Munster captain Tadhg Beirne hails from Eadestown, in Kildare, so Craig Casey is the province’s sole home-grown representative in Ireland’s senior squad. Jack Crowley and Calvin Nash were included in the squad announcement as injured players not considered, so there are two crumbs of comfort for the southern brethren.

Taking a closer look at the Munster squad, and Ireland’s pressing needs, a few excluded players can consider themselves hard done by. Evan O’Connell and Brian Gleeson have started this season well, and had been tipped in some quarters to get called up. Both have been in and around senior squads before, but Farrell opted for the likes of McNabney and Connacht’s Darragh Murray.

For the past decade, there has been a growing sense Munster players do not get the tight squad selection calls, and that they are under-represented… Saturday at Aviva Stadium could be very spicy.

There had been some speculation that Farrell would bring in former England tighthead, Kieran Brookes, now that he is ensconced at Munster. The 36-year-old, who won the last of his seven England caps a decade ago, has proved to be a canny signing by Munster, and has impressed at scrum time, but Ireland clearly like what they see in Sam Illo. The Connacht prop will push Tom Clarkson to back up Tadhg Furlong. Jeremy Loughman was surely in with a shout, yet Billy Bohan got the last loosehead place.

After a tough start to the season against Glasgow, there has been optimism around Munster. Following last weekend’s win over Racing, Clayton McMillan declared: “I hope what people are seeing is people that are happy to turn up to work, seeing the evolution of a clear identity around how we want to play – a team that when put under pressure is going to fight hard to win more moments than we lose.”

For the past decade, there has been a growing sense Munster players do not get the tight squad selection calls, and that they are under-represented. Last October, four Munster players were named in Ireland’s squad, and they took offence at that, beating Leinster at Croke Park three days later. This time around, with another Leinster game coming up, they have only two inclusions. Saturday at Aviva Stadium could be very spicy. Plenty of points to be proved.

Prendergast to start, but Frawley form a huge bonus

Leinster attack coach Tyler Bleyendaal flippantly suggested Sam Prendergast has not drastically changed his game, or bulked up, but instead grew his hair out. The 23-year-old has put on some timber though over the summer and is playing with a real spark.

Noticeably, he has been more of a running threat in his three games so far and is showing a willingness to get stuck into defensive duties. Farrell will be as encouraged as swathes of Leinster fans by his bright start to the season. Expect him to wear 10 against Argentina and, in all likelihood, South Africa.

Sam Prendergast evades a tackle against Clermont
Prendergast scored 16 points including a try in an impressive display for Leinster in their win at Clermont (Photo Idriss Bigou-Gilles/AFP via Getty Images)

Frawley has enjoyed a fantastic start for Connacht, playing three games in the 10 jersey, scoring four tries and picking up two man-of-the-match awards. He has 15 caps for Ireland so far and his only fly-half start was against Japan last summer. His form, and talent, certainly merit a start against Fiji. Frawley will be gunning for more than that and at 28, his time may have finally come.

One-horse race for the No.7 jersey

One of the key sub-plots of this squad announcement centres around who will compete with Josh van der Flier for the starting openside role. Farrell has looked at Caelan Doris and Nick Timoney in the 7 jersey, conscious that van der Flier is 33. The Leinster back-row missed out on Test minutes on his first ever Lions tour, in 2025, but Farrell started him in all six matches, last season, against true heavyweight nations. 

Had Doris been fit, Farrell may have been tempted to play him at openside against South Africa, with Sean Jansen No.8. As it is, Doris and Jack Conan are sidelined for the Nations Championship. Ulster’s Bryn Ward suffered a knee injury and also misses out. “It’s always going to test you when you’ve got a couple of injuries in one position,” Farrell noted. “That’s not just up to the guys that are stepping in. It’s up to the rest of the squad, to make sure that we all roll in together.”

Ryan Baird and Cian Prendergast will scrap for starting at blindside, Van der Flier gets the big outings and Sean Jansen looks set for a couple of big starts at the back of the pack.

Farrell is unlikely to rush into any other back row changes. Ryan Baird and Cian Prendergast will scrap for starting blindside, van der Flier gets the big outings and Sean Jansen looks set for a couple of big starts at the back of the pack. It was fascinating to note, however, Leinster naming Dan Sheehan in the 8 jersey for this weekend’s clash with Munster. The hooker, who will captain Ireland in November, played 15 minutes in the back row, last season, against Sale Sharks but this is a first start there in senior rugby. It remains to be seen if this is a Leinster innovation, or a Farrell nudge.

There may be a temptation to start Beirne at No.6, but Ireland are better with him in the second row, and James Ryan as impact sub.

Can McCloskey back up his best ever season?

It was interesting to note, earlier this week, that Alex Nankivell has signed up for two more seasons with Munster. Should he come through those unscathed, the New Zealander then becomes Irish qualified. Nankivell would be 32 in 2028 when, under World Rugby’s five-year residency rules, he is eligible to play for his adopted country.

We are still two years out from this possibility, but the centre is firmly on track. The latest Ireland squad contains four centres aged over 30 – Garry Ringrose (31), Robbie Henshaw (33), Stuart McCloskey (34) and Bundee Aki (36) – while the versatile Jimmy O’Brien is not far behind. They might need Nankivell yet.

Stuart McCloskey thunders into Jordie Barrett
McCloskey has established himself as a dominant presence in Ireland’s midfield over the past year
(Photo Michael Bradley/AFP via Getty Images)

McCloskey enjoyed his best ever campaign, for Ulster and Ireland, last season but finished it on the sidelines after injuring his hamstring. He looks to have usurped Aki and Henshaw and is playing with a real confidence. If he is capable of going up another level, Ireland could certainly do with it. Benson and Jamie Osborne are the younger options, but do not expect Farrell to deviate from his plans too much up to and including the World Cup.

Battle royal on the wings

Farrell rates Mack Hansen extremely high. When the Connacht winger is fit, he starts for Ireland. In his final two games of last season, back in November 2025, Hansen was selected at full-back against Australia and South Africa. He then underwent foot surgery but has returned to log three straight starts for Stuart Lancaster’s men. If he gets through Connacht’s next two games, against Zebre and Leinster, I expect him to go straight back into the Ireland XV.

I would use this opportunity to give Tommy O’Brien a long, hard look at outside centre, in at least one game.

Hugo Keenan is odds-on to start at full-back, so that leaves Jimmy O’Brien, Tommy O’Brien, Rob Baloucoune, Jacob Stockdale and possibly Osborne dicing it out for the final spot in the back three. Ireland may be short of Test-proven looseheads and No.8s, but Farrell is spoilt for back-three options. My vote would be Baloucoune, and I would use this opportunity to give Tommy O’Brien a long, hard look at outside centre, in at least one game.

My strongest Ireland XV: 15. Hugo Keenan; 14. Mack Hansen, 13. Tommy O’Brien, 12. Stuart McCloskey, 11. Rob Baloucoune; 10. Sam Prendergast, 9. Jamison Gibson-Park; 1. Andrew Porter, 2. Dan Sheehan, 3. Tadhg Furlong, 4. Joe McCarthy, 5. Tadhg Beirne, 6. Cian Prendergast, 7. Josh van der Flier, 8. Sean Jansen.


Relive the drama, intensity, and history — all the iconic British & Irish Lions documentaries from 2001-2021, available now on RugbyPass TV.


Comments

13 Comments
T
TT. 24 days ago

So glad and a bit surprised when reading this article since I was saying to myself that Sheehan could make a great 8 and that O’Brien should be tested at 13 while watching Clermont-Leinster.

I do not know to which extent Sheehan could really develop into a new position but, at least, it would enable Ireland to have more ingame options.

O’Brien really looks like a player who need to get the ball amap so having him as an outside center makes, in my opinion, a lot of sense. He also seems to have the defensive ability to make the conversion… at club level at least because I can not see him ging into a WC without a few caps and I do not know if Farrell is ready to lock him into that position for the NC’s and 6 Nations’ games.

I also think that Ireland desperately need a new lock to show up. Even if McCarthy and Beirne make a world class a second row, James Ryan is not up to the level he previously was and I do not know if he can still strenghen his game. Maybe Darragh Murray will give them the depth they need especially as the possibility of Beirne playing 6 without weakening their second row in an insurmountable way would probably be a delight for Andy Farrell.

Their backs also quite desperately need McCloskey to come back at his ever-best level. Without that, and I also think that it would be a sine qua non requirement to enable Andy Farrell to experiment O’Brien at 13, their midfield could look rather worrying…

From a far-off (french) point of view, I did not know that Baloucoune was srated so highly. Is it due to the Twickenham game ? To his creativity ?

I must say that I was quite impressed by Mack Hansen when he was used as a fullback last year. Even if Keenan seems to (rightfully) own this position, I hope they could more often switch their position when attacking.

To conclude, if we take apart the front row’s interrogations, the irish squad could look, in my opinion, up to the level for a WC. Nevertheless, it would probably take a second row, Van der Flier, McCloskey to show up to create real depth. As much as their forward could be the key for their sucess, I hope they will be more inclined to try 6-2 benchs…

Btw, do you know why Tom Farrell has been given so much game time last year ? I have not seen him play enough to have a definitive opinion but I must admit that I find it hard to believe that Andy Farrell was considering him as a credible option for the future…

P
PM 23 days ago

The O’Brien to 13 train is leaving the station. All aboard!!

Tom Farrell has been injured, so is yet to feature this season. Hopefully back soon.

Will be watching Sheehan closely, this weekend

B
B 24 days ago

O’Brien at 13 is a great shout and really should have happened before now


Technically brilliant and a superb tackler. He often takes man and ball which is tailor made for his ability on the breaking ball and quick attack


Let the Boks and France slug out the NC and get going now to tweak a 30 man squad and depth for next year


He needs to be allowed to make a few early mistakes at 13 but McCloskey can cover any blushes with his own defensive game


We haven't held our own against the ABs, Boks and France in the last 2 years because of our lapses in midfield


Often giving up winning positions in the second half as we get softened up in the centre

T
TheNotoriousFig 24 days ago

Has TOB played outside centre before? I like the thinking about having the fastest and best players on the pitch and he is one of those. Much as I rate Ringrose and Henshaw, they need to recapture form and fitness in the next 12 months, Aki is hanging on as an impact guy so McCloskey is the most important of the veteran centres. Nankivell is a really good player but I’m not convinced with that after this cycle that he would be more than a squad player with Osbourne and some of the other young lads.

P
PM 23 days ago

Tommy played there for the U20s, and made his Leinster debut at outside centre, too. He has a couple of inside centre starts. Leinster were well stocked with centres in his breakthrough years, so he shifted to the wings.

If he loses out to Hansen or Baloucoune, you could see him missing out on the 23 entirely, and I would not like to see that. With Henshaw & Ringrose pushing on (although TO’B is 28!) I’d like to see him get some game-time there.

B
B 24 days ago

Yeah. The better the opponent, the more time your centres will be defending than attacking. Aki is now potentially a liability on the defensive side of things


He's off contract this season, I'm not sure he hangs on for RWC


McCloskey and his big body should be fine as his age doesn't reflect the damage of the 80 test caps he should have by now


If he kicks on from last season then he would be in POTY territory


Beyond this cycle, there will be some huge holes in the midfield but that's for another year

u
unknown 24 days ago

Not sure that Furlong is still up for the test level, but I suppose we’ve all been saying that for a while now. Otherwise I really like this team—surprised to say I actually really like the idea of trying ToB at 13, he’s one of our best tacklers and knows how to find a gap with pace. Not sure that he could supplant Bobby B or Hansen on the wing. With the way Prendergast and Frawley have been playing, if Crowley can find his incredible form from before the injury when he comes back I reckon we’ll have depth in the 10 jersey for the first time since before Sexton left.


Curious how people feel about Nankivell—agree that he’s class and he seems to have an eye on that 13 jersey, where he have little to no depth… but he’ll be 32. And I know that’s not super old, but we’ve been complaining about our squad age for the past three years. I’m all for it but I wonder how everyone else is feeling.

P
PM 23 days ago

Reckon with Nankivell, that is just good business from Munster and his missus is Irish (they’ve just sorted a house here). Let him rock on for Munster and see where we are in 2028. If he maintains his current form, get him in!

B
B 24 days ago

Agree. Injury aside, the starting wings pick themselves and would possibly see O’Brien benching. He's worth a crack at 13 for sure. He and McCloskey could be dynamite


My only worry around Crowley is that it sounds like a very complex injury. He is a smashing player on his day. He has the talent that you build a team and style of play around him short to mid-term, but the injury issue is the worry. It seems to be the sort of thing that flairs up in the blink of an eye without warning. Farrell has a huge call to make around this


There is a lot to like about Nankivell but I think he's still developing. I don't think he'll be test ready until he's eligible, still needs a couple of seasons

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT