Northern | US

LONG READ ‘If the Bledisloe Cup must be a two-Test series, why not put it up for grabs every match?’

‘If the Bledisloe Cup must be a two-Test series, why not put it up for grabs every match?’
3 weeks ago

In the 90 years since its inception, the Bledisloe Cup has – to borrow from the great US sitcom Veep – maintained one common thread: continuity with change.

HSBC SVNS returns to Cape Town this December!

Don't miss your chance to see the world’s best rugby teams take centre stage 5-6 December in Cape Town.

Curiously, New Zealand Rugby and Rugby Australia can’t agree on whether it was first played for in 1931 or 1932. Both unions agree that Lord Bledisloe, the New Zealand Governor-General from 1930 to 1935, donated the giant trophy early in his reign, and unsurprisingly, both contend it was first played for when they won.

But since 1931 or 1932, the format has changed a lot. For the last few years, it has been played as a two-Test series. Next year, with the addition of the ANZAC Day Bledisloe Test in Brisbane, it will revert to the three-match series it was mostly through the 2010s.

It became a four-match series on the resumption of rugby after the Covid pandemic in 2020, as it was in a previous iteration from 2008-2010 when extra, lucrative ‘cash games’ were played in Hong Kong and Tokyo.

From 1999 through the early 2000s, the format was a two-match series. Having enjoyed a 3-0 whitewash in 1998, this allowed Australia to hold onto it for five straight years – including three drawn series – until 2002. The last time we’ve held it, in fact.

Australia celebrate with the Bledisloe Cup in 2002
The bulk of the 1999 World Cup-winning side were the last Aussie team to hold the Bledisloe Cup in 2002 (Photo William West/AFP via Getty Images)

Before professionalism, though, it was all over the place; three Tests in 1992, one-off Tests in 1993 and 1994 (the George Gregan tackle at Sydney Football Stadium), two matches in 1995.

Through the 1980s, a one-off Test one year would be followed by a full tour by one trans-Tasman neighbour to the other the following year. The last Australian win at Eden Park in Auckland was the Third Test of the Australian tour in 1986, which followed the one-off Test at the same venue in 1985. A 1983 Test at the Sydney Cricket Ground was followed by a three-Test tour by New Zealand in 1984.

But from the very early 1980s right back to its inception – whenever that was – it wasn’t necessarily played for every year, or even every other year. Two, three and even four-year gaps were quite common in the period from the 1930s through to 1982.

And equally strangely, the cup itself went missing for three decades in the middle of all that. The Wallabies won a two-Test series in New Zealand in 1949 – the last time they achieved that – and the cup wasn’t seen again until 1979. It was discovered in a storeroom in Melbourne, of all places.

They paraded this massive cup around the ground and the All Blacks were saying, ‘what’s that?’ They hardly knew that this thing existed.

The great Kiwi commentator Tony Johnson reminded me of all this only last week.

“The Wallabies were beaten in the first two Tests in 1978, so the Bledisloe was decided,” Johnson explained on the 8/9 Rugby podcast.

“But then they ripped the All Blacks up at Eden Park in the Third Test; Ken Wright and Tony Melrose, and Greg Cornelson scored his four tries, of course. Then the following year, the All Blacks went to Australia and they played a one-off Test at the SCG and Australia won it.

“They paraded this massive cup around the ground and the All Blacks were saying, ‘what’s that?’ They hardly knew that this thing existed.”

Codie Taylor hoists the Bledisloe Cup aloft for New Zealand
Codie Taylor was the latest in a long line of New Zealand captains who have lifted the trophy for the past 24 years (Photo Phil Walter/Getty Images)

How such an enormous trophy was subsequently lost in Melbourne, which only hosted its first Bledisloe Test in 1997, at the MCG, remains a mystery.

This fascinating history of the Bledisloe is the context behind a discussion that has bubbled up again on both sides of the Tasman. With the current two-Test series making it awfully hard for the Wallabies to regain the Cup, the question has popped up as to whether the Bledisloe Cup should be on the line every time Australia and New Zealand meet.

Certainly, a three-Test series would be the preference. A one-off Test will almost certainly never happen again, given the gate receipts both unions enjoy each year, so if it must be a two-Test series, why not put it up for grabs every match?

Tony Johnson raised it again in another discussion on New Zealand radio late last week.

“Some people are calling for that, you know. Maybe they think about having just one Bledisloe Cup Test a year,” he said. “At the moment, if you’re the holder, you only have to win one game. It’s swung so much in favour of the holder.”

In putting forward this idea of a format change, I acknowledge it could be very easily construed as just the latest desperate attempt from Australians to try and get their hands back on the trophy.

It would be a huge change, but it’s a really interesting one. And it seems like there would be two ways of doing it.

The first would be to play a one-off Bledisloe Cup Test and then play another two games as part of The Rugby Championship. It’s my strong suspicion that the instant success of the ANZAC Bledisloe in Brisbane next year will see NZR wanting a piece of that action as well, and so you could then put the Cup on the line for the one-off ANZAC Tests, alternated between each country each year.

The other way would be to put it on the line for every match, as a challenge concept seen in various sports. In a rugby sense, it’s most well-recognised in the Ranfurly Shield, played for by the provincial unions in New Zealand every year. Many over the ditch see the games for the ‘Log O’Wood’ as what is truly holding the provincial game together in NZ.

In putting forward this idea of a format change, I acknowledge it could be very easily construed as just the latest desperate attempt from Australians to try and get their hands back on the trophy.

Tom Wright sits alone on the pitch after Australia's defeat in Sydney
Australia are digesting a 13th successive loss to their trans-Tasman rivals and 24th straight year without the Bledisloe Cup (Photo Darrian Traynor/Getty Images)

There’s some truth in that, of course, but I really don’t lie awake at night thinking about concepts that might make acquiring the Bledisloe Cup more attainable. Trust me on that. But this idea is more intriguing because it has been New Zealanders raising it recently.

“The Bledisloe Cup is the thing that Australia really wants because it’s something that resonates with people,” Tony Johnson pointed out.

“During that era, that great era, when Australia held it and you had the likes of John Eales doing their thing and George Gregan and Stephen Larkham and co, holding the Bledisloe Cup was so important for Australia.

“And I think people this side of the Tasman realise what it would do for the game in Australia. We all want the game to be strong. In New Zealand, we need the game in Australia to be strong.”

It’s a really interesting discussion, but I think it all comes down to one key point: Would New Zealand Rugby truly be game enough to risk losing it on one loss, after holding it for 24 years?

Footnote: Lord Bledisloe also donated a trophy in the 1930s to the New Zealand Chess Federation for its inter-club championship, for which clubs compete annually for… the Bledisloe Cup! Otago beat Wellington to claim the 2026 title on Sunday, the day after the All Blacks completed their clean sweep in Sydney.

1 YEAR TO GO - RWC27

1 YEAR TO GO 

The countdown is on until the biggest Men’s Rugby World Cup ever kicks off in Australia. Go All Out and secure your seats with tickets now available! 

BUY TICKETS NOW

Comments

35 Comments
K
Kashmir Pete 20 days ago

Brett


Firmly in favour of cup sitting near the sideline and going to victor each game - think it would add some ritual oomph, just like the haka.


Cheers

KP

D
Derek Murray 24 days ago

I am trying to avoid anything to do with the Bledisloe right now but this was fun.


I particularly like that the two unions can’t agree on when it was first contested.

m
muglair 26 days ago

Kiwis take the BC more seriously than we do, so it won’t be going away soon. 1979 is more significant than the record books remember, the 1949 win was against a 3rd string ABs with an entire touring party in SA. Winning the game on our merits straight after the 3rd test in 1978 was a turning point for rugby, with few people still remembering winning the BC in the 30s.


I liked Spew’s idea of a cumulative points system, maybe in years where there is not either one or three tests scheduled. Having the BC competed for on ANZAC Day but not the other two games does not work for me. Treating every game as a one off test for the BC somehow does not fit with the history, as we know it.


Personally it was awesome to win it comprehensively in 1998 but a little ho hum hanging on to it by drawing each series while bragging about being the holder. Probably many Kiwis feel the same way? Taking the trophy two tests to one is still a big mountain but it also makes achieving the goal something special.

J
JW 26 days ago

Having a BC series seperated by 5/6 months works even less well for me muglair (might not be happening next year as these games will be played earlier in the year, in the July window from memory).

B
Brett McKay 26 days ago

No, I can’t agree with any suggestion Australian rugby doesn’t take the Bledisloe Cup seriously, Mug.


The result of that series alone forms much of the Australian sporting public’s opinion on rugby. Outside a RWC, it’s the only series that properly cuts through the broader sporting understanding..

C
CN 26 days ago

Correct me if I’m wrong, but didn’t Australia cut it back to 2 tests when they won in back from New Zealand as opposed to 3? Then they were paid a very tidy sum from Telstra Stadium to have the opening match played in Sydney for 10 years, thinking they would win the first one and retain it? Only to lose it, then when the opening match money ran out, bring in the 4th test, which is crazy as they’d have to win 3…. The NZ plays the first one at Eden Park, and well, the rest is history (and still being made)

B
Brett McKay 26 days ago

The tidy sum from the Olympic Stadium is certainly true CN, but everything else is probably conjecture. It’s gone back to two Tests when NZ have held it too, and indeed, the format switching the number of Tests played has essentially changed since its inception..

J
JW 26 days ago

It should definitely be up for grabs in the ANZAC test.

S
Spew_81 26 days ago

The easiest way to keep a two Test series alive, through both Tests, is to make the winner of the cup etc. based on the aggregate of the two Tests.


Association football has been doing this for years and the fans seem to have no issue understanding.


With the addition of the ANZAC Test in 2027 there will be three Tests between the All Blacks and Wallabies going forward?

B
Brett McKay 26 days ago

I have to agree with JW’s point about the Bledisloe/TRC overlap erasing the dead rubber, Spew. But I don’t mind the idea of aggregate..

J
JW 26 days ago

The easiest way to keep a two Test series alive, through both Tests, is to make the winner of the cup etc. based on the aggregate of the two Tests.

They are TRC fixtures, there is no need to “keep the series alive”. They are already contested matches.

G
GS 26 days ago

Maybe the ABs should just give the Wallabies a 10 point lead or start with 14 men?


Or the Wallabies just become good enough to win the actual cup?


Win the BC first and then make changes if wanted, otherwise would be making changes because it’s to “tough” to win the BC - but isn’t that how it’s supposed to be?


Talent is feeding through for Australia - Oz U18’s put 90 points on the NZ schoolboys last year and again beat them this year in NZ - so Oz is slowly but surely getting pathways going/better.


I mean RA makes it so tough for the Wallabies - for the ANZAC test next year, it’s outside the international window - so guess what, suddenly Wallabies can’t get to pick Skelton,Topou, Hooper etc but get to face a full strength AB side including the likes of Savea, Mo’unga, Love (think 17 players injured for this series for the ABs).


That game will most likely be a cricket score to the ABs - obviously great $$ generator for Oz and NZ - but in a game sense, RA is doing zero favors to the Wallabies to allow them to win the BC.

C
CN 26 days ago

“Talent is feeding through for Australia - Oz U18’s put 90 points on the NZ schoolboys last year and again beat them this year in NZ - so Oz is slowly but surely getting pathways going/better.”. - would be good to see NZ U18’s vs Oz U18’s, not schoolboys vs mainly club?

D
DP 26 days ago

Nah. Gotta let the AB’s make it 25 in a row first.

B
Brett McKay 26 days ago

That could easily happen. I’d be stunned if any such change was in place for 2027..

M
Mark 26 days ago

The Bledisloe cup, hasnt been an actual contest for some yrs now.

N
NoLongerARuck 26 days ago

NZR and RA should add a mandatory third test every year between the sides and it should be played during the Super Rugby season or directly after. 2 home games and 1 away game every year alternating between the teams. A best of 3 is the best way to decide the series and if thats not possible it should be a one off in that year. The two test contest is far too lopsided to continue.

B
Brett McKay 26 days ago

And that feels like a completely logical position, NLAR.


But I do think the sheer amount of format change through history - and it’s a lot - actually makes it tough to mandate? It’s hard to say what the ‘traditional’ format for the Bledisloe even is.


But certainly, an odd number is preferrable..

R
Rabble 26 days ago

I think the idea of having it on the line for the one-off Anzac test is a great one. For rugby's sake, not just Australia's.


Out of interest, I looked up all the times NZ has retained the cup, rather than won it outright - i.e. all the drawn series since 2003.


2019, 2015, 2011, 2007, 2004. An amazing correlation with RWC years! 2023 was the aberration of course. A pity we didn't win that game in Dunedin.


It makes me feel slightly better knowing that NZ haven't won the Cup for 24 straight years. They've obviously retained it the whole time, but there's been 5 drawn series' in that period.


7 straight series losses (and only 1 match win) since that 2019 series is dismally abysmal though.

B
Brett McKay 26 days ago

Yeah, and the history of one-off Tests arguably supports that, Rabble.


I’m still working my way around “dismally abysmal” though.. 🥴

m
muglair 26 days ago

Quite a few of these years involved playing an AB side on rotation, as well as SA.

N
NoLongerARuck 26 days ago

Its also an indication of how incredibly dominant NZ have been. Well in excess of 80% against Australia right over like 60 tests. its a pretty awful record

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Watch Nations Championship - Round 5 LIVE

close

Hemispheres collide in the new Nations Championship. Stream live, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV.

Watch on RPTV
Starts 4th July 2026 - USA only.