The good, the bad and the ugly of the Wallabies' Murrayfield defeat
The Wallabies took a few big steps forward at Murrayfield, but they also took a couple of steps backwards.
It is this feeling that they struggle to chew gum and walk, which likely leaves many Aussies disheartened at yet another loss on the bounce.
Yes, the defensive effort against Scotland versus the effort shown a week prior against England was night and day.
Punch, verve, energy, aggression, line speed, and connection all came to the fore and kept the Scots to just 15 points.
However, the Wallabies scored just 12 points at Murrayfield, their fewest in over a year, and against a similarly ranked opposition.
The Wallabies have managed to put 40-plus points on the Springboks, around 20 against the All Blacks, but against Scotland they only mustered two tries and a single conversion.
Whilst the Wallabies were making almost all the right decisions in defence, it was when they had the ball in hand that the errors and bizarre actions took place.
This is not an inexperienced team; a lot of these players have between 20-50 caps, with a few more experienced leaders in the group.
The Wallabies will once again rue a result that was within reach, and will also be pondering why they left their surge so late.
The Good
Sometimes, just sometimes, rugby requires violence, just plain and simple violence.
The Wallabies looked like they took the “learnings” on defence from last week very seriously.
Not only was the shape and speed off the line vastly improved, but you could feel the contacts in the stands.
Billy Pollard led the defensive sting in London the week prior, and he did the same in Edinburgh against Scotland.
Wallabies players were flying into contact like their lives depended on it, and what was even more impressive is that they left no holes, conceding only one linebreak the entire match.
Rob Valetini used his renowned choke-tackle to win a turnover; Len Ikitau looked like he was born again, flying up, swimming through, and making Scottish ball players rush their pass.
Right across the park, Wallabies players were consistent in both system application and aggression.
The Wallabies tackled at 87%, which is now the standard for both aggression and how the system must operate.
The Bad
The Wallabies’ decision-making was generally poor.
Kicked when they should have run, went for a lineout when their coach called for three, and called for a 22m drop-out when their scrum with Taniela Tupou was dominant.
Moments like these really stood out when you reflect on the tight 15-12 scoreline.
The Wallabies struggled to leverage their advantages and rarely chose to use them.
Taking a 22m drop-out when they had the option for a scrum just outside the 22m is one of these decisions.
The Wallabies scrum had the Scots on the ropes the entire match, and a scrum penalty could’ve put them 30m upfield; to opt for a drop-out just felt like the Wallabies didn’t trust in their process or attack.
Despite being outside the 22m, the last play of the game showed they can orchestrate linebreaks from anywhere.
The Wallabies had their opportunities, but at other times they just handed away possession, like when Ryan Lonergan launched a box kick into Scotland’s 22m for a chasing Joseph-Aukuso Suaallii in the 51st minute.
It was a piece of play which, had the Wallabies shown any real dynamism in attack more generally, then variation would have been called for, but instead, the Wallabies just looked rudderless as opposed to cutting-edge.
A kick for Suaalii in the 22m line is a good tactic, but not like that, especially when Carter Gordon, Tom Wright, and Max Harry Potter have 40m to attack on the short side in a 3v3.
You’d back that trio to win that melee most times.
The final major moment, which captain Harry Wilson says he would’ve chosen with hindsight, was to take a shot at goal in the 39th minute almost directly in front, 23m out.
With less than a minute left on the clock, the score standing at 12-8 to Scotland, the Wallabies should’ve realised how difficult points were to come by on a wet night at Murrayfield.
Coach Les Kiss knew it; he stepped out of his box and signalled down to his pitchside men to take the three.
It’s a pretty telling move for a coach who didn’t advocate for his Super Rugby Pacific side to take a shot at goal until the quarter-finals in 2025.
Instead, Wilson “trusted the lineout-maul” and went for the touchline.
No points came, and Gordon ended the half by kicking a nothing kick across the field to no one; it really summed up the ugly side of the Wallabies on a cold Edinburgh night.
The Ugly
The Wallabies’ attack was flat, one-dimensional, and lacking genuine options.
Many Wallabies fans would’ve wanted to see Carter Gordon come in and instantly spark a free-flowing attack.
Despite Ikitau looking strong in defence, he is not truly a ball playing no.12 and that meant that in the moments when his pass was to be the defining one in the backline, it added nothing more than another pair of hands, as opposed to a injection of potency.
The Wallabies looked as though they had found a rhythm early on for Harry Potter’s try.
Four sets of hands ran their swing-and-dig pattern masterfully in tight quarters.
Each player did their bit to straighten the line and draw in Scottish defenders, but even then Potter had plenty of work to beat Finn Russell and then survive another tackle before he crossed the line.
For the many Potter detractors, that is a stark reminder of what he brings to the table.
Despite this impressive display, the Wallabies’ attack regularly failed to leverage their attacking weapons and instead were regularly caught behind the gainline.
It was too frantic; players missed their cues, ran them too early, or were not set up to create a threatening picture against the wall of Scottish defenders, or simply seemed to lack the energy to get into shape.
Gordon looked lost at sea at times; the extended period out of the side seems to have taken a toll, with him being unsure of where his runners were supposed to be and where he was best placed to influence the contest.
The Wallabies have now built a habit of making the incorrect calls when they found open space, and it continued in Edinburgh.
Max Jorgensen was on the end of a counter-attacking play from a brilliant Josh Canham break in the 45th minute.
Jorgensen tried to use the same inside-out step he has used in Super Rugby on so many occasions, but in this instance the space was too tight, and all he needed to do was to draw in the Scottish winger and pop the ball to Potter on the outside, and the Wallabies would’ve had another 5-pointer.
However, instead, the attack died with him, with Scotland winning a turnover at the resulting breakdown. Yet, another moment where the wrong decision was taken.
Passages side to side without punch, pulling out the back to a wave of attack without motion; it was not pretty viewing in a backline that should be capable of almost anything.
It was the same process time and time again.
In the 70th minute, the Wallabies pulled off Len Ikitau and put on Ben Donaldson, shifting Gordon to no. 12; it delivered immediate results, with Gordon being given more time to play and Donaldson organising better in their system and shape.
McDermott helped as well, but it was too little too late; his injection of pace and threats around the ruck visibly caused the Scots distress.
The Wallabies also used the last play of the match to throw a second genuine punch in attack, making a 40m run out of their 22m only to throw a wild offload for Scotland to end the match through Blaire Kinghorn.
Decision-making under pressure in attack is very much a Wallabies work on; they made 10 linebreaks against a side which on average only conceded six per match.
To walk away with only two tries to show for it and no penalties kicked; will be music to Wales’s ears.

Watch Hemispheres collide as North faces South in the Nations Championship. Live matches, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV here
(*USA only)