Northern | US

Pressure mounts on Gregor Townsend as Scotland melt in Roman rain

By PA
Press Associaton

Pressure mounted on Gregor Townsend as Scotland suffered a disastrous Guinness Six Nations start by losing 18-15 to Italy in rain-lashed Rome.

ADVERTISEMENT

The fired-up Azzurri raced into a 12-point lead within 14 minutes and the Scots – with back-three big-hitters Blair Kinghorn, Darcy Graham and Duhan van der Merwe all dropped amid question marks over their form – were unable to get their attack firing in response, while their set-piece continually malfunctioned.

As Italy held firm for a deserved victory on a sodden Stadio Olimpico surface, it was the first time since 2020 that Townsend’s side had lost their opening game of the Six Nations.

VIDEO

The timing of this horror show in the Eternal City could hardly be worse for the long-serving head coach, given that his position was already under intense scrutiny after a poor autumn campaign and following his contentious decision to take on a part-time consultancy role with Red Bull.

A Murrayfield showdown with England is next up for the under-fire Townsend.

Fixture
Six Nations
England
48 - 7
Full-time
Wales
All Stats and Data

Scotland could have no excuse for underestimating the Italians, given that nine of their XV had also started when they lost 31-29 on their previous visit to Rome in March 2024.

But they were caught cold as the hosts – missing key duo Sebastian Negri and Ange Capuozzo through injury – made the breakthrough in the eighth minute.

ADVERTISEMENT

Juan Ignacio Brex’s grubber kick out to the right sent Louis Lynagh scampering towards the line and the wing gleefully slid over. Paolo Garbisi’s conversion attempt came back off the post.

Italy scored again in the 14th minute when Lynagh outjumped Jamie Dobie under a high ball and captain Michele Lamaro looped a lovely pass out to the left for Tommaso Menoncello, who burst away to dive over the line, leaving the Scots shell-shocked before Garbisi added the extras.

As torrential rain fell from the Rome sky, Scotland were all in sorts of bother.

They temporarily managed to stem the Italian deluge, enjoying a period of pressure in the 22 that eventually led to Jack Dempsey pushing his way through from close range to score in the 24th minute, with Finn Russell adding the extras.

Italy reasserted their authority in the 35th minute with a Garbisi penalty seconds after the stand-off had sent a drop goal attempt wide of the target.

ADVERTISEMENT

Trailing by eight points at the break, a Russell penalty in the 46th minute brought the Scots back to within a score.

But the Italians swiftly replied with another Garbisi penalty after Ewan Ashman, who was having a torrid afternoon, was penalised for a high tackle.

The hooker was immediately replaced by George Turner, with Graham also introduced in place of Dobie.

Within five minutes of entering the fray, however, Turner was yellow-carded for a dangerous clearout on Manuel Zuliani, although the Azzurri were unable to make their numerical advantage count.

Just as the game looked to be drifting away from the visitors, they gave themselves a lifeline in the 67th minute when substitute George Horne dived over on the right off the back of a lineout. Russell sent his conversion attempt wide.

It summed up a dismal afternoon for the Scots that they barely threatened to get the score they needed in the closing stages, leaving their hopes of contending for the championship all but over after matchday one.

Related

Create your ticketing account and unlock presale access for Rugby World Cup 2027 now

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

17 Comments
J
John Campbell 48 days ago

Terrible conditions for rugby. But the aerial and mauling suited Italy more than Scotland

u
unknown 48 days ago

Italy 100% deserved the win.

S
SB 48 days ago

So impressed with the Italians.

E
Eric Elwood 48 days ago

Solid win by Italy. There was a deluge last 15 minutes of half, worst rain many of the pundits had ever been in never mind played in. Italy knew it was important to get a lead and raced into a 12 nil lead. Half time was 15-7 but that was significant. Dempseys try came a little too early for Scotland as it was just after an official warning for Italy. But maybe just clever by the Italians to not foul even if it meant conceding.

Italy managed the win 18-15 but could have managed the match better. They gave a few unnessessary penalties which gave Scotland a lifeline. For example one contestable was short and they were pinged for offside. There was no vital need to be super accurate with the contestables. It was a major achievement just to catch the thing. Knocking it an extra 5-10 metres was risk free.

Anyway, good win but it should have been by more than one score. Italy gave SA a game in the November and their B team did OK in the summer down in the Republic.

They benefitted a lot from those matches. Beating Scotland is not a shock. They are up there. Don’t write Scotland off next week either.


Ireland-Italy next week will be good!

England-Italy in Rome also………

C
CM 48 days ago

Yeah Scotland gave away a few unnecessary pens themselves. Like Turner clearing out a guy with no arms. That’s pretty unnecessary I would have thought.

G
GRB13 48 days ago

South Africa played with 14 men for 90% of the game.

D
DP 48 days ago

Pressure mounts?! Scotland have themselves to blame for continuing with Townsend. Franco Smith should have been offered the job.

u
unknown 47 days ago

100%

u
unknown 48 days ago

Another false dawn for Scotland?? How many times have we heard about Scotland's ‘Golden generation’!!??

E
Eric Elwood 47 days ago

It’s mainly by English media though in fairness. I would say the Scots would prefer quiet build ups with spotlights off.

C
CM 47 days ago

Pffft, they haven’t been favourites or even second favourites to win the Six Nations with the bookmakers this century. They consistently punch above their weight.

H
Hammer Head 48 days ago

In terms of trajectory…

O
OD43 48 days ago

Surely it’s time for a change this time. As in the autumn, major calls all wrong - not a natural 15 in the wrong place for the first two tries, late use of bench, no attempt to make changes despite failing set peice, combined with a complete lack of intensity - despite being the best player pool he’s ever seen. Wondering which SRU board member Townsend has photographed with a man called Jeffrey to still be in this job.

B
BC 48 days ago

Totally agree - another miserable display from what is arguably the best Scottish side in a generation. It’s essentially a Glasgow side that always performs brilliantly. What’s the difference - Townsend. What were the SRU thinking in extending his contract. He has won nothing in 8 years. Friends in other countries even see this. Will the SRU finally do something right and let Townsend go and hire Franco Smith. If we play like this against England next week we will lose by 50 points. So frustrating for fans who pay good money to watch this ineptness.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT