Munster player ratings vs Castres | Investec Champions Cup

Munster player ratings: Munster’s overall discipline and execution issues cost them a chance of turning over Castres at Stade Pierre Fabre, and they ultimately had to settle for 16-14 scoreline and a losing bonus point.

Here’s how we rated the Munster players:

15. Mike Haley – 4
Pinged early for holding on, lobbed the ball into touch like he was aiming for row Z, and rounded things off with a forward pass that wouldn’t have looked out of place in a pub sevens match. A night to forget for the full-back.

14. Calvin Nash – 5
Struggled to assert himself in the game, with few chances to show his pace or skill on the wing. Good in the air.

Schalk Burger on Siya Kolisi’s move to No.8 | RPTV

Schalk Burger discusses the way Bok captain Siya Kolisi has played at the back of the scrum. Watch the full Boks Office episode on RugbyPass TV now

Watch now

Schalk Burger on Siya Kolisi’s move to No.8 | RPTV

Schalk Burger discusses the way Bok captain Siya Kolisi has played at the back of the scrum. Watch the full Boks Office episode on RugbyPass TV now

Watch now

13. Tom Farrell – 5.5
Tried his best to inject some grunt into Munster’s backline and was solid defensively, but couldn’t dent Castres’ resolute defence.

12. Alex Nankivell – 6
Showed plenty of fight and aggression, throwing himself into tackles and carries with real intent. However, his efforts often felt like a solo mission in a misfiring backline.

11. Thaakir Abrahams – 5
A real comedown after last week’s heroics. Did his best defensively, including a valiant but futile attempt to stop former Connacht No.8 Abraham Papali’i’s try, before being forced off with a shoulder injury.

10. Jack Crowley – 5.5
Nearly the architect of Munster’s comeback hopes with solid conversions, but his missed touchfinder in the 80th minute will haunt him more than a dodgy Christmas pudding. He’ll need to do better than this if he’s to fend off Sam Prendergast for the Ireland 10 jersey.

9. Craig Casey – 6
Injured early, limiting his contribution, though he battled to organize the attack before leaving the field.

1. Dian Bleuler – 5
The South African was one of a number of Munster players who needs to look at their tackling technique. Went off injured after 21 minutes.

2. Niall Scannell – 5.5
One of the few brightish sparks in the pack, with solid defensive work and a key role in Munster’s maul try. That said, must hold up his hand for Munster’s setpiece omni-shambles.

3. Stephen Archer – 4
Seemed determined to be on first-name terms with the referee with his appalling tackling costing Munster dearly here. It might be time for Munster to finally start looking beyond the 36-year-old.

4. Fineen Wycherley – 5
Struggled to make an impact after a pretty poor start to the game.

5. Tadhg Beirne – 7
Led the side well and provided some key turnovers, though not his most commanding performance.

6. Peter O’Mahony – 6.5
Fought the good fight with his usual grit and determination, scrapping for every inch at the breakdown and in defence. His departure due to injury left Munster missing a vital edge in the closing stages.

7. John Hodnett – 8
Munster’s standout performer, Hodnett crossed the whitewash twice and worked tirelessly in defence. A gutsy display that kept his team in the fight, even if the support around him fell short.

8. Brian Gleeson – 6
On his first start of the season, he showed promise with physical carries and defensive contributions but faded slightly as the game progressed. Huge promise.

REPLACEMENTS

16. Diarmuid Barron – 5
Brought energy to the pack and was effective in the maul but missed a crucial lineout opportunity late on.

17. Dave Kilcoyne – 6
The old warhorse added some much-needed heft to the scrum and brought his usual brand of controlled aggression.

18. Oli Jager – 5
Had limited time to make an impact in the scrums or open play.

19. Tom Ahern – 7
Brought fresh energy to the forwards and was reliable in the lineout.

20. Alex Kendellen – 5
Had little time to impose himself on the game.

21. Paddy Patterson – 5.5
Provided quick service from the breakdown and added tempo after replacing Casey in the first half.

22. Rory Scannell – 5
A steady presence off the bench but had little chance to influence proceedings.

23. Jack O’Donoghue – 6
Added some physicality in the final stages of the game.