Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Ken Laban's not wrong about the Mo'unga-less Crusaders

PARIS, FRANCE - OCTOBER 28: Richie Mo'unga of New Zealand looks on prior to the Rugby World Cup Final match between New Zealand and South Africa at Stade de France on October 28, 2023 in Paris, France. (Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

I wholeheartedly agree with Ken Laban.

The veteran television commentator cast doubt upon the Crusaders’ Super Rugby Pacific title-winning credentials due to the absence of an accomplished playmaker.

ADVERTISEMENT

They team had one in recent years, in Richie Mo’unga, but don’t boast anyone of his quality now.

Saturday’s clash between the Crusaders and Chiefs left me a bit flat. Nothing wrong with the game itself, especially the Chiefs’ contribution.

It was more a case that I came to the conclusion that the Chiefs have no real challenger this season.

I had doubted the Chiefs. I had felt they didn’t have the defensive discipline to win when it counted.

That, at least in theory, still remains to be seen. We’re not at the playoff stage, after all. But if anyone was going to offer a credible championship alternative this year, I felt it would be the Crusaders. I’m not sure that I do now.

Control from the first five-eighth is an issue, but I’d probably broaden the issue a bit from what Laban said.

ADVERTISEMENT

Match Summary

0
Penalty Goals
3
3
Tries
4
2
Conversions
3
0
Drop Goals
0
123
Carries
162
5
Line Breaks
6
13
Turnovers Lost
18
7
Turnovers Won
7

The Crusaders are hugely profligate as a team. They turn the ball over so softly, they kick without purpose, and they don’t have the ability to defend their plentiful mistakes.

The teams Mo’unga played in didn’t do that. Those sides fed off your indiscipline at the breakdown, they scored points from your dropped passes.

Mo’unga ensured the Crusaders played at the right end, he kicked a lot of goals and he was expert at turning opposition errors into clinical counterattacks.

Of course, the Crusaders are nowhere near as good without him, but the difference wouldn’t be so marked if the whole team were better at looking after the football.

ADVERTISEMENT

The thing I always admired about Crusaders sides of yore was how risk-free their rugby was. They dismantled opposition set-pieces, demoralised playmakers and won games through defence.

Related

I just don’t think they know how to do that anymore. That saddens and even perplexes me. I’ve been a huge admirer of that franchise’s ruthless efficiency and can’t understand why they insist on putting themselves under pressure by
making so many errors in possession.

We’ll see about the Chiefs. They were genuinely excellent on Saturday and basically did a Crusaders on the Crusaders.

The only mountain they have left to climb is delivering when it really counts. For the others, where there’s life, there’s hope.

The Crusaders could still revert to the rugby that’s characterised their historic success. The Hurricanes are getting steadily better, and then there’s the Blues.

They’ve underwhelmed this year, but sit fifth on the table and have as much talent as anyone, including a noted playmaker in Beauden Barrett. I’ve been critical of them at times, but I wouldn’t entirely discount them.

That’s the beauty of sport and knockout rugby in particular.

The sooner we get to the sudden death phase of this competition, the better.

Download the RugbyPass app now!

News, stats, live rugby and more! Download the new RugbyPass app on the App Store (iOS) and Google Play (Android) now!

ADVERTISEMENT
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

5 Comments
S
SadersMan 36 days ago

When will these “experts” ever learn?

G
GP 37 days ago

Based on the way the Crusaders played in the second half against the Chiefs and Moana Pasifika , Hamish would be right. But this team have been by and large better than that this year. Kyle Preston and James )’Connor must be brought on earlier if need be. Rivez Reihana is developing nicely. Richie Mo’unga , contrary to what his knockers say , was one of and still is one of the greats. David Havili and Will Jordan, ( I know he is injured), have stepped up big time. A fortnight ago the Chiefs were drilled by the Hurricanes. It has been that type of comp.

C
Cantab 36 days ago

This year’s competition has been somewhat bizarre as the 6 teams in contention have had games where they look a million dollars and followed up with awful performances. Consistency is a quality that seems to be sadly lacking. Seems likely that Chiefs & Crusaders will clash again in the final with the Chiefs favoured to take it out but who knows for certain ???

B
BH 37 days ago

I’ll be cheering for anyone who plays the Blues in the finals. They don’t deserve to win the comp based on their bad form this year.

A
Andrew Nichols 37 days ago

The Blues winning would be a travesty.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

TRENDING
TRENDING Where to Watch: Lions and England headline big weekend of rugby What to watch this weekend on RugbyPass TV
Search