They never recovered.
NSW was shocking in the second half, conceding six tries and 38 unanswered points as the Chiefs won for the first time in NSW since 2007.
“It was 51 points, crikey. There’s some pretty brutal terms being used to describe what that second half looked like,” Penney said.
“It’s very concerning. How does that happen?
“There were six clean drops in that second half where we just turned over ball inexplicably, and we’ve got good players doing it.
“Through the hands and off the chest. That happens through a bit of pressure I guess but it’s not acceptable and it’s just embarrassing.
“It’s really tough on our supporters and the people that believe in these boys.
“It’s just not acceptable. We got bullied off the ball. We went in soft and high.
“You can train until the cows come home but if you don’t want to put your body in a tough position or your head in a hard position … it looks vulnerable.”
It was the most points the Chiefs have scored away against NSW, the second-most ever in Australia and their biggest win anywhere against the Waratahs.
The bonus-point victory saw the Chiefs jump from seventh to first on the competition ladder.
Hunt also set up their second try after he took a crash ball and managed to transfer possession to Jack Dempsey who crossed out wide.
Consecutive conversions from rookie No. 10 Will Harrison gave the Waratahs an unlikely lead in the 33rd minute.
But it was all downhill from there as the relentless Chiefs kept NSW scoreless in the second half while piling on 38 straight points to secure an emphatic victory.
“It’s been a long time since we’ve won against the Waratahs in Australia so we wanted to put that right,” Chiefs coach Warren Gatland said.
“But yeah 38 unanswered points in the second half is a pretty good effort.”
WATCH: Jim discusses the ramifications of the Six Nations going behind a pay wall and no longer being shown on free to watch TV.
Sign up to our mailing list here and we’ll keep you up to the minute with weekly updates from the world of rugby.