Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Andrew Porter breaks silence on his role in Antoine Dupont incident

By PA
France captain Antoine Dupont is consoled by Maxime Lucu after last Saturday's injury (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

Ireland prop Andrew Porter has insisted “I haven’t done anything wrong” as he hit back at France head coach Fabien Galthie amid the fall out over Antoine Dupont’s season-ending knee injury.

ADVERTISEMENT

Les Bleus captain Dupont – widely regarded as the world’s best player – faces a lengthy spell on the sidelines after rupturing an anterior cruciate ligament during his country’s 42-27 Guinness Six Nations win in Dublin.

France were furious with the incident which caused the injury, with Galthie branding it “reprehensible” as he announced his intention to refer Ireland pair Porter and Tadhg Beirne to the citing commissioner for possible retrospective punishment.

Video Spacer

Will Felix Jones be the next Bok Head Coach? | RPTV

The Boks Office boy speculate as to whether Felix Jones’ return could set him up for a long term future with the Springboks. Watch the full show now on RugbyPass TV.

Watch now

Video Spacer

Will Felix Jones be the next Bok Head Coach? | RPTV

The Boks Office boy speculate as to whether Felix Jones’ return could set him up for a long term future with the Springboks. Watch the full show now on RugbyPass TV.

Leinster loosehead Porter, who – in addition to teammate Beirne – is free to feature in Saturday’s round-five fixture away to Italy, said he had “no malicious intent”. “He can say what he wants, see how far it gets him,” Porter said of Galthie.

“No, I wasn’t disappointed. I knew what I did; I didn’t go out to try and injure anyone. That’s not the type of player I am. If he [Galthie] wants to think that, that is up to him.

Fixture
Six Nations
Italy
17 - 22
Full-time
Ireland
All Stats and Data

“I even sent Antoine a message on Instagram just to see how he was and obviously you never want to see anyone going off the pitch like that. If you have the head coach calling for your head, it’s a bit much to be fair.

“But he is such a pivotal player for them that they nearly don’t want him to be touched at all. Look, he is entitled to his opinion but I know I haven’t done anything wrong there. I sleep well at night.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Dupont was visibly upset when he limped from the field in the 29th minute of Saturday’s match after Beirne, who appeared to be pushed by Porter, fell on his right leg, causing it to buckle.

France’s anger fuelled a breathtaking second-half display as they turned a slender 8-6 advantage into a emphatic demolition job to move into pole position for championship glory and halt Ireland’s Grand Slam bid.

“His leg got trapped in between a ruck when he was trying to counter it and he obviously just got trapped and went over,” Porter continued. “It happens so much in this sport. There was no malicious intent surrounding it at all. It’s obviously unfortunate and unlucky.”

Ireland had hoped to travel to Rome on the cusp of an historic third consecutive Six Nations title. But Simon Easterby’s side are now in danger of finishing third on the back of a first home loss in the competition in four years.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ireland must win at Stadio Olimpico and then hope second-placed England and table-topping France slip up against Wales and Scotland respectively. “It’s obviously not easy moving on from a game like that,” Porter said of the sobering loss to Les Bleus.

“You can’t dwell on the past too much. But you’d be lying to yourself if you said you weren’t still thinking of that game. It was just a few small mistakes on the day really. We’re not going to let something like that shake us.

“We know exactly who we are as players and as a team. We know exactly what we can do, it just didn’t click for us on Saturday. If anything, it has emboldened us to go out and produce the rugby we can play.

“We are not out of the competition completely yet. It’s everything to play for. We get to go out and play this weekend and right a few wrongs.”

Related


To be first in line for Rugby World Cup 2027 Australia tickets, register your interest here 

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

12 Comments
H
HH 5 days ago

Start now making every month extra $6000-$22000 or more by just doing an easy online job from home. Last month i have earned and received $19650 from this job by giving this only 3 hrs a a day.Every person can now get this job and start earning online by.v­­is­it­in­­­g fo­­l­­lo­­­wi­­ng web HERE→→ 𝗪­𝘄­𝘄­.­𝗛­𝗶­𝗴­𝗵­­𝗣­𝗿­𝗼­𝗳­𝗶­𝘁­𝟭­.­𝗖­𝗼­𝗺

Y
YeowNotEven 6 days ago

Shannon Frizell got a garbage yellow card for a similar thing once. It was an accident, these things happen, move on.

We don’t need a moral panic everytime someone gets bumped in a game of rugby.

The head contact rules have gone too far now this?

This is why Rugby League is better: players are treated like adults.

Rugby is 10% rugby and 90% bitching about the rules.

B
Bull Shark 6 days ago

I broke wind after Porter broke his silence about breaking Antoine’s knee.

J
J Marc 6 days ago

“Nobody done anything wrong your honor” , it is what we will say in the court when the contact point will be on the cervical spine instead of knee.

Any foul ?

What about :

* binding at a ruck?

* supporting your body weight ?

* not falling on your opponent ?knee ?

Two weeks ago Gary Ringrose got a red card. Saturday, P L Barassi was injuried by a double contact : with the head by Nash, with the shoulder by Robbie Henshaw. I think it was far more dangerous than Ringrose case.

I also think that ,with this kind of décision, World Rugby is digging its own grave, or far more ennoying, the grave of rugby union.

K
Kinhack94 6 days ago

Big man words mean very little on the Internet buddy. There’s very few rucks in international rugby that doesn’t break one of these laws. The first 30 seconds of the highlights from Wales vs Scotland at the weekend will prove this. Yeah the rucks need to be cleaned up but this goes for everyone not just Ireland.

B
Bull Shark 6 days ago

If a springbok broke an irish knee in a rugby game - good Lord Turlough would lose his mind. The offending player would be quartered and strung outside World Rugby Head Quarters.

C
CM 6 days ago

Pity refs ignore Porter's illegal scrummaging. Ireland always go off there feet at the breakdown and again this is ignored by refs. As for the slow Ireland line out, Gardner warned them then once again ignored it. Refs please apply the laws, especially when it is games with Ireland.

M
Matt Perry 6 days ago

Porter is a penalty machine at scrums I hardly think it's ignored.

T
Teddy 6 days ago

Breaks his silence? Such drama.


Was he on the run, hiding out between safe houses?

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 53 minutes ago
'France may leave top players at home but will still be serious contenders in New Zealand'

The country turned septic on Foster for losing a series to what was arguably the best Irish side in history and one that may not have been ranked number one in the world when they arrived, but were by the time they left.

Imagine how feral the nation will be if Robertson’s All Blacks lose to what is supposedly going to be a French ‘B’ team?

This author proving he has less of an understanding of rugby than the general population.


The country was septic because of how easily they got beat Paul. The country is smart enough to rate the relative level of performances, and if Razors team goes backwards like Fosters the criticism you suggest might come will be fully deserved. If France B perform as good as France A and win by the same margins then those with the criticism the team should be winning every game will also be deserved. But the inference that the public didn’t give Ireland the credit they deserved couldn’t be further from the truth imo.

France have beaten the All Blacks on the last three occasions the two sides have met, and that the former has used 38 players in the process.

France could leave 40 players at home in July and still be a serious contender

And to the vibe of this article, it provides abosolutely zero reason to believe the next 38 best French are going to be as good as these first 38. Paul got one thing right, it’s no joke that France will be leaving behind 40 players.


France have a 45 man squad for 6N (well using Wiki), the team could be made up of these leftovers from the teams not likely to get close to Toulouse and Bordeaux, given that just the third place team is doing commendably well not to be in negative for and against like the rest.

Uini Atonio ——— Prop

Giorgi Beria ——— Prop

Georges-Henri Colombe ———- Prop

Jean-Baptiste Gros ——— Prop

Dany Priso ——— Prop

Rabah Slimani———- Prop

Hugo Auradou ——— Lock

Mickaël Guillard ——— Lock

Matthias Halagahu ——— Lock

Romain Taofifénua ——— Lock

Esteban Abadie ——- Back row

Grégory Alldritt ———- Back row

Paul Boudehent ———- Back row

Oscar Jégou ——— Back row

Nolann Le Garrec ——— Scrum-half

Gaël Fickou ——— Centre

Antoine Frisch ——— Centre

Émilien Gailleton ——— Centre

Noah Nene ——— Centre

Théo Attissogbé ——— Wing

Gaël Dréan ———- Wing

Gabin Villièren —— Wing

Léo Barré ——— Fullback


One wouldn’t think Atonio is going to come (I’d be surprised if Fickou is still not rested or he and Le Garrec aren’t involved in a relegation playoff game) but a few good players there like Leo Barre, Le Garrec, Taofifénua, and that back row, but also a distinct lack of a spine with the 3 best playmakers playing in the Final at home.


What are the possibilities to fill out these missing spots? looking at Opta’s stats hub Serin and Couilloud provide good back up for Le Garrec by fact of having the highest try involvements in the Top14 (along with Michael Ruru). And Serin’s partner Herve looks the most threatening to carry on the teams style with his elusiveness?

12 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Will the real Queensland Reds please stand up Will the real Queensland Reds please stand up
Search