Northern | US

All Blacks need to knock the front door down first

Jordie Barrett of New Zealand during the Castle Double Malt Rugby's Greatest Rivalry, 2nd Test match between South Africa and New Zealand at DHL Stadium on August 29, 2026 in Cape Town, South Africa. (Photo by Ashley Vlotman/Gallo Images/Getty Images)
Comments
4 Comments

If that’s the standard, the All Blacks aren’t far off it.

ADVERTISEMENT

I’m not remotely discouraged by New Zealand’s 33-26 loss to South Africa in Cape Town.

Yes, the lineout is under pressure and, of course, you’d like the All Blacks to be better at catching high balls. But I feared the Springboks could dish out a hiding in this match and they didn’t.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

As I’ve indicated many times, this is a development tour for the All Blacks. It’s about exposing players such as Ruben Love and seeing how they cope.

This is a team that’s rebuilding. The past standards of excellence don’t apply here, because of how far the All Blacks have fallen in recent times.

They have to try and ascend to South Africa’s level and, two Tests in, they’re showing that they might be able to do that.

If there’s an area of concern for me, it’s in the All Blacks’ desperation to go around the Springboks. To shovel the ball across, no matter what pressure that puts on a teammate.

ADVERTISEMENT

I’d much prefer the team to be more direct and I think they’ve got the cattle to do so.

Peter Lakai would start at openside flanker, for me. Probably Asafo Aumua at hooker too and Patrick Tuipulotu at lock.

No disrespect to the guys who occupied those positions at Cape Town, but they’re just not physically robust enough to give the All Blacks the impetus to then throw the ball wide.

You have to earn the right and the team seems unprepared or incapable of doing that right now.

This is South Africa in South Africa and I don’t think that’s a setting for the soft option.

I’ll go back to the idea that, similar to Wellington last year, the Springboks appeared primed to inflict a heavy defeat upon the All Blacks.

ADVERTISEMENT

South Africa were poor in Johannesburg, just as they were at Eden Park last year. The All Blacks, fortuitously or otherwise, humbled them.

I expected all sorts of fire and brimstone this week and perhaps a scoreline not dissimilar to 43-10. It is to the All Blacks’ immense credit that, despite going behind early and forever having to play catch up, that they only finished a converted try short.

Did people honestly think the All Blacks were going to win in Cape Town? Do they seriously believe things went wrong and that soul-searching is required? Can they not recognise that the team is a long way from being the finished article and that they’ll only grow from these experiences?

Coaches don’t have magic wands. You don’t wander into the dressing room and transfer caterpillars to butterflies. This team is a work in progress, with the emphasis on the progress.

The All Blacks are better than they were under Ian Foster. They’re better than they were under Scott Robertson.

Far from gradually getting worse, as they did under their previous coaches, this All Black team is actually getting better.

It’s not perfect. Things could improve. But that’s why this tour is so valuable.

The original point stands: if South Africa is the benchmark, the All Blacks are getting close to it.

I wouldn’t have said that previously. I would’ve said they were papering over cracks, rising to small occasions and being exposed for the ordinary team they were any time that the result really mattered.

But you can’t finesse your way to success against the Springboks at home. You have cop some bumps and bruises and that’s what I want to see from the All Blacks this weekend.

I get that Will Jordan and Leroy Carter are able to do good things when given space, but I think it looks a bit weak to not try and bang the front door down first.

Let Rassie Erasmus fuss and fume. Let the great and the good of South African rugby pat themselves on the back because the series now stands at 1-1.

Then be brave, be physical. Stand up to the bully boys of world rugby and see where that gets you.

The All Blacks aren’t far off.

Watch Rugby's Greatest Rivalry LIVE

Two rugby giants collide. Stream live, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV. 

Watch on RPTV

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

4 Comments
R
Rugby3 40 mins ago

It appears the Boks are only just starting to find their rhythm.

c
cnw 51 mins ago

Agree with this. The Boks at home must be the standard for any team. The ABs have been schooled at scrum and line out - but they have also sliced open the Boks defence nine times in two weeks. Also agree that we need to back our players to go direct as well as around - we have great carriers - eg, Lakai, Aumua, Sititi, Numia, Tavatavanawai, Semisi, Taukei’aho, Paddy and it’s coming time to use them - perhaps not Test 3 - but soon. And if we lose trying to explode out of the blocks - so be it.

G
GrahamVF 1 hr ago

The bully boys of world rugby vs the crying custard baby - “sir they’re cheating” can you imagine Griz Wiley saying that.

B
BH 43 mins ago

Question: who was the coach who has been swearing and moaning his arse off?


Hint: It was the same guy that made a 1 hour long video crying about the refereeing in 2021.


2nd Hint: It wasn’t the same guys that didn’t bite back when asked by the media about the first guy’s moaning.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close