Northern | US

'10 games off the bench': Ex-All Black's theory on Kyle Preston selection

Kyle Preston of New Zealand during the New Zealand v South Africa Rugby Championship match at Eden Park on September 6, 2025 in Auckland, New Zealand. (Photo by Craig Butland/MB Media/Getty Images)
Comments
44 Comments

One of the most surprising names in Dave Rennie’s first All Black squad was not a debutant, but second year halfback Kyle Preston from the Crusaders.

ADVERTISEMENT

The three halfbacks who made the cut were Hurricanes star Cam Roigard, Chiefs’ Cortez Ratima and Kyle Preston.

Preston beat out a handful of capped All Black No.9s, including his club teammate at the Crusaders Noah Hotham who had started all year ahead of him in Christchurch.

Video Spacer

Cheslin Kolbe injury – overenthusiastic or plain stupidity

Video Spacer

Cheslin Kolbe injury – overenthusiastic or plain stupidity

Blues halfback Finlay Christie, with 28-Test caps, also missed out. Christie started the Eden Park Test against the Springboks last year, which was Preston’s All Black debut where he had a handful of minutes off the bench.

“Let’s talk about Finlay Christie as well, Noah Hotham? Why did they miss out? Why was Kyle Preston elevated above them?” Sky TV host Jeff McTainsh asked the panel on The Breakdown special.

“10 games off the bench for the Crusaders this year. Kyle Preston, you talked maybe about Mike Blair, guys wanting to see something out of his halfbacks going into the series?”

Ex-All Black hooker James Parsons identified one unique aspect of Preston’s game that might have led to his selection as the third No.9.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Well, look, you’ve got to acknowledge he kicks off both feet and at Test match level, and the pressure that’s around the contestable game without escorts, he’s pretty accurate with the boot, you know,” Parsons said.

“I thought Noah would finish really strong for the for the Crusaders, but they’ve obviously seen something in Kyle that they need in their game plan.”

Preston’s role with the Crusaders was as a finisher, wearing the 21 jersey all season long which perhaps factored into the decision-making with Preston considered a specialist closer in that regard.

 

Register your interest to receive priority updates on RWC27 ticket releases. Don't miss out, stay in the loop!


ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

44 Comments
J
JW 43 days ago

Yeah hopefully this coach is good enough to stop that from happening, not that I’ve really seen it evident at int level.


I don’t think you’re likely to see any different pudding. These things you describe haven’t been seen by him in black and one would just expect him to continue providing the best test option (though that could change if someone was prepared to go with Love). Nothing great, just a solid test controller and backline enabler. It’s saying a lot when those simple things are so precious!

C
Conrad 44 days ago

Roigard has the best kicking game in the SH, possibly the sport. Preston looks tidy and is two footed.


Don’t really understand how Ratima is there?

R
RD 45 days ago

One of the things I admired about Perenara was how despite having a different tempo from Aaron it never felt disruptive. If Kerr-Barlow came off the bench everything would become a shambles, TJ would slow it down a bit but the backline still functioned, Weber was also decent off the bench, Ratima conversely isn't.


To me the bench isn't where you put your second best players, it's where you put your best bench players, if Kyle is more accustomed to the bench role then he's inherently going to be less disruptive when replacing Roigard, hopefully he moves back to Wellington and they form a coherent 1-2 combo

P
POHM 44 days ago

Bugger off you didn't want him, now he's a Crusader for life.

J
JW 45 days ago

I like that take. Not so much TJs tempo but I see what you’re trying to say there, and hell you might even be right.

B
B 45 days ago

Preston’s first cap AB’s performance at Eden Park was solid and then was replaced at Sky Stadium with Hotham who lasted 9 minutes and subbed with Christie!?!?…


Cam and Cortez both looked physically fit and injury free during the SRP final from where I sat..I'm happy for the chosen half backs with their skill sets, the reason why…

I
Inbetweener 45 days ago

I dont think Ratima should’ve been picked, hes too slow behind the scrum/ruck/indecisive like the Roigard/Preston/Holtham. Then again BB shouldn't be there.

J
JW 45 days ago

Don’t think Roigard or Preston are indecisive.

B
Bazzallina 46 days ago

Both Cam and Cortez are left footed Preston can kick off both they don’t have to change chase block setups so much on box kicks

R
RD 45 days ago

I thought Cam could kick off both

C
Cantab 46 days ago

This is of course only the FIRST squad of the year and the ABs would be expected to win comfortably enough against Italy, understrength France & Ireland. There are several players to come back from injury absence and some players who have missed out for now can still put their hands up for later selection. South Africa will provide Rennie with his acid test.

B
Bazzallina 45 days ago

France are bringing a strong squad Cantab questions will be asked about their front rowers but you would expect Lucu Jalibert to start for example they ain’t coming to make up numbers but playing with the cards they gave been dealt and it’s not a bad hand ABs are going to have to be on point should be a good one

S
SB 46 days ago

He should put pressure on Ratima’s spot.

I
Icefarrow 46 days ago

Rennie said Hotham was dropped due to ruck speed. Preston gets quicker ball, and can box kick well unlike Hotham, who can barely make 20 metres.

T
Two Cents 46 days ago

Noah and Christie have both never shone at international level and were fairly pedestrian for the Saders and Blues this year.


Preston has a higher ceiling than both and it's a fitting reward for his continuing high performance to finally get a shot at the big time, especially in the lead in to the tour.

J
JW 45 days ago

Noah has definitely shone at the international level, but not so much for his general skill-set, just his superb running game.

j
johnz 46 days ago

A better question would be whether Ratima deserves a spot. He’s so pedestrian at test level - like a deer in the headlights.


I noticed how much the game sped up when Christie replaced Ratima on occasions last season. And I’m no Christie fan, but credit where it’s due, he looks so much more comfortable at test level than Ratima.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close