Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'Some of the those tackles were absolutely appalling'

Zoe Aldcroft of England runs with the ball as Dannah O'Brien and Aoife Dalton of Ireland attempt to stop her during the Guinness Women's Six Nations 2024 match between England and Ireland at Twickenham Stadium on April 20, 2024 in London, England. (Photo by Alex Broadway/Getty Images)

The Ireland Women’s team’s 88-10 hammering at the hands of England in the Women’s Six Nations has been described as unacceptable by commentators.

ADVERTISEMENT

It’s even worse than the 48-0 drubbing the women in green received in the same fixture in last season, suggesting the gap is growing between the sides.

The performance has sparked its fair share of criticism.

Ireland struggled defensively throughout the game, missing 61 tackles which translated into a poor 71 percent tackle completion rate. This meant they failed to make a successful tackle one out of every five attempts.

Video Spacer

England Women’s coach John Mitchell on the Red Roses squad

Video Spacer

England Women’s coach John Mitchell on the Red Roses squad

The contrast England demonstrated superior skill and execution, making 24 linebreaks and 18 offloads while gaining 1,067 valuable metres out of their total 1,547 metres carried. The Red Roses capitalized on Ireland’s sloppiness, amassing 14 tries in front of a record crowd of 48,778 spectators. Standout performances came from Abby Dow and Ellie Kildunne, each completing hat-tricks. Megan Jones and Jess Breach also made significant contributions with two tries apiece.

Kildunne in particular dazzled with her athleticism and sharp attacking skills being a constant threat throughout the game. Her ability to break from deep positions was highlighted by a cunning dummy kick that turned defensive play into attack.

Despite the overwhelming scoreline, Ireland managed a penalty try reflecting their persistent if ineffective effort, but it wasn’t enough to put any respectability on the scoreline.

Former Ireland Women’s internationals speaking on Virgin Sport did their best not to put the boot into the Irish side, but it proved an almost impossible task given the dire nature of their defending.

ADVERTISEMENT

Former Ireland outside back Eimear Considine said: “They will be really working hard on tackling this week. Individually, they’ll be wanting to make 100 tackles before heading into that Scotland game… That was below the standard of any of those girls and they will all think that and I know they will think that.”

Former Ireland prop and Six Nations winner Fiona Hayes was even more direct in her appraisal of the performance.

“Let’s be honest, some of those tackles were absolutely appalling,” Hayes said after the bloodbath. “If a player can say, that won’t happen to me next week, I promise you I’m going to do better, because sometimes when you’re in the heat of battle you can’t change that.”

Former outside centre Jenny Murphy said a lot of players needed to ‘look in the mirror’.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Speaking about honesty, a lot of players are going to have to look in the mirror. Some of the best feedback and toughest feedback you get is not from your coach, but it’s from your teammates. If they are a close-knit team that is driving to be better, then there are certain standards that are to be expected.

“I imagine you see some of the leadership come down on some of those players, saying ‘This is what is expected of you. This is what you need to work on’…In some areas, it was just not good enough.”

Related

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

2 Comments
Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

c
cw 1 hour ago
The coaching conundrum part one: Is there a crisis Down Under?

Thanks JW for clarifying your point and totally agree. The ABs are still trying to find their mojo” - that spark of power that binds and defines them. Man the Boks certainly found theirs in Wellington! But I think it cannot be far off for ABs - my comment about two coaches was a bit glib. The key point for me is that they need first a coach or coaches that can unlock that power and for me that starts at getting the set piece right and especially the scrum and second a coach that can simplify the game plans. I am fortified in this view by NBs comment that most of the ABs tries come from the scrum or lineout - this is the structured power game we have been seeing all year. But it cannot work while the scrum is backpeddling. That has to be fixed ASAP if Robertson is going to stick to this formula. I also think it is too late in the cycle to reverse course and revert to a game based on speed and continuity. The second is just as important - keep it simple! Complex movements that require 196 cm 144 kg props to run around like 95kg flankers is never going to work over a sustained period. The 2024 Blues showed what a powerful yet simple formula can do. The 2025 Blues, with Beauden at 10 tried to be more expansive / complicated - and struggled for most of the season.

I also think that the split bench needs to reflect the game they “want” to play not follow some rote formula. For example the ABs impact bench has the biggest front row in the World with two props 195cm / 140 kg plus. But that bulk cannot succeed without the right power based second row (7, 4, 5, 6). That bulk becomes a disadvantage if they don’t have a rock solid base behind them - as both Boks showed at Eden Park and the English in London. Fresh powerful legs need to come on with them - thats why we need a 6-2 bench. And teams with this split can have players focused only on 40 minutes max of super high intensity play. Hence Robertson needs to design his team to accord with these basic physics.



...

220 Go to comments
Close
ADVERTISEMENT