Northern | US

Ulster player ratings vs Leinster | 2024/25 URC

at Aviva Stadium, Dublin

Jack Murphy of Ulster in action against Gus McCarthy of Leinster during the United Rugby Championship match between Leinster and Ulster at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin. (Photo By Brendan Moran/Sportsfile via Getty Images)
Comments
Comment

Ulster player ratings: Ulster started brightly but faded after the opening 20 minutes as Leinster took control of this URC contest, ending up on the wrong end of 41-17 scoreline.

ADVERTISEMENT

A few individual efforts stood out, but it was a tough night overall for the province in Dublin. Here’s how we rated the players.

1. Andrew Warwick – 7.5
Carried well and scrummaged with authority against Clarkson, though the officials rarely sided with him. His evening was cut short just before half-time due to injury.

2. Rob Herring – 6
Workmanlike throughout. Got through his set-piece duties but struggled to make an impact on the other side of the ball.

3. Tom O’Toole – 6
Held his own defensively but the scrum was an inconsistent battle and a bit of a lottery ultimately. Stuck at it with little reward.

4. Alan O’Connor – 6
Reliable in the lineout and never shied from the fight. One of Ulster’s more composed performers.

5. Cormac Izuchukwu – 8
A standout. Commanded the lineout and showed rare athleticism for a lock in finishing his try. A bright return from injury.

ADVERTISEMENT

6. James McNabney – 7.5
An explosive 6’4, 116kg presence at blindside. Carried with intent and brought real physicality throughout. A big shift.

7. Nick Timoney – 6.5
A consistent breakdown threat and handled link duties well in limited attacking phases. Played above the general team standard.

8. David McCann – 5
Not as influential as his fellow back-rowers. A yellow card and penalty try for a collapsed maul capped a frustrating outing.

9. Nathan Doak – 7
Tactically sharp with his kicking and led with energy. Let himself down with a poor moment covering O’Brien’s try.

ADVERTISEMENT

10. Jack Murphy – 6
Had patches of involvement but couldn’t control proceedings. Took a heavy hit from Jimmy O’Brien and was on the edge of the game for stretches.

11. Jacob Stockdale – 8
Ulster’s most dangerous back. Beat multiple defenders and asked serious questions of Leinster’s defence when given space.

12. Stuart Moore – NA
Departed for a HIA after just 15 minutes.

13. Jude Postlethwaite – 5
Survived defensively but failed to leave a mark in attack. Limited opportunities.

14. Zac Ward – 5.5
Physically imposing but made several errors. The Sevens athlete has plenty of athletic ability but this was an altogether messy outing.

15. Mike Lowry – NA
Looked electric early on and caused problems in broken play. His exit after 20 minutes with a neck injury was a big blow.

REPLACEMENTS:

16. Tom Stewart – 5
A key missed throw in the Leinster 22 summed up a difficult cameo.

17. Callum Reid – 5
Injured soon after coming on. No real impact.

18. Scott Wilson – 5
Caught with a big hit that resulted in a turnover. Struggled to settle.

19. Matthew Dalton – 7
Took his try well and brought real aggression off the bench.

20. Kieran Treadwell – 6.5
Physical and willing. Added some steel in the closing stages.

21. John Cooney – 7
A classy assist for Izuchukwu and tried to lift Ulster with his energy and vision.

22. Wilhelm de Klerk – 5.5
On early due to Moore’s injury but struggled to assert himself. Quiet overall.

23. Matty Rea – 5.5
Limited minutes and little involvement of note with Leinster turning the breakdown into a total mess.

Related

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

U
Utiku Old Boy 53 minutes ago
All Blacks dig deep to deny Stormers in ill-disciplined RGR opener

Good perspective Graham. That is the value of this tour for this AB touring group. Being exposed to the traditional SA style of aggressive, skilled big men who can dominate the set piece - and now adding an attacking dimension through the Rassie/Brown influence. IF Rennie can get the ABs playing their historical game, or at least growing back into it, he/they cannot ignore having to deal with a highly efficient and dominant set-piece team who have added dimensions to their game. In the development phase, we are some distance from the Boks, but because we are trying to play our high tempo, ruthless “AB” game - as well as cope with strong opponents (SA, France, Argentina, England, Ireland) we have a lot of work-ons. What has been admirable about Rassie developing his team is his willingness to test players and systems with an occasional loss seeming to be “acceptable” as part of the process. NZ fans are not so understanding and expectations of winning - even in development - are always high. I think the “trajectory” rationale for changing our HC was necessary because the previous group with an “okay” winning percentage was not seen as AB rugby - the game plan was not integral to the NZ game. Getting that re-established - and then (like Rassie) adding dimensions to that AB game is a long process and the timelines are not favorable. The SA fan base crowing about how the ABs will get dealt with in the tests (if they play like the team facing the Stormers) might be missing the value of these games for re-establishing the AB game so they can also add to their traditional strengths the required steel and techniques to handle any opposition. The AB squad gained a lot from that exposure. Will that exposure result in a series win? Highly unlikely. But the overall project will benefit greatly.

170 Go to comments
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close