Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

The Rugby World Cup wound Scotland just inflicted on themselves

Scotland's wing Darcy Graham reacts to their defeat after the Autumn Nations Series international rugby union match between Scotland and Argentina at Murrayfield in Edinburgh on November 16, 2025. Argentina staged an astonishing rally as they came from 21-0 behind to beat Scotland 33-24 in an Autumn Nations Series rugby international at Murrayfield on Sunday. (Photo by ANDY BUCHANAN / AFP) (Photo by ANDY BUCHANAN/AFP via Getty Images)

Scotland didn’t just blow a massive lead at Murrayfield; they have blown their shot at a top pool seeding for Rugby World Cup 2027.

ADVERTISEMENT

And in truth, they only have themselves to blame after throwing away a 21-point advantage.

The 33-24 defeat to Argentina means Scotland have fallen short of the top-six ranking cutoff that decides the first-tier seeds for the draw on 3 December.

The maths is grim for Gregor Townsend’s side. Argentina won’t shed enough points even if they lose to England next weekend, and Australia won’t gain enough even if they beat France, suggesting the top six is pretty much set.

VIDEO

Effectively, Scotland’s route to a favourable draw has gone up in smoke like the discharge from one of Edinburgh’s famous canons.

And the manner of it will sting almost as much as the consequences.

The men in dark blue were booed from the field after capitulating in astonishing fashion, conceding five tries in the last half-hour to a Pumas team that had offered almost nothing until Scotland handed them a lifeline.

It had all looked so simple early on. Forced into a late reshuffle with Ben White ruled out through illness, Scotland still started fast. With Juan Cruz Mallia in the bin after a deliberate knock-on five minutes in, Jack Dempsey steamed through a soft gap on 13 minutes and Finn Russell knocked over the extras.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ewan Ashman – twice – then powered over either side of half-time, both times slipped in smartly by the excellent Jamie Dobie. At 21-0 after 44 minutes, Argentina were drifting and Murrayfield was relaxed.

Then came the turning point: an over-ambitious Russell pass, picked off to spark a counter-attack that ended with Blair Kinghorn sent to the bin for cynically shutting down the break. What followed looked like a side unravelling in slow motion.

Julian Montoya’s try broke the dam in the 57th minute after a lengthy TMO check. Rodrigo Isgo followed three minutes later. Russell briefly steadied things with a long-range penalty to make it 24-12, but momentum had already flipped on its axis.

Pedro Rubiolo muscled over to cut the gap to five with ten minutes left. Pablo Matera then forced the ball onto the line – another TMO decision going Argentina’s way – and Santiago Carreras’ conversion pushed the visitors ahead for the first time.

ADVERTISEMENT

By now the collapse was total. Justo Piccardo’s 79th-minute sprint for Argentina’s fifth try sealed a remarkable turnaround and Scotland’s most self-inflicted defeat in years.

A first home loss to the Pumas since 2009 is damaging enough. But the bigger wound may not show until 2027 – when Scotland walk into a World Cup draw that just got a whole lot tougher.

Related

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

19 Comments
D
Dave Didley 29 days ago

Warriors won a brilliant URC title - the hard way - and two seasons later, the national team is still sliding backwards. No bounce from it at all.


It’s not like they don’t have talent in that match day 23 either.


It seems that knocking over England most 6 Nations was all that kept him in the job.

M
Mike Gibson 29 days ago

The extreme headline “booing” etc used to get the most clicks. People are catching on.

The story here is Scotland’s blowing their chance at a top seeding on the way to blowing the match. A supporter or two booing is expected and not news.

M
Mike Gibson 29 days ago

A 16 point win would have meant Scotland just about making the top 6 before the final round next weekend. Argentina would have needed to draw or beat England.

21-0 up and Argentina needing a broken match, Russell throws a hail Mary 5 metres from the Argentina try line. Argentina Intercept and score 2 mins later with a Scot in the sin-bin. Townsend amazingly didn’t match the Argentinian bombsquad and we saw the rest. SA have lead the way by creating mismatches in the last 20 and scoring huge amounts.

But at 21-0 if Russell shows composure Scotland are 28-0 up and their world cup dream alive.

I am devastated for Scotland. The draw they got in 2023 was utterly disgraceful. But this was an own goal today in Edinburgh.

C
Carlos 29 days ago

The fans did NOT boo Scotland off the field! What nonsense. I was there.

A
Archibald 29 days ago

Are you calling Ian Cameron a liar?

A
A S 30 days ago

Ah yes, Scotland, famous for its story continuities. Jokes aside, Scotland brought this on themselves by refusing to replace Townsend and extending his contract to 2027. Yet more final quarter collapses, and “plucky defeats” incoming.

J
JH 30 days ago

A “canon” is a kind of priest. It’s possible that some of Edinburgh’s priests are notorious chain smokers, but I think you mean “cannons”. These are very big guns and they smoke. Just because you are a sports reporter doesn’t mean you have to be a complete idiot…

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close
ADVERTISEMENT