Northern | US

Springboks player ratings vs All Blacks | 3rd Test Rugby's Greatest Rivalry 2026


South Africa's hooker Malcolm Marx celebrates after scoring a try during the third Rugby's Greatest Rivalry international rugby union match between South Africa and New Zealand at the FNB Stadium in Johannesburg, on September 5, 2026. (Photo by GIANLUIGI GUERCIA / AFP)
Comments
40 Comments

South Africa player ratings: The Springboks built a 2-1 lead in Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry series on Saturday, defeating the All Blacks 29-24 at FNB Stadium.

ADVERTISEMENT

Just like the first Test in Johannesburg, there was nothing to separate the two sides at the break, with a 12-12 scoreline meaning everything was to play for.

But similarly to the first Test, the Boks appeared to spurn a few chances. However, on this occasion it did not come back to haunt them.

VIDEO

Rassie Erasmus’ side did not take their foot off in the second half, with the scrum continuing to dominate and the replacements adding real value.

The Boks now know they cannot lose the series as they head to the United States for the fourth Test. Here’s how the players rated:

Match Summary

1
Penalty Goals
0
4
Tries
4
2
Conversions
2
0
Drop Goals
0
95
Carries
130
6
Line Breaks
12
14
Turnovers Lost
16
6
Turnovers Won
7

15 Cheslin Kolbe – N/A
Cleaned up the backfield nicely, particularly a chip and chase by Will Jordan, and cleared the ball well from deep, but was forced from the field after only 10 minutes and failed his HIA.

14 Kurt-Lee Arendse – 7
Went over in the corner for the Boks’ first try, which was fairly rudimentary for a player of his class. But he frequently threatened with his carries.

ADVERTISEMENT

13 Jesse Kriel – 8
Struggled to make a defining mark on the match – with his highlight maybe being a basic knock-on in the first half – but came alive after the break by wrestling free of Leroy Carter and running it in from 40 metres to give the Boks the lead on the hour mark. Linked nicely with Damian de Allende for a break in the closing minutes.

12 Damian de Allende – 8.5
Produced the footwork and fend to put Arendse in for the Boks’ opening try. Withstood everything that was thrown down his channel defensively, putting in 11 tackles. Put Kriel in for a break late on, then pulled off a turnover on the ground minutes later as the Boks were just playing with the visitors.

11 Ethan Hooker – 8.5
Produced a vital turnover when the All Blacks were fizzing after 25 minutes – his work at the breakdown proved surprisingly effective. Thrived in the unglamorous parts of the game – chased kicks and was strong in the air. That perhaps cost him, though, as he was sucked in trying to compete on the floor when Leroy Carter broke through, rather than covering the pop from the floor, which gave Jordan a try – maybe that’s being harsh.

10 Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu – 7
Can have no complaints about his yellow card in the opening 10 minutes for a deliberate knock-on, and on another day it could have easily been a penalty try too (the All Blacks did score soon after anyway). Upon coming on, he inadvertently tapped the ball back in a ruck, allowing Ardie Savea to pounce for his second try. Managed the game well, not necessarily turning to his bag of tricks but pulling the strings with his boot. Pulled off some smart defensive reads as well. Played the majority of the match at full-back, where he was able to get his hands on the ball in space. Sharing the playmaking responsibilities with Manie Libbok seemed quite liberating for the 24-year-old, meaning he wasn’t guilty of forcing too much.

ADVERTISEMENT

9 Cobus Reinach – 6
Penalised for an off-ball skirmish with Cam Roigard during the Boks’ penalty try, but, to his relief, the try still stood. That was fortunate, as the entire Bok attack came from his turnover on halfway, when he rushed out the line to meet hooker Asafo Aumua, and ripped the ball out of his clutches – one of the most important moments of the match. That was a moment of real quality, but he was ponderous on the ball at times. Only lasted a couple of minutes in the second half before being replaced.

1 Ox Nche – 8
Showed the movement and handling of an outside back when he supported Jasper Wiese to make a break late in the first half and send Manie Libbok towards the try-line. The try didn’t come from that attack, but the Boks opted for a scrum after an All Blacks penalty and Nche showed the other side to his game (the one he is renowned for), driving his way for a penalty try. Clearly on top in the scrum.

2 Malcolm Marx – 9
Hit a long throw to Jasper Wiese in the Boks’ first attack, but they couldn’t profit from the momentum. It was over an hour before Marx got over the ball to win his first penalty, but it was a huge one in his own half which really shifted momentum. At the back of an insatiable driving maul which powered over with 15 minutes remaining. Lineout functioned perfectly as well. The World Rugby player of the year stood up.

3 Wilco Louw – 8.5
Got a good shove in on the first scrum after seven minutes, but the All Blacks were able to get the ball out quickly. Second scrum was even, but he came up with the penalty with his third on 16 minutes. Part of the monster scrummaging effort moments before half time as the Boks drove over for a penalty try. Racked up another penalty on the 50-minute mark in another dominant display, but that was his last action. Got through some work defensively, but not many people are interested in that, in truth.

4 Eben Etzebeth – 6
Knocked the ball on from the base of a ruck when the Boks had the All Blacks under pressure in the first half, as things started to look eerily similar to the first Test. Only managed 56 minutes this week, which contain a solitary carry and five tackles. Unable to trouble the All Blacks’ lineout like he did last week.

5 Ruan Nortje – 7.5
Powered towards the line in the Boks’ first promising attack, but actually isolated himself slightly, allowing Peter Lakai to get over the ball. Tireless in the engine room yet again, putting in the most tackles, 12, for the Boks.

6 Siya Kolisi – 7
Brought some real grunt to his carrying and most promising Bok phases of play usually had a strong Kolisi carry in there. Led the match for tackles, 11, when he was substituted before the hour mark.

7 Pieter-Steph du Toit – 7.5
Just grew and grew in influence as the match developed, and by the time the match reached the final quarter, he seemed to have as much energy as the replacements coming on. Nailed carriers behind the gain line with some trademark brutal hits, but maybe didn’t hit the defensive numbers Bok fans have become accustomed to.

8 Jasper Wiese – 8
Was experiencing a muted first half with ball in hand by his standards, but produced a key moment of brute power after 35 minutes to bust through a tackle and put Ox Nche away. Led the Boks for carries, 9, when he left the field on 61 minutes, and also had the joint-most tackles with Kolisi, and even a turnover. Great stats, sprinkled with a moment of class – game-changing class.

Replacements

16 Deon Fourie – 6
Came on as a flanker before shifting to hooker. Settled in nicely but didn’t do too much.

17 Gerhard Steenekamp – 7
Chipped in with a scrum penalty of his own in the 65th minute. At the heart of a driving maul in the final quarter, which the Boks scored from and built a nine-point lead.

18 Thomas du Toit – 6
Pinged for walking around moments after coming on – Dave Rennie would have had a wry smile. But the scrum was solid thereafter.

19 Lood de Jager – 6
Fairly quiet, but didn’t put a foot wrong.

20 Andre Esterhuizen – 6
Came on in the pack late on and saw very little action.

21 Cameron Hanekom – 6.5
Put in a hit-and-drive which resulted in a penalty in the Boks’ half in the final 10 minutes as everything seemed to be going the way of the world champions.

22 Morne van den Berg – 7.5
Injected real energy in the second half, got through a mountain of tackles, and kicked well in a tricky wind that wasn’t in the Boks’ favour.

23 Manie Libbok – 7.5
Called into action after only 10 minutes, as he was initially manning a six-man backline. Almost stepped and pirouetted his way to the line before the break, which would have been a superb solo effort. Shouldered the playmaking responsibilities alongside Feinberg-Mngomezulu, which worked well and manned the backfield adroitly.

Related

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

40 Comments
S
SunChaser 45 days ago

We don’t appreciate Siya - he is criminally under scored every week

H
HenryAU 45 days ago

Votes are in, close the polls .. Malcolm Marx WRPOTY .. back to back.

r
rhubsch 45 days ago

Something is wrong with the app, cannot open and display articles to read. Been 2 weeks now.

P
PR 45 days ago

I would give Nika Amashukeli a 9.5 for SA. Clearly he wants to referee the next world cup final and you’re not going get that if you have upset Rassie.

u
unknown 45 days ago

I would give him a 10. Brilliant ref who was not biased and was very good with his decision making. Deserves to ref a RWC final. Although your comment was clearly sarcastic and revealing, at least you believe that the Springboks will be in the final next year. Being bitter is only hurting you and not your enemy. Try to get some sleep over the next week. Ps. Do not bet if you can't afford to lose!

J
J T 45 days ago

Manie was good and biggest difference was losing Ardie and Love not playing with confidence and effectiveness

D
DK 45 days ago

I understand player ratings are based on personal opinion, but as professionals, journos should be held to a higher standard. Looking at these ratings one would think the Boks steam rolled NZ. Im a Bok supporter and i think the baseline Bok ratings should be 7s with NZ coming in at 6s. If you were really a stand out like Ardie you can be rated with an 8

u
unknown 45 days ago

Just a mention of the ref. A completely different level to the previous refs in this series. Although not every decision favoured the Boks I thought that he was absolutely brilliant. His positioning at all times, his decision making and his communication was elite level. Wish he was allocated to ref next weekend again.

W
Wayneo 45 days ago

Wow, these RP journalists are sour.

H
Hammer Head 45 days ago

Speaking of. Can’t wait for Ben’s spin on this. Should be great.

H
Hammer Head 45 days ago

Harsh on Hanekom and Libbok. Thought both were great.

G
GrahamVF 45 days ago

Agreed. I get why Jasper starts ahead of Hanekom but I think Hanekom should come on earleir - say 50 minutes. Libbok had a great game.

A
Ayre123 None 45 days ago

Well done the Boks, the left no leeway for the ABs!

Rennie’s being Rennie, enhanced his faith in the Fijians/Samoans to beat the mighty Boks at their homeground, he hasn’t learned a thing from the Robertson (failed) Experiment😂, he’s well on track to 1:3.

T
Tryrannosaurus Rex 45 days ago

As an all blacks fan I am entirely disappointed with the direction of the team right now. They really need to turn this ship around for the fourth test. 🫤

D
Drewski 45 days ago

I think the ABs played outstanding and held their own. Not much between the teams. I would argue the ABs’ set pieces were not to as good and discipline were lacking over the 3 test matches, with 23.5% more penalties. The Boks did well to capatilise on that, by taking points when needed. Other than that the ABs look a lot better than a year ago. SB fan.

A
AussieBokkie 45 days ago

Man you have very unrealistic expectations. Look at what Rennie has done in a matter of months! The way he’s building this team, I’d almost say the ABs will go into the RWC as favourites

D
DT 45 days ago

That’s incredibly harsh. As a bok supporter I have been so impressed with how well the ABs have played. Springboks have been under Rassie for almost a decade while Rennie hasn't even had a full season. The fact that the games are still this close is a testament to how high this AB's ceiling is.


Really looking forward to the world cup next year, pity these two teams probably won't be in the final together.

u
unknown 45 days ago

As a Bokke fan I think we are getting better with each game, especially the defense was a lot better and the backs are also gelling more and more.

I cannot see the AB's winning the next one, there was nothing today that shows they are improving.

u
unknown 45 days ago

Ruben Love wins soccer player of the day for his acting after that little incident with Reinach.

H
Hammer Head 45 days ago

Shirley Maclean strikes again

H
HS 45 days ago

Roigard

H
Hammer Head 45 days ago

Siya was massive today.

H
HS 45 days ago

Well done Boks. No questioning about scrums after this week, if there was any to start with.


Hope Ardie's injury is not too bad.


Ref really good. Totally different than last week.

H
Hammer Head 45 days ago

Agreed. Much better test match level refereeing.


Although that penalty against Reinach was a pair of bollocks.

p
pm 45 days ago

Love’s place KiCking was a big let down & Lost the AB’s the game .. Boks were the better TeaM

H
HS 45 days ago

Boks will target Leroy Carter going forward.

C
CHILLI 45 days ago

😣 poor all moans did a doodoo again just like 95. We’ll be waiting for their excuses again 😆

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close