Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Springbok player ratings vs Argentina | The Rugby Championship

JOHANNESBURG, SOUTH AFRICA - AUGUST 31: Springboks head coach Rassie Erasmus during the Castle Lager Rugby Championship match between South Africa and New Zealand at Emirates Airline Park on August 31, 2024 in Johannesburg, South Africa. (Photo by Gordon Arons/Gallo Images/Getty Images)

Argentina beat the world champions South Africa 29-28 in an incredible test match at the Estadio Único Madre de Ciudades on Saturday evening.

ADVERTISEMENT

Hearts would have been in the mouths of each and every Springbok supporter this evening as Manie Libbok stepped up to kick what should have been the match-winner. Each heartbeat thumped louder than the last as the talented number ten stepped up to the tee.

The result of the next two seconds would come as a surrounding deflation amongst a nation as the kick went wide.

Here’s how we rated the Springbok players:

1 Ox Nche – 9.5

Stick him in the backs and he’d put a shift in there. Solid in the scrum, and deadly with ball in hand. Deserved to be on the winning side. A colossal performance.

2 Malcolm Marx – 5

Pretty ineffectual throughout and missed a couple of important tackles.

3 Thomas du Toit – 7.5

Like his front-row teammate, Du Toit was dominant in the scrum before he was taken off and sorely missed.

ADVERTISEMENT

Match Summary

1
Penalty Goals
0
7
Tries
1
5
Conversions
1
0
Drop Goals
0
141
Carries
86
17
Line Breaks
3
19
Turnovers Lost
15
2
Turnovers Won
5

4 Salmaan Moerat – 5

Ferocious in defence, but offered little else. The experiment may well be done.

5 Ruan Nortje – 7

Another player who ran truly under the radar. His running game was solid and he was vital in the lineout.

6 Marco van Staden – 5.5

ADVERTISEMENT

He conducted a tremendous turnover at the breakdown early on to stop an almost certain Argentinian try. Defensively, however, he was poor, missing three tackles in vital areas.

7 Ben-Jason Dixon – 6

He settled into the game well by making a fantastic break early on which was finished by the impressive Jesse Kriel under the sticks. Besides that, it was a relatively quiet game from Dixon.

8 Jasper Wiese – 6

You can’t knock his performance. It was solid, efficient, and everything you would expect from an international number 8. Sadly it was too average to make a major difference against an inspired Argentinian side.

Turnovers

2
Turnovers Won
5
19
Turnovers Lost
15

9 Cobus Reinach – 6.5

Started the game like his teammates, world class. His fluid passes from the base of the ruck were next level. He excelled when being used as a playmaker, and put in a huge defensive effort before being suitably rewarded with a wonderfully taken try. Sadly his performance dwindled from there. Once Argentina turned up the pace, he was no longer in control, and his team suffered as a result.

10 Handre Pollard – 6

It was as well be a copy and paste of the above. A wonderful early touch-finder led to a brilliant bullet pass to set up the opener. His display quickly hit the off button, however, and his early brilliance quickly became a thing of distant memory.

11 Makazole Mapimpi – 5

He put his body on the line when needed, but in reality his defence was poor and offered little in attack. Will be disappointed with this rare start.

12 Lukhanyo Am – 7.5

Appeared panicky in the early stages, but settled in well at inside centre. The future of the Springbok midfield partnership remains up in the air.

13 Jesse Kriel – 8

Joining up with Lukhanyo Am, Kriel showed wonderful cohesion with the backline throughout and scored a well-worked try early on. His incredible talents were on full display through, particularly during an early play when he collected a crossfield kick from Handre Pollard before flicking the ball over his shoulder.

14 Kurt-Lee Arendse – 6.5

The speedy didn’t start well, He was pushed into touch early on and things didn’t look up when he was sent to the bin for a high tackle. He did look dangerous on the kick return, however, and will come away from the game with plenty to work on.

15 Aphelele Fassi – 8

The talented fullback the early try well, sliding straight through the gap to set the world champions up for what many expected to be a comprehensive victory. He continued the match with incredible confidence, getting himself involved in each facet of the game, as he proved to be a valuable member of the national side.

Replacements – 5

Known for their incredible impact on most games, the Springbok replacements will be disappointed not to have made the pressure pay when they entered the field. It was a game in the balance, and few managed to tip it in the correct way – see Manie Libbok.

Video Spacer
ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

31 Comments
Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

S
SK 1 hour ago
The times are changing, and some Six Nations teams may be left behind

If you are building the same amount of rucks but kicking more is that a bad thing? Kicks are more constestable than ever, fans want to see a contest, is that a bad thing? kicks create broken field situations where counter attacks from be launched from or from which turnover ball can be exploited, attacks are more direct and swift rather than multiphase in nature, is that a bad thing? What is clear now is that a hybrid approach is needed to win matches. You can still build phases but you need to play in the right areas so you have to kick well. You also have to be prepared to play from turnover ball and transition quickly from the kick contest to attack or set your defence quickly if the aerial contest is lost. Rugby seems healthy to me. The rules at ruck time means the team in possession is favoured and its more possible than ever to play a multiphase game. At the same time kicking, set piece, kick chase and receipt seems to be more important than ever. Teams can win in so many ways with so many strategies. If anything rugby resembles footballs 4-4-2 era. Now football is all about 1 striker formations with gegenpress and transition play vs possession heavy teams, fewer shots, less direct play and crossing. Its boring and it plods along with moves starting from deep, passing goalkeepers and centre backs and less wing play. If we keep tinkering with the laws rugby will become a game with more defined styles and less variety, less ways to win effectively and less varied body types and skill sets.

284 Go to comments
Close
ADVERTISEMENT