Northern | US

Scott Robertson opens up on drama surrounding Bongi Mbonambi's knock-on try

Bongi Mbonambi of the Springboks in action during the Castle Lager Rugby Championship match between South Africa and New Zealand at Emirates Airline Park on August 31, 2024 in Johannesburg, South Africa. (Photo by Dirk Kotze/Gallo Images/Getty Images)
Comments
69 Comments

All Blacks head coach Scott Roberston has revealed how the side tried to intervene to get Springboks’ hooker Bongi Mbonambi’s controversial try looked at in the Ellis Park Test last year.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Springboks were blindly awarded a try to Bongi Mbonambi breaking from the back off the maul against the All Blacks in Johannesburg, despite replays showing a clear knock-on by the hooker afterward.

The crucial five points scored by Mbonambi aided the Springboks in the final wash in their 31-27 win.

Video Spacer

Springbok coach Rassie Erasmus talks about the number of seasoned front row players unavailable

Video Spacer

Springbok coach Rassie Erasmus talks about the number of seasoned front row players unavailable

Robertson has revealed that they attempted to challenge the decision and alert the officials but referee Andrew Brace didn’t understand what they were requesting.

“Let’s use Bongi’s try, that wasn’t a try, that was a try,” Robertson told Justin Marshall in an exclusive interview for The Breakdown, “That’s a prime example.”

“Ellis Park, first Test, at that moment, you know it is not going to go up on the big screen, not at Ellis Park.

“So our analyst, who is always checking that stuff. He’ll say ‘it’s a knock-on Razor’, okay sweet, I go straight down to Scooter [Scott Barrett], “Scooter, get to Andrew Brace.”

ADVERTISEMENT

“Sacha at that stage was taking the kick [at goal]. Remember, he went too long on the kick, over 30 seconds.

“Scooter comes up to him [Brace] and goes “can you check the knock-on from Bongi?”, he goes “nah, nah, we’ve got the kick he’s over the 30 second limit”.

“Scooter goes “nah, nah, nah, we’re not worried about the kick, we’re worried about the try” and he goes “I’m not talking about the kick, he’s missed it.”

That got Scott Robertson up in arms and reacting to the drama unfolding on the field.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Anyway so there’s confusion around which one [we are asking about].

“We should’ve gone to the AR. Talk to him and get through so the guy upstairs can see it, because you’ve got until the kick off. The conversion’s done but you’ve got til the kick off, the next start of play.

“That’s when you see me animated, “Don’t kick it off D-Mac, hold the ball, hold the ball” and the ref’s going “kick it”.

“Those are the ones I’ve got to be a step ahead, I can’t get too emotional in that moment because I’ve got to think what’s next.”

Follow your favourites in the RugbyPass App

Your home for rugby. Download the RugbyPass app on the App Store (iOS) and Google Play (Android) now!


Follow your favourite teams, tournaments and players, and get personalised news and Match Centre notifications direct to your device.


From live rugby streams and upcoming fixtures to breaking news, in-depth analysis and live scores, RugbyPass has everything you need to stay connected to the game.

Visa Priority RWC2027 Ticket Sale: 28 - 30 Sept 2026

Register your ticketing account now for Visa Priority Sale access. Visa sale: 28 - 30 September, 2026

Create Account
Visa Priority Sale: eligible Visa card required. Restrictions apply.
ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

69 Comments
Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

N
NoLongerARuck 1 hour ago
Can the Wallabies evoke the spirit of 2021 to rock the world champions?

The Wallabies lineout is one area where they have maintained high standards throughout the years despite dropping to below 40% in term of win percentage. The Boks didnt get tested there against NZ and I expect Aus to certainly challenge there. This is as good an opportunity that Aus will get against the Boks. Its a new team with plenty of inexperience but Rassie has kept an experienced core for the lineout but Grobbelaars throwing can go awry when under pressure as we have seen in big matches for the Bulls. The Wallabies backline is also stacked with quality and theres some power on the bench too. For the first time in a long time the Wallabies have some depth to call upon and real quality options across the park. Even so this is a different Bok team than the one that exited covid. That team hadnt played in front of a crowd since 2019, had 18 months apart and barely had any cohesion. Their game plan was literally kick scrum and maul throughout the Lions series and the Argentina tests and they were very much a team that regressed since 2019. They had to recover their game and recover their conditioning and that was top of mind for coaches. Having said that the team that runs out this weekend has several green players with few minutes behind them in the past 2 months. They should be short of a gallop. Sure they have been training as a shadow team against the first team Boks but training is no substitute for game time. I expect them to be rusty and to lack cohesion and thats why this a good opportunity for an Australian team building momentum.

47 Go to comments
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close