Northern | US

Rassie Erasmus has tried to hide it, but he can't hide no more


Rassie Erasmus, the South Africa Springbok head coach, faces the media during the South Africa press conference at Southern Sun Hyde Park on July 06, 2026 in Sandton, South Africa. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)
Comments
89 Comments

Springboks head coach Rassie Erasmus has played his cards to the best of his ability, but he can’t hide it anymore.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Boks don’t have a Bomb Squad in this series.

The innovative tactic was a brilliant discovery, using data, stats and performance metrics to conclude that no matter what level of conditioning the forwards had, their effectiveness & power would drop by as much as a third in the final 20 minutes of a Test.

That was a significant finding as most heavyweight Test matches would be decided in the final 20 minutes. Not being able to hold up the maul or scrum could prove fatal with a penalty. Tired forwards unable to hold the gainline could also matter. Over 80 per cent of teams that win the gain line win the match.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

They also found that injuries to outside backs early in a game was statistically rare, so loading a bench with six or seven forwards was less risky than many thought.

So for a good three years the Bomb Squad helped the Springboks win the final quarter. The fresh pack gave South Africa power & strength when they needed it.

But the Springboks don’t have a Bomb Squad in this series and Erasmus has tried to mask it.

They’ve been outscored in both second 40s, by 21-3 at Ellis Park and by 12-9 in Cape Town, with the All Blacks storming back by 12-3 in the final 20 minutes.

In the first Test, after Steenekamp gave away the scrum penalty to the All Blacks, he pulled him for a reserve hooker.

ADVERTISEMENT

Steenekamp had already replaced Ox Nche after 45 minutes. Erasmus kept Malcolm Marx on for 80 minutes which meant he had to then put him on the bench for the 2nd Test.

That bench in Johannesburg cost the Springboks. Not just because they lost Kurt-Lee Arendse early which put pressure on the 6-2 split, but the performance also. Steenekamp couldn’t do what Ox did, Marco van Staden had a brain explosion and it cost him his place in the 23. Cobus Reinach also compounded matters with the second yellow.

The way the bench was managed also speaks to the lack of Bomb Squad impact with staggered introductions. He gave reserve lock Cobus Wiese just seven minutes, while the emotional decision to yank a fresh Steenekamp showed a lack of trust.

Knowing that Marx had played big minutes in game one, the front row with Nche, Marx and Louw were always going to be coming off the bench in game two. The finish was so bad in Johannesburg, they needed to reverse that.

ADVERTISEMENT

They got a fast start in Cape Town and then Erasmus gambled the entire series in the 35th minute by sending Ox Nche and Malcolm Marx into the game early with the Boks having a scrum five metres out. They held a slim 17-14 lead minutes from the half.

It was a brilliant tactical substitution. But had they blown that opportunity and not converted with a try to Siya Kolisi, they would have lost that game. The early introduction of that front row left them tired in the final 20 minutes, which saw the All Blacks dominate the final quarter.

Erasmus gambled to get a strong buffer on the scoreboard, and then turned to Kolbe’s boot to keep that cushion knowing that he had pulled the trigger early. It worked. Just. If you add five minutes to that game, the All Blacks have a high chance of equalising.

Now ahead of the third Test, the debt is due for playing his older veteran forwards for big minutes across the first two Tests.

Pieter-Steph du Toit, who looked way off the pace in the first Test coming back from injury, has played all 160 minutes. His second rowers, Eben Etzebeth and Ruan Nortje have played 153 and 147 minutes.

Erasmus doesn’t have locks. RG Snyman is the big omission, a world class lock who makes a big difference. Snyman is sidelined with a long-term injury. He doesn’t seem to think Lood de Jager is up to it returning from injury. He gave him only 13 minutes and then he got sin binned anyway.

He’s flogged his second rowers and named them again for the third Test, which will be at altitude this time.

Big Jasper Wiese was gassed in Cape Town after his showing in the first Test. He managed 21 metres on 11 carries and was shut down by the All Blacks. He’s now clocked 147 minutes. He’s named to start again. He’s only got 35 minutes in him this week.

Malcolm Marx is now at 125 minutes. Is he going to play 80 again like the first Test? Ox Nche and Wilco Louw are at 90 and 84 minutes.

So the first choice front row is back in the starting side. And they are tired. And they are playing at altitude.

Erasmus will be finally forced to rely on the second string unit, which is Deon Fourie, Gerhard Steenekamp and Premiership force Thomas du Toit.

Steenekamp has been a liability this series, Fourie was a stable pick while du Toit is fortunately relatively fresh. However, if Fourie is forced to play the second half at hooker, the All Blacks need to go after this part-time thrower relentlessly.

There’s just been one change to the Springboks 23, with winger Kurt-Lee Ardende returning. There are no fresh legs up front. There are old forwards with huge mileage now carrying big minutes.

They are heading to the Highveld where the All Blacks have won eight of the last 10, to a stadium where the All Blacks are 2-0. The Boks have conceded nine tries in two Tests already.

The wheels are about to fall off this pack. There is no Bomb Squad to save them.

Batten down the hatches Rassie, the debt is due and the collector is coming.

 

 

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

89 Comments
D
DT 28 days ago

So this aged well. It takes a lot of courage to be wrong this confidently.


My theory is that BS is playing a numbers game. If you make loads and loads of predictions you are likely to be right at some point. Unfortunately this one has to go in the loss column.


That being said, thanks ABs and Springboks for a cracking month of rugby, so sad it’s already over!

P
PaPaRumple 36 days ago

How stupid does this article read now?

C
CM 37 days ago

LOL! I think your maths might be a little off for this weekend—probably for the best that you’re no longer an auditor!

H
Howbzr76 38 days ago

Wow lots of offense been taken, everyone's entitled to their opinions right?-Maybe not to some people- but each to their own i guess. The series has been great so far let’s just enjoy it for what it is- the two Titans of world rugby battling for supremacy on a history making tour before the big dance in 12 months time. Win or lose the All Blacks have my unwavering support- and the mighty springboks have played a dominant role in helping to build that legacy.

L
LW 39 days ago

Despite his trolling you have to give this guy credit for having some valid points which are interesting to consider at least

R
Red and White Dynamight 39 days ago

Erasmus leaning in on the dinosaurs is a far bigger story. All that “depth”. theyve been shoving down everyone’s throats. But then select a 40yr old loosie in place of a regularly injured 35yr old hooker and that pack is 35+ generally. ABs way ahead of the RWC development curve at this stage. Lose/Draw this Series and its implosion time at Kamp Staaldraad all over again.

J
Jacque 37 days ago

Come again???

L
Loosehead 39 days ago

9 trys to 4 to ab's in 2 tests.

Boks in both second half of each test hav only combined 12 points to ab's 33.

Boks in second half of both tests hav not scored a try.

watch out wen ab's click.🤣

P
PaPaRumple 39 days ago

Garbage article from a garbage “journalist” that only know how to write click bait rubbish. I can see this article isn't gonna age well but then again you can't tarnish a reputation with nothing.

N
Nickers 39 days ago

haha funny article deliberately written to wind up South Africans, as everything “Ben Smith” writes is.


Now watch the South Africans pile into the comments to complain about the referee.

D
David Gedye 39 days ago

I’m not taking the bait lol. Let the rugby on Saturday do the talking …

Q
Quincy79 39 days ago

Ben Smith, you’ve spent so much time predicting Rassie’s collapse that you’ve apparently forgotten the one thing an actual rugby analyst is supposed to do: wait for the match to happen. Your masterpiece is basically “if this happens, then maybe that happens, and if you add five minutes…” — congratulations, you’ve discovered fiction with a scoreboard. And now you’re writing the Boks’ funeral program before the corpse has even arrived. At this point, Rassie isn’t living rent-free in your head — he’s apparently paying your salary.

D
David Gedye 39 days ago

Interesting analysis Ben. Have you got the equivalent playing time numbers for the ABs?

N
Nickers 39 days ago

Ardie, Jacobson and Vaai would be high - I think all three have played 80 mins in the first 2 games and starting again with Ardie and Vaai likely doing 80 mins again. Ardie coming into the tests completely fresh though. Holland has played 80 in both but these were his first games back and is now on the bench. But Lakai has played 25 mins, Sititi and Taukeaho haven’t played since the Lions game and had limited game time before that, Aumua has played 45 mins, Newell about the same, Numia even less.


The result may not come to fruition, and the Springboks may not fall off in the last 20, but the observation that the ABs forwards are fresher going into it is true.

H
Hellhound 40 days ago

Yeah yeah and I'm a monk. Once again smacks of desperation and trying to undermine the Boks morale. News flash BS, they don't read your articles. Tripe is all you have and that's actually quite sad. Keep hoping, keep slamming, keep drowning. You have tried for how many years now to make the Boks look weak? Still failing. Failing upwards, downwards and sideways. It just doesn't stick now does it? The Boks biggest weapon the scrum vs the AB's biggest weapon, BS, social media and refs. Gatland style. He won the first test with the refs help and he thought he was the greatest coach ever, then got brought back down to earth…Very very hard and he lost that series. Then tried to revive his flagging career after that big failure of a Lions tour by coaching Wales and actually made Wales worse than they ever been. Gatland? Done and dusted. Now Rennie have decided he just got the winning trick, social media and refs. Worked in the first and a bit less in the 2nd Test. Now that his desperation is exposed to the public, refs will be careful how they approach these tests. Amashukeli loves scrums. His country is known for their own scrum power. He is an ex player himself. He isn't as easily influenced as Gardener in the WC, 6N and RC and now the RGR. He is a fair ref and have no favourite team. He will blow both teams off the field, yet he isn't a Lackey of the AB's or social media.

B
Barefoot 40 days ago

In the loosely translated words of Franz Beckenbauer, “We’ll see and then we’ll see“.


As usual, lots of ifs and buts from the author, masquerading as facts. Every Springbok positive explained away, every negative made into a mountain. The truth is a lot more grey, for my money it’s too close to call. Saturday will be a cracker.

B
Barefoot 37 days ago

We saw and then we saw

H
Hellhound 40 days ago

Hey BS, I love how they rip you a new a..hole on X😂😂😂 Should feel sorry, but don't. You deserve it😂

U
Utiku Old Boy 39 days ago

Some of you guys are just low-class. Always make differences of opinion into personal attacks. You must be great to hang out with.

k
kt 40 days ago

Nice try - bits of Dave’s mouthpiece rage baiting. Let’s see if it rings true.

W
Wayneo 40 days ago

The Greatest Rivalry series is only at the half way mark and we have the URC starting on 25 September 🔥🔥🔥


EPCR Champions Cup starts 16 October and then we still have the Nations Championship to get through starting again 6 November.


What a time to be alive for absolute wall to wall rugby 365 days a year!!!🍿🍿🍿

T
Tk 40 days ago

Its a crap article but a great bit of rage baiting. Cue the howls from the direction of the South Atlantic.

J
Jacque 40 days ago

The Boks don't necessarily need their starting pack to dominate for 80 minutes.


They need them to build a lead.


If South Africa can get ahead by 10–15 points before fatigue becomes decisive, the tactical equation changes dramatically. They can kick, slow the game down, force the All Blacks to play from deep and use Kolbe/Libbok/Pollard-type kicking options to manage territory.


You’re worried about the Bomb Squad… I’d be more worried about what happens when it detonates.

H
HS 40 days ago

I just hope that the ref stops the All Blacks from utilising illegal and “cynical tactics” to disrupt the flow of play by slowing down the ball.


The All Blacks intentionally inhibit the ball’s pace near their tryline, opting to accept penalties rather than allowing opponents scoring opportunities.


I would also like the ref to check to the ABs dangerous manoeuvres, such as neck-rolls and shoulder charges.

T
Toaster 40 days ago

Would love if this was true and played out like this on Saturday 😀🙏

E
EQ 40 days ago

As usual Ben you are such a biased AB and Kiwi that you cannot be objective which is what a good journalist should be. The ABs have played well above the level many thought they were capable of but for all Dave Rennie’s whinging, they don’t have a scrum nor any good front rowers. That is why he is hiding that fact complaining about the Springboks ‘walking’ around. The Bok scrum destroyed France, England and Ireland so what is he he talking about. I do not anticipate the ABs will improve whereas the Boks comfortably have more squad depth. 2-1 after the game in Soweto Ben then we will hear the bleating and whinging go up ten notches.

H
Hellhound 40 days ago

Dont forget the high balls. Even Japan is better at it. It's the worst the ABs have ever been under the high ball. What crap is that catching the ball over your shoulder? Making it easy for any player competing for the ball to snatch it or disrupt it? The Boks are too rusty so far to take advantage of it. Most of the rust have been shaken off I hope. The Boks haven't had one really good game. Not yet. When they do, be aware.

P
PB 40 days ago

Well that is because he is not a journalist. He isn't even a pundit. He is a master troll though.

u
unknown 40 days ago

The Boks have a lot of miles on the clock. Will players like Etzabeth, Kolisi, De Alende, Pollard, Reinach, De Jager, and PSDT last until next year’s RWC?

p
pm 39 days ago

They will be managed to peak again @ the RWC

W
Wayneo 40 days ago

Yes

T
Two Cents 40 days ago

Whether or not they last, as long as they're still playing they will be selected as there's not really any alternatives bashing down the door to get ahead of them. Which is a good thing for everyone else who are currently in the process of revitalizing.

T
Two Cents 40 days ago

I think it's simply a question of the price that Father Time demands has fallen due sooner than Rassie would've liked and the age difference between the two squads is starting to become a real factor.


The average age of the Boks squad is about 31-32. The average age of the ABs is about 27-28. You may not think a difference of 4 years matters but at the elite level of sport is absolutely does and we are seeing it in real time.


Whether or not that means these guys gas out this weekend is uncertain but there is no doubt as Ben points out that the big minutes these guys have played so far will have a reckoning.

P
PB 40 days ago

Ah but isn't this narrative the same as what was sprouted in 2023, maybe even 2019?

And you say there are no players kicking the door down, well they all thought that when John Smit, Matfield et al retired.


Eben is still a beast so should make the WC

We still have RG Snyman to come back.

Lots of young players that have already played tests groomed to step in.

Hashim Pead, Yagheen Ahmed, Vusi Moyo, Siyaya, Cheswill Jooste, Mnbele, Riley Norton, and Paul de Villiers


Remember the Junior Boks are back to back RWC champions, the SA Schools side is undefeated for 3 years running.

Don't stress, Boks will be right up there

W
Wayneo 40 days ago

Based on this logic, somebody should DM Ben and get him to change the title of the article to “Flogged Dinosaurs in Looming Disaster”


I suppose Kiwi fans definitely don't want a pack of cynical, battle-hardened veterans who know exactly how to manage their air intake, slow the game down, manipulate the referee, and use historic old man strength to choke the absolute life out of a scrum. No, youth always wins no matter how green behind the ears they are.


Just therapeutic manifestation and pure emotional coping IMO.

J
Jmann 40 days ago

I’d just be happy if the ref could have the Bok loosehead push straight in the scrums.. that is all I want to see. The evidence is clear - everyone knows it’s happening. It is up to the ref to stop it. You see it a lot in NH competitions which is astounding really - given how much the NH like to convince us (or maybe they’re just trying to convince themselves ) that their refs are the best. Which is a nonsense. Gardner and Berry are the best refs in the world at present. But Berry can’t go to SA because the locals all have a big cry-wank when he refs them.

H
Hellhound 40 days ago

Berry got demoted. He is one of the worst refs in WR. What are you smoking? The best really?? I guess you just stayed how much you know about rugby in general. Dang

W
Wayneo 40 days ago

According to World Rugby Berry is not a T1 referee so please explain why he should he be officiating these types of matches?


And I fully agree with you on the Bok looseheads, the referees should absolutely enforce him to scrum straight in the scrums and to do that they will have to enforce the oposition tighthead to be stable in the setup, not make sideways foot adjustments and not pancake on the engage.

P
PB 40 days ago

No actually what you want to see is another ref protecting the AB scrum. If allowed to scrum the AB’s are back on the skateboard.


Berry is the best ref in the world? 😂😂😂😂🤡

They had a video which was leaked by Australia. If WR agreed that he was the best ref they would have backed him. They pulled the plug 🔌

He is maybe a SRP ref, because he is a weak individual

S
Stooge 40 days ago

Right…. Someone’s been watching all the All Blames’ whinging and whining posts.

The fear and panic is real!! 😂🤣

B
Bazzallina 40 days ago

It’s not really what we have seen before no doubt but Boks been rolling like this for awhile now haven’t they? When was the last time they rolled 6 dudes on at the same time? Still got some good bench players and Rassie still canny with his subs front row at 35 test 2 grabbing the opportunity by the nutcrackers example no hesitation

H
Hellhound 40 days ago

Uhm last many changes happened in The Nation's Championship. What are you on about rolling on the same players? Most of the current players did not even play a minute in the Nation's Championship, mostly due to injuries and those coming back from injury.

K
KwAussie 40 days ago

It’d be nice if this is true. I’m not sure it’s as dire as Ben is making out but he does make some good points.

P
PB 40 days ago

Which are?

u
unknown 40 days ago

A former financial analyst & auditor in retail banking, Ben is a columnist at RugbyPass


That makes sense. My 7 year cousin knows more about rugby than this dude…

W
Wayneo 40 days ago

Ben is “RugbyPass’ delusional optimist” there I fixed it for you.

S
Stooge 40 days ago

TEMU Ben’s panic & fear is real!! How marvelous to see him squirm and post his biased & irrelevant drivel just to convince himself. 🍿😂

The reality is that the Boks have not clicked yet and have a number of unused gears. TEMU Ben must pray for another Angus Gardner to save the All Blames.

P
PB 40 days ago

Angus Gardner wasn’t too bad for the Boks,they did win you know!

C
Cantab 40 days ago

Just note that the Boks are yet to score a second half try and are ripe to be outlasted by the ABs. NZ will doubtless be working on their discipline at not cpnceding penalties and holding the Boks at least even until the latter run out of puff as they have done in both test matches to date. This 3rd test will again be close but I think the ABs have more room to improve than do the Boks. Beware !!!

G
GRB13 40 days ago

They are making a much bigger impact in the first half this year so it makes sense to change strategy. Also missing two key members of the bomb squad will make a difference.

T
Tooly 40 days ago

The Bomb squad referred to the front row and how they were used . There was nothing wrong with them it was how they were used and how Gus Gardiner refereed .

The problems Rassie has are :

The other replacements are not performing .

Brilliant individuals not playing as a team after little time as the team .

Rushing out of the line in defence and missing the tackles .

NZ is doing everything well as a well settled team .

J
Jacque 37 days ago

???

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close