Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Tony Johnson: 'Most significant performance of McKenzie's career'

EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND - NOVEMBER 08: Damian McKenzie of New Zealand celebrates scoring his team's third try with teammate Billy Proctor during the Quilter Nations Series 2025 rugby international match between Scotland and New Zealand at the Scottish Gas Murrayfield on November 08, 2025 in Edinburgh, Scotland. (Photo by Ian MacNicol/Getty Images)

With 20 minutes to go at Murrayfield in Edinburgh, it’s safe to say the game was in the balance, and Scotland were well and truly in the hunt for a famous victory over the All Blacks.

ADVERTISEMENT

But International rugby can change just like that, and that’s what happened when replacement playmaker Damian McKenzie came onto the field for Caleb Clarke in the second half for the All Blacks.

Current Sky Sports commentator Tony Johnson, who called the game on Sunday morning, was full of praise for the 72-Test veteran, who almost single handedly won the away side the game.

“Look, it was a remarkable cameo, because all in a half hour performance he made a try saving tackle. He got that 50/22, he scored a try and I’m still struggling to figure out how the heck he managed to do that,” Johnson told Ian Smith on Sport Nation Morning’s.

“Because he was up against a pretty good defender in Kinghorn, the fullback for Scotland. He had an outstanding game, but McKenzie, it just was almost like a kid playing bull rush or something.

Related

“Just the absolute determination to get away from the tackle, get the ball over the line; that spoke volumes for his character and his determination, because he knew that was a big moment in the game and he wasn’t going to miss out.

“And then, of course, he didn’t quite hit the conversion right, but then the nerveless manner with which he stepped up and slotted that ball was about a 45 meter penalty to lock the game down.”

Johnson also believes that McKenzie’s performance was one of his best ever, due to taking the game by the scruff of the neck when the All Blacks needed it the most.

“To me, that is the most significant performance of Damian McKenzie’s Test career, because it was a real match winning performance.

ADVERTISEMENT

The veteran commentator still thinks the coaching staff will stick with Beauden Barrett at first-five and McKenzie off the bench in the No.22 jersey, based on what the Chiefs playmaker can bring off the bench late in games.

“But, you know, I just get the feeling, Smithy, they’ll stick with that setup that they’ve had where Barrett starts the game in the driver’s seat, and they can bring Mckenzie on later on the game, when maybe things are breaking up, or the game’s in the balance,” the Sky Sport commentator told Smith.

“Because whatever the situation, he can make a difference, but I can understand why people want to see him on the field for longer than that.

“I don’t disagree with that. I’m just sort of guessing with the way that the coaching staff are thinking and the way they use them.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Johnson adds that in International rugby nowadays, the bench impact and who comes on in the second half is just as important as who starts, especially when the All Blacks coaches have the luxury of versatile backs.

“In a way, it underlined why they like him coming off the bench, because he’s got the ability to come on and change the game and we all say it now so often, it’s a 23 player game, and you just look at the impact of the bench on the South African game against France, the French just couldn’t live with the Springbok bench.

“So to me, I wonder whether that is what they’re going to continue to do and of course, when he comes on, you’ve got different options. You can move will Jordan to the right wing, or they’ve got the potential to move Leicester Fainga’anuku from center to wing, that sort of thing. ”

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

14 Comments
G
GG 32 days ago

I sense all supporters and rugby folk from various countries, including ex players, have an obsession with individuals and whether they should start or be preferred. Rassie always looks at what is best for the team in a particular week as well as during a game. Always team first. In this process the players have bought in to this approach and I am always surprised how supportive the non playing guys are, even after being subbed. Rassie may not always get it right, but the players buy in.

B
BleedRed&Black 33 days ago

McKenzie is a better 10 Barrett in almost every regard, particularly in the crucial area of goalkicking where he has longer range and is more accurate. Barrett routinely fails under pressure, against England in the end of tour last year, against France on the end of tour year last year. The one area Barrett is superior is defence, where he is the best in the world. Which, I suspect, is why they keep picking him.

s
sf 31 days ago

There is simply no chance that in the decision for who gets the 10 jersey— Barrett’s marginally better defence is what tips the scales in his favor if dmac is better in every other aspect as you say. That makes no sense.

G
Gary C 33 days ago

While McKenzie is an attack plan all on his own, the coaches do not seem to have many strike moves to use in a game. All Blacks will need to catch the high balls and manage their discipline to beat England

B
B 33 days ago

Damian McKenzie at his mercurial best of turning nothing into something...it was simply a matter of backing yourself…. like Beaver RWC 2011 and Beaudy RWC 2015…

A
Another 33 days ago

He has a lot of mental composure in pressurised situations. You can see it in his plays where he is assured in the time he has available. Major asset to the ABs.

T
TokoRFC 33 days ago

Can we stop calling Dmac a choker now? He isn’t perfect but this was just the best of a few times he’s made significant late game contributions.


With the England tour last year him and Barrett are quite good at saving each others ass.

G
GrahamVF 33 days ago

I think the main problem with Dmac is that the coaching staff were (are?) not sure of how to use him in the best interests of himself and the team. He need to have a very clear idea of what his role is and how he plays to fulfil that. Up to now that hasn’t seemed apparent - hopefully this performance will point the way.

G
GL 33 days ago

The issue is that BB is 34, looks tired, playing poorly and his kicking is to nowhere. Even in the McKenzie try his pass hit grass and had to be picked up by Leicester.


So clearly McKenzie is great from the bench and has proven it in many many tests (He was also instrumental vs England 3 years ago), but BB is 34 and starting McKenzie with Love in the bench at least gives a view of the future…in 27, BB will be 36!!!


DC retired at 33 and was still an amazing player

G
Gary C 33 days ago

Ruben Love to start against Wales GL.

A
Another 33 days ago

Beauden Barrett earned his starting place in the ABs last year and has still demonstrated class in that position. The tries scored in the win against the Springboks at Eden Park earlier this year directly came from BB plays. Fans are a capricious lot - and the occasional mistake occurs with all First Fives as they are in a highly scrutinised position. If you swapped out an older player with a newer player, like Reuben Love say, then it wouldn’t take long for fans to start demanding he be dropped too.


The All Blacks don’t currently have the luxury to keep dumping players, however. Barrett will be the incumbent No10 for the foreseeable future. DMac remains world class as an impact player, evidently.

S
SunChaser 33 days ago

How he got over for that try god only knows -

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close
ADVERTISEMENT