Northern | US

All Blacks player ratings vs Springboks | 3rd Test Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry 2026


New Zealand's number eight Ardie Savea scores a try during the third Rugby's Greatest Rivalry international rugby union match between South Africa and New Zealand at the FNB Stadium in Johannesburg, on September 5, 2026. (Photo by GIANLUIGI GUERCIA / AFP via Getty Images)
Comments
110 Comments
The Springboks will head to Baltimore leading Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry 2-1 after overcoming the All Blacks, 29-24, in Soweto.

Rennie’s side held on in the first half to head into the oranges level after a blistering start in Soweto. All Blacks captain Ardie Savea dotted down twice, while Rassie Erasmus’ Springboks hit back with two tries of their own, including a penalty try from scrum time.

ADVERTISEMENT

The second half, though, was a completely different contest. The All Blacks were inaccurate, and the Springboks swarmed the visitors.

Here’s how the All Blacks rated in Soweto.

Related

1. George Bower – 5
Tough night at scrum time, where he was overpowered on his side of the scrum in two of the first three shoves, although he came up clutch on the stroke of halftime, earning the All Blacks a free-kick. Added six tackles in the first half. Pinged for hinging in the first scrum of the second half, in his last contribution to the game.

VIDEO

2. Asafo Aumua – 7
Strong outing. Aumua made three-for-three from the lineout to start, and his ball-carrying was explosive in the first quarter. Great spot tackle when the Springboks looked threatening in the 30th minute. Aumua hit seven of his eight lineouts in the first half, a massive improvement for the All Blacks from Cape Town. Off in the 60th minute, with nine carries. The only negative was the first-half scrum performance.

3. Tyrel Lomax – 5
The tighthead was sent backwards for the Springboks’ penalty try, but the scrum issues were largely on the other side for the majority of the first half. Not a standout performance, as Lomax didn’t overly influence the contest. Off early in the second half.

4. Tupou Vaa’i – 6.5
The All Blacks’ kick-off issues remained from Cape Town, with Vaa’i struggling to take several first-half kick-offs. Seems less effective than when he’s at blindside, where he’s given the freedom to roam on the edges. More effective in the second half, but only added six tackles and six carries.

5. Sam Darry – 6
Darry’s first 40 minutes were workmanlike. Strong actions around the field, and helped the All Blacks have a better start, compared to the first two Tests. Didn’t feature much, if at all, in the second half. Off in the 60th minute.

ADVERTISEMENT

6. Peter Lakai – 7
Important breakdown turnover with the home side hot on attack, to get Rennie’s side out of trouble early. Dynamic with ball in hand, offering a different dimension for the All Blacks, often getting over the advantage line. Finished his 80-minute shift with nine carries.

Player Carries

1
Will Jordan
13
2
Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu
11
3
Jordie Barrett
11

7. Luke Jacobson – 7
Luke “concrete shoulders” Jacobson was a menace on defence. Powerful stop on Jasper Wiese in the 16th minute, and looked to have sorted his ill-disciplined breakdown decisions. Picked up the captaincy when Savea left the field, contributing three tackles in the first half. Had less impact in the second half, when the All Blacks couldn’t get their game going.

8. Ardie Savea – 7.5
Savea opened the scoring in the eleventh minute, diving over after the All Blacks started to threaten on attack. Savea was ill-disciplined in the ten minutes, giving away two breakdown penalties, the last of which resulted in a Springboks try. Savea crossed again, picking up the scraps from Carter’s break. Unfortunately for the All Blacks, the captain left the field after a Wiese cleanout. Led the carries stat at halftime with eight, despite only playing 30 minutes. Could feel the drop-off in the All Blacks’ performance after the inspirational captain left the field.

9. Cam Roigard – 8
Roigard’s ambition to play from their own end showed when the halfback took a quick tap from inside their 22, winning an offside penalty. Nice mini-break in the lead-up to Savea’s second, linking up with Barrett. Crucial in starting the All Blacks’ attack from a variety of positions on the field. An incredible box-kick from midfield, basically earning a 50/22, as Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu sliced his exit. Off at 65 minutes, after another impressive performance.

ADVERTISEMENT

10. Ruben Love – 5
Not accurate enough. Love’s first action was a pass out of play to Leroy Carter, but he responded with a solid rest of the first half, without breaking the game open. His penalty kicks for touch struggled, slicing a couple off the side of his boot. Love was sent to the bin with a couple of minutes to play in the first half for being cynically offside. Missed two important kicks at goal, which would have extended the All Blacks’ lead to ten, before the Springboks stormed home.

11. Leroy Carter – 6
Exceptional in-play kick to force the Springboks to play from their own end, from a Jordie Barrett cross-kick. Carter couldn’t contain Damian De Allende for the Springboks’ first, being fended off in the lead-up. Game-high three missed tackles at halftime, but had a strong 40 minutes on attack. Costly missed tackle, again, on Kriel, resulting in the Springboks taking the lead. After Rennie said Carter was selected over Josh Moorby on his defence, it was a tough night for the Chiefs winger on the defensive side of the ball, even though his work on attack was strong.

12. Jordie Barrett – 7.5
Another brilliant showing defensively, despite not shining on attack. Strong first tackle on Jessie Kriel, rushing up to force the Springboks midfielder backwards. Barrett’s contribution around the field shouldn’t go unnoticed, with unseen efforts helping the All Blacks withstand the Springboks’ attack. Had eleven carries and a game-high 14 tackles.

13. Quinn Tupaea – 6
Pinged in the second minute for a high tackle, gifting the Springboks an entry into their 22. Rushed out of the line on Kriel, slowing down the centre. Some solid work defensively during the first 40 minutes. Didn’t last long in the second half, succumbing to a leg injury.

14. Will Jordan – 6.5
Exceptional with ball in hand, but too many costly errors. In what looked like a nothing play, Jordan made a line-break from his own end, stabbing a kick behind the defence. It was an electric break, when most players would have cleared their lines. Jordan’s contribution in the first half was impressive, highlighted by a breakdown turnover close to their own line. Threw one pass directly to Ethan Hooker, one of his four turnovers in Soweto. A smart grubber kick that led to his try, popping up in support for Carter. Poor execution on a clearing kick that resulted in the Springboks dotting down under the posts through a dominant driving maul. The Test match swung in the direction of South Africa after that moment.

15. Damian McKenzie – 6
McKenzie was solid during the first half in Soweto, often linking up well with his teammates out the back of sweeping backline moves on attack. But ultimately, McKenzie couldn’t find his running game in Soweto.

Match Summary

1
Penalty Goals
0
4
Tries
4
2
Conversions
2
0
Drop Goals
0
95
Carries
130
6
Line Breaks
12
14
Turnovers Lost
16
6
Turnovers Won
7

Replacements

16. Samisoni Taukei’aho – 5.5
On with 20 minutes to go, contributing a late consolation try.

17. Xavier Numia – 4.5
Pinged at scrum time by the touch judge, Christophe Ridley, at his first scrum. Lacked impact.

18. Fletcher Newell – 4
Scrum struggled when Newell was on the field, and the prop was sent backwards on a couple of occasions with ball in hand. Penalised by the referee for an incorrect pickup at the ruck, with the All Blacks hot on attack.

19. Fabian Holland – 5
Got his timing wrong at the breakdown, taking out a Springbok defender past the ruck.

20. Wallace Sititi – 7.5
Much improved after a tough start to the tour. Sititi entered the contest earlier than expected, with Savea leaving the field in the first half. Helped the All Blacks get on the attack in the second half, stripping a Springbok attacker in midfield, linking up with Vaa’i. Brilliant late line-break, breaking through the Springboks’ defence with no one in support.

21. Kyle Preston – 5
Provided quick ball, but misjudged an attacking opportunity by taking a quick tap instead of a lineout drive.

22. Anton Lienert-Brown – 5.5
On for Tupaea early in the second half and didn’t have an important impact on the game. Having appeared off the bench in all three Tests, it’s clear Rennie’s side needed more impact from their reserves. Missed a tackle on Manie Libbok, but made up for it with a breakdown turnover.

23. Josh Moorby – 5
A couple of strong touches, but also knocked the ball on.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

110 Comments
R
RugCs 44 days ago

13. Quinn Tupaea – 6 Didn’t last long in the second half, succumbing to a leg injury.


It was Jacobson who grabbed Tupaea’s leg and twisted it until the MCL broke. What a filthy player Jacobson is.


Edit:

MCL and ACL gone… maybe career too.

R
RugCs 44 days ago

Here kiwis go after Jacobson, end him like he ended Tupaea


https://x.com/grapgatza/status/2096626876391264740/video/1

D
Drew 45 days ago

I thought the AB loose trio were all 8 and Ardie maybe a 9. Vaai is a great player too. This AB team are not gonna go away. Its 50:50 between the Boks and them and will be for the next few years. What a disaster the world cup draw is.

S
SunChaser 45 days ago

Cam Roigard has been stand out but I hope they chat to him about the theatricals - it’s not how the all blacks behave. Leave that for the Aussies

R
RD 45 days ago

Why are Carter and Moorby defending midfield? Thats a specialist job, especially against SA centres. Is this a management mistake?

Z
Zac 45 days ago

Our Centres got outplayed..

r
rhubsch 45 days ago

Something is wrong with the app, cannot open and display articles to read. Been 2 weeks now.

A
Ayre123 None 45 days ago

I thought that Rennie will act when that fijian lock Vaai blew 3 try opportunities but he didn’t, anyway Rennie is still way better than Razor.

N
Naki 45 days ago

Not surprised by the result ,no killer instinct, make chances ,fail to finish,nothing new ,srum an maul still not gd enough ! Performance again not good enough !

G
Guy 45 days ago

“cynically offside” 🤣

u
unknown 45 days ago

Roigard won soccer player of the match for his pathetic acting at the Reinach incident.

G
Guy 45 days ago

you mean when Reinach obstructed him then dropped him on his head?

B
Bruiser 45 days ago

Get DMac to do goal kicking in Baltimore and tell Love to chance his arm…he's been steady but holding back a bit too much

J
Jordon 45 days ago

A little harsh on Love. Those touch finders were in to a stiff breeze in the first half, and his missed penalty was quickly followed by a try. Tupou vaai has been the disappointment of the series. He shouldve been a 4.

B
Bazzallina 45 days ago

Tough one for Ruben but he didn’t didn’t poopoo the bed or anything still 3 tests in a row week in week out won’t complain if Richie gets a start in the next one it will be a big call with how much change Renz makes as we will really want to win the next one

B
Bazzallina 45 days ago

Jeesh tuff on Preston for the quick tap I’m quite heartened by the fact he was decisive.

They have only been short stints but is good to see him play pretty well in a absolute cauldron of text rigby at its hardest

B
Bruiser 45 days ago

Can someone tell me why a left footer ie Cam, doesnt take the penalty kicks to touch on the right hand touch. I've been banging on about this for years. One of loves kicks went 5 metres when we were under pressure

B
Bazzallina 45 days ago

He does for the Canes often and he took one during NC but you dead right easy win there for the boys

B
Bruiser 45 days ago

I don't think we doubled down on our attack…we went into our shell. Narawa must replace Carter in Baltimore. Assume teachers pet ALB will start at centre, so Jim and Reiks onto bench surely.

R
RD 45 days ago

What did ALB do wrong off the bench?

G
Guy 45 days ago

Reiko will start, wing or centre. It will be more obvious when they name the ones going to Baltimore

B
Bruiser 45 days ago

Overall this has been a great tour for us and this is what we wanted to be found out in the areas that we need to improve for next year. We are going to have change our thinking on scrummaging. Physics suggests we need 2 140 guys at prop. Mau should go to Baltimore and get 30 mins…let's just see how he goes. Williams needs to lift more weights before he returns. Darry and Holland the same. Lakai should start at 7, Wallace 8 and Vaii back to 6.

c
cnw 45 days ago

M’au, Tosi, Ofa - all provide huge ballast. Yes Tosi could not keep his feet - but ironically he will be facing Boks who don’t hinge. Would suit him. Be good to see how they go against this Bok team.

O
OtagomanII 45 days ago

Lomax has not been the same for 2 years with those injuries. Maybe back to Tasman simply to play more games rather than do it by tests. Yes, give Ma’u a crack off the bench.

G
GS 45 days ago

Think this game showed all the ABs shortcoming that we probably all felt was coming basis last years games vs the Boks.


Scrum is weak and the issue is that Super Rugby, where we play likes of Oz sides and where the commerical realities of providing an entertaining and fast game, means that tight forward play is not supported - think this is the reality of the Bok teams leaving Super Rugby and not sure how we can address it.


Then I think for the first time DR choked a little bit around the team selection - Nacewa, Ioane, Blackadder, Tavatavanawai - all had strong cases to be on the bench or starting and Holland has to be the first name on the team sheet - only 20 minutes at the back end of the game?


Looking forward for the team


Vai’i for me has declined as the series has moved forward, looking really tired and his hands have let him down mutiple times, Lomax is playing off past glories but reality not exactly replent with replacements to replace him.


Lakai is a great player but at 7 or 8, you give up so much by having a short player at 6 - I’m not sure of the solution, however as seen how weak it makes the lineout real head scratcher I guess.


Then Love is still not a WC 10 - seems to be holding the seat for Mo’unga and poor old Leroy Carter, fantastic player gives his heart but found out today (like vs England last year) a defensive liablity - do wonder if ABs will be brave enough to select him again, because every team will have watched the game and will now look to isolate and target him in defence.


Will be interesting to see the team that is selected for next week, however still positive around how the team is trending, but quality sides like the Boks will find out your weaknesses and pretty clearly they did that today.

S
Steppin 44 days ago

I agree for the most part but one thing I still haven’t seen AB supporters mention is our kick restarts and exits. More often than not we score points and then put the pressure back on ourselves right at the get go. Kudos to the Boks for exploiting this and putting so much pressure on us but we need to be better. Get the catch right and then clear it.


A note on Love. He had an off night and it showed. The kicking conditions seemed really difficult there but it also seemed the pressure of the moment got to him. He will get better - he is generally playing far beyond his experience. I would be happy if Love started and Mounga finished or something of that nature - split halves. The main thing I don't want for Love is what happened with the Mounga/Barrett/Dmac saga. Love will be the future 10 for the ABs - he just needs strong mentorship and our coaches confidence.


Here's hoping fresh legs get on in the US but I’m sure they will (Blackadder, Ioane, Narawa, Tavatava)

j
johnz 45 days ago

I agree with all of that. I thought Vaa’i was dissapointing, and I’d already pointed out Carter’s shortcomings which many couldn’t see. He missed 5 tackles in one of the recent tour matches. Great on attack, but he’s a liability otherwise.


Lakai is definitely a 7 or 8. The problem is Savea and Jacobson have their names pencilled in each week. Jacobson has played well, but has dropped of as the serries wears on. I don’t understand how he gets a 7 mark after making only 3 tackles in the first half? I watched him closely after Savea went off. I wanted to see if he would stand up to the leadership role. I saw nothing. Actually, it reminded me of when I watched him in the SR final, he seemed to check out mentally there also. So for me he’s not an essential starter - he’s an option. I’m surprised he was elevated to the leadership group so quickly without ever having been a consistent AB before.


Lakai and Segner both have much greater upsides as 7s. I think Jacobson is playing at his ceiling. We need to invest in the younger lads.

G
Guy 45 days ago

When did Nacewa everplay for the All Blacks?

J
Jbo 45 days ago

Agree with several but I feel we’ve seen Mounga for years in the ABs and he’s never really asserted dominance and leading the team around as a 10.


Love had his first off night, and with Roigard I’d argue the prime playmaker the ABs use with their structure is actually off 9, with 10,12, and 15 all slotting in as needed. It’s worked well I thought and contributed hugely to our attack success against the world’s best defensive team.


The team across the board let themselves down. Can’t understate how manu of the boks opportunities came off set piece dominance

S
SC 45 days ago

Every point you nailed and could not agree more.

N
Nickers 45 days ago

Extremely amateur performance from NZ tonight. SA upped the ante at half time and we fell to pieces. Individual errors under pressure shone a light on where we actually are. We can’t have anyone on the field who can’t make spot tackles - Carter shows great physicality in the carry but was brushed aside for 14 points. I don’t see how he comes back from that. Moorby had similar problems. South Africa do not make mistakes like this, and we will never beat them if we continue making them.


Love has largely gone under the radar this series putting in a number of solid 7/10 performances. He could have changed the game with his kicking tonight but failed. Kicks he would make 9 times out of 10 went wide, and his 10 minutes in the bin came at a terrible time. He has so much more to offer than what he has shown this series, but SFM outplayed him massively. No team has ever won the World Cup without a clutch goal kicker.


Losing Tupea and Ardie was very costly. They are two of our most prominent ball carriers, especially off set piece, and Tupea in particular was really missed. I can’t see how we persist with ALB on the bench.


Every person in the All Blacks camp will know the game was there to be won tonight. Every player will be able to look back at a critical error they made that swung the game - It’s up to them to get better so that they can take advantage of the opportunities they are presented with.


We also have to concede that SA were not at their best either, but once again carried a two score lead into the last 10 minutes. As the series progressed we just got looser and looser culminating a very il disciplined performance tonight. That should be the main take away for the All Blacks - you are not even close yet.


The game next week is nonsense, so even if the ABs win it I don’t think many sane people will take solace from it.

Z
Zac 45 days ago

I will..2. 2 series draw is better than a 3:1 loss.

G
Guy 45 days ago

Yes we will because we won’t have diminished our win loss record over our Test History. Beating them at home is worth more points too

G
GS 45 days ago

Love is just keeping the seat warm for Mo’unga. Mo’unga not ready for test match footy yet but only a matter of time.

L
Longshanks 45 days ago

The bench had little impact, Lakai aside. Feel it’s being wasted by Rennie. The whole team was flagging by the 60th minute and needed the replacements needed to bring some impact. Instead the majority of them contributed little over those they replaced. If you’re not starting ALB & Moorby, you would never look to them as impact players. Ioane despite his faults still has pace and strength, even Narawa ahead of any of those two. I’d move Vaa’i back to blindside for the final test and drop Lomax, who hasn’t hit the heights of 3/4 years ago. I’d love to see Mo'unga at 10, Love hasn’t been the worst thing about the last 2 performances but he’s been far from the best. Maybe even move him back to fullback to lessen the pressure, then we can have McKenzie off the bench late in the game. Loves goalkeeping was poor and I'm curious why the more experienced McKenzie or Barrett weren’t given the responsibility. Game management was poor as well, we had 2 kickable penalties while we were down to 14 and didn't take them, sure one was on halfway from the Reinach flip, but in centrefield, for Jordie, at altitude, definitely worth a crack.

U
Utiku Old Boy 45 days ago

Lakai started. Not off the bench

G
GrahamVF 45 days ago

Watching the Kiwis argue about who’s fault it was is the most entertaining read on this site/

T
Tim 45 days ago

Easily amused?

D
DM 45 days ago

Two weeks running poor goa kicking has cost the ABs dearly

c
cnw 45 days ago

One very happy moment for me was seeing Sititi in action - he stood out alongside Ardie for me - both deserving 8 at least.

R
RD 45 days ago

Hopefully he is back now and quite possibly a future game breaker.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close