Northern | US

All Blacks legend weighs into Ireland: 'They've turned into a pack of whingers'


AUCKLAND, NEW ZEALAND - JULY 18: Sam Prendergast of Ireland shows his frustration during the Nations Championship match between New Zealand All Blacks and Ireland at Eden Park on July 18, 2026 in Auckland, New Zealand. (Photo by Joe Allison - Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images)
Comments
37 Comments

All Blacks legend Justin Marshall says Ireland should take a long, hard look at themselves rather than look for excuses after they were beaten 40-21 by New Zealand in the third round of the Nations Championship last weekend.

ADVERTISEMENT

Defensively Ireland were all over the shop in the first half as they trailed 28-7 at half-time before restoring some pride to ‘win’ the second half.

The match could possibly have had a different outcome had Luke Jacobson’s dangerous clearout at the ruck on 27 minutes been upgraded to a red, while Quinn Tupaea was perceived to be lucky not to get binned for a deliberate knock on.

VIDEO

New Zealand had surged into a commanding 14-0 lead when Jacobson’s foul play was put on review, and there was only one team in it. And Marshall believes any Irish angst should be directed at putting their own house in order – they were turned over over 18 times and missed 35 tackles – rather than blame the officiating.

“They’ve turned into a pack of whingers to be honest,” the 81-cap blasted during an appearance on The Good, The Bad, The Rugby, ANZ.

“They feel like their performance wasn’t up to standard but it is everyone else’s fault.

“They’ve been blaming a couple of decisions within the game, ‘We were ripped off, the All Blacks cheated, they always get the favourable decisions going their way, particularly at Eden Park … there was this, and there was that’.

“It was like, mate, we didn’t make you drop the ball f***** ball 15 times.

“Do you know how many tackles they fell off? They were falling off tackles like that. But they go straight towards, Quinn Tupaea, it should have been a yellow card, Jacobson should’ve been a red.

ADVERTISEMENT

“It’s like, you know what guys, sort out your own s*** first, and don’t blame everyone else.

“Look at yourself in the mirror, Ireland, for goodness sake.”

Related

Follow your favourites in the RugbyPass App

Your home for rugby. Download the RugbyPass app on the App Store (iOS) and Google Play (Android) now!


Follow your favourite teams, tournaments and players, and get personalised news and Match Centre notifications direct to your device.


From live rugby streams and upcoming fixtures to breaking news, in-depth analysis and live scores, RugbyPass has everything you need to stay connected to the game.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

37 Comments
E
Eric Elwood 21 days ago

I watched the Virgin media coverage. I can only assume Marshall didn’t. I didn’t witness any excuses being offerred for Irelands loss.

At no point did any pundit even hint that NZ would not have won if the match was reffed differently. One actually said that Ireland was lucky the brain fart head hit happened when it did because Ireland was about to go 21-0 down!

There was annoyance over the yellow knock on non call, but one pundit pointed out Preendergast lucky with not being penalized first half and the mid air tackle on Love deserves further scrutiny.

A big one for Ireland was how the ruck was reffed but as I recall that was 2-1 of the 3 pundits backing the ref there more or less. Once said maybe too much coaching form him and to just penalize infringements.

They were very tough on Irish poor play but said that in the first half Ireland had generally played OK, but that NZ excellent attack was to be commended.

d
dk 21 days ago

Stephen Jones was the absolute worst rugby writer of all time but the Irish media are not too far behind. Yes Marshy, you are right. They squeal like stuck pigs over the smallest issue. Think back to the accidental head knock by Cane in Dublin after we’d lost in America. OMG. Ireland were terrible in Auckland. While agree we got the rub of the green on those card calls, Ireland were handing the game to us with simple mistakes.

E
Eric Elwood 21 days ago

The pundits didnt say what Marshall said he said. BTW have NZ supporters still stopped whining about TMOs after 22/23?

M
Max Imus 21 days ago

A stupid comment from a stupid man. Of course fans are going to point out injustices. There were three glaringly obvious ones in that match, the red that never was, the yellow that never was and blowing up before the match was over. In what world would any fan base not mention these bad calls? But no Irish fan is saying Ireland deserved to win the game or that these decisions changed the outcome. And certainly no player or coach has even mentioned the bad decisions. Pundits will do what pundits are paid to do, ie analyse the talking points of the game and these three were obvious bad calls, so I don't know what this clown is criticising them for.

B
Brian 22 days ago

Marshall saying “did we make you drop the f×××%ing ball 15 times”,

Is yes they did, Ireland were woeful and seemed to have both eyes on the hit instead of the ball and lost forward on numerous occasions

E
Eric Elwood 21 days ago

I thought NZ made them crack a little with the pressure. Symptoms are direct mistakes from direct pressure and indirect mistakes from the pressurized enviroment. I was hoping that Ireland could get into the sheds at 14-7 which would have represented us getting away with murder.

A
Alex 21 days ago

Agreed there. They were their own worst enemy in the first half

P
PickOllieMathisOrKeepLosing,Rob. 22 days ago

Spot on Marshy! They need some of the cool, calm, respectful introspection New Zealanders showed in 2022 when Ireland won that series… we didn’t even mention the TMO, did we?

d
d 22 days ago

well we may have, might have got a bit obscured by our more colourful synonyms for “TMO”; anyway it goes without saying that we are the best in the world at cool calm respectful introspection, although it must be said Argentina is making a late run at the title.

A
Alex 22 days ago

This is why the Aeteorua pod is so much better!!

u
unknown 22 days ago

It shows you how much of a tit Marshall is when he’s only just realised this now. Everyone else has known it for eons.

E
Eric Elwood 21 days ago

He is stating something which didnt happen. Maybe that where you get your info?

Have you stopped whinging since 22/23?

U
Utiku Old Boy 22 days ago

Hard to disagree but have to say it is mostly ex-Irish players and pundits who are moaning - not AF or the team. So, Justin Marshall is quite within his rights to call that group out also. And the points he made are valid.

E
Eric Elwood 21 days ago

No ex pundits moaned in that coverage. Marshall is either misinformed or is being dishonest. It appears to me that he cynically brought up ref scrutiny (happens after most matches) to pretend the pundits were blaming the ref.

T
Tk 22 days ago

Marshall was a tit when he was playing and still a tit now as a pundit. As a Kiwi and an AB fan, he needs to put a sock in it.

H
HenryAU 21 days ago

One of the few commentators who show genuine enjoyment when the opposition do something well or score a brilliant try against the All Blacks - you can hear in his voice he loves the game.

R
RugCs 22 days ago

Apparently this is all Nienaber’s fault. For modernising Leinster’s defence. Now the confused Leinster players cannot adapt to Farrells defence. What a disaster.

P
POHM 22 days ago

Not sure if Marshall wasn’t paying attention to the past, Ireland have always been whingers just like the Aussies.

E
Eric Elwood 21 days ago

Youre a troll son.

T
Tom 22 days ago

🍿

S
SB 22 days ago

Fantastic hypocrisy.

R
Rob 22 days ago

“Old man shouts at cloud”


There’s not a single fanbase amongst all tier 1 and most tier 2 teams that don’t behave like this online. It’s framed to sound like he’s talking about the actual team themselves because he knows that’ll get engagement, Andy Farrell is one of the least likely coaches to talk about refereeing or decisions that go against us often to our detriment. When asked about both of the non card decisions he moved on without comment in the presser after the match.


Yet again it’s the same pot kettle black with these kiwi pundits, they should read their own fanbases forums or even actually listen to their own players comments for a change instead of assuming they’re the arbiters of moral authority with a blank slate.


Let he who has clean clothes throw the first mud ball….

U
Utiku Old Boy 21 days ago

His point is valid regarding Irish pundits and fans.

A
Alex 22 days ago

Exactly 💯 he should look at AB fan forums too.


Boy was there some moaning over the world cup final red card!

O
Over the sideline 22 days ago

Did you actually eatch the podcast? Mmmmm

R
RD 22 days ago

Always have been. Moaned for decades about poaching Pacific Islanders by Australia and NZ, while they were working hard to sign likely lads from the SH as project players. Top class hypocrisy 👏

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

R
Red and White Dynamight 2 hours ago
'Bit unfair': Bulls boss Johan Ackermann's vow before All Blacks clash

“kicked out”. Safas clutch so desperately to their string of victim pearls that excuses are always at the ready to explain away their own poor management decisions. SARU threatened their SANZAR partners for years that ‘because of viewership numbers’ that they were owed a bigger slice of the broadcasting rights pie. Aus and NZ quite rightly told them to FO, SANZAR was an equal partnership. Notwithstanding that each partner brought their own strengths and weaknesses, certainly a winning record completely escaped SA teams as part of their ‘package’. OFS were chopped, and early, despite being 1 of the more attractive SA teams to watch. Still the concentration of SA players from 5 teams to 4 had little discernible improvement on teams performance. In fact, SA teams were - by far - the least successful partner. Only 1 Champion SA club whereas all 3 origin Aus teams won and all 5 NZ teams have won. SA teams had a 22% win rate in NZ - so noone was turning up to watch them - whilst NZ teams had a 50% win rate in SA. When Covid pandemic hit the entire World and, NZ for 1 closed borders in and out, obviously this impacted an International competition and whilst a trans-Tasman lite-Super comp returned eventually, SARU used this opportunity to scream “we’ve been kicked out”. The reality was a temporary solution that would have soon corrected itself. Of course everyone knows the Safas innately clutch desperately to being a victim - ‘noone likes us, we dont care’ - and everyone outside of SA knows that the truth is found elsewhere. After only a few seasons of turning up to matches with teams full of development players in the URC/Champions Cup, those partner nations and their fans are already sick of the moaning and whinging that inherently accompanies all things Sth African. SARU are probably still kidding themselves that they will enter the 6Nations and that they will be “kicked out” of the Rugby Championship. What a bunch of big babies.

50 Go to comments
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close