Wales were unable to pile further misery on an Ireland squad licking their wounds at the Principality Stadium on Saturday, as they fell to a 22-17 defeat on home soil.


Warren Gatland’s men were profligate in the first of their back-to-back fixtures with Ireland and the Kiwi will be hoping for a much improved display when a likely first-choice side heads to Dublin for the return game next weekend.

Here, RugbyPass runs the rule over a disappointing display for their second-string players in Cardiff.

  1. Hallam Amos6

A responsible outing from Amos, who dealt well with Ireland’s kicking game and a had a couple of forays as a counter-attacker. He will be frustrated by how lateral he got in the transition from Wales’ second half lineout steal, though.

  1. Owen Lane7

Grabbed a much-deserved try in the second half and was Wales’ most effective operator in the back line. He frequently came off his wing at the set-piece and looked for work in the midfield, making an important cover tackle on Jacob Stockdale and showing impressive strength to use the touchline and stay in field in tackles.

  1. Scott Williams6

Williams didn’t provide the overall attacking impetus he would have liked, although his defence was strong and his decision-making prevented Ireland from having a number of breakaways that could have led to tries. Lovely back-handed offload nearly created a try.

  1. Owen Watkin4.5

An early knock-on when he took his eyes off the ball seemed to set the tone. He lost the physical battle with Bundee Aki on a couple of occasions and when he did have success running back against the grain, he ended up being turned over.

  1. Steff Evans5

Evans was quiet by his usual standards. He chased industriously and had a couple of counter-attacks, although the majority of Wales’ positive attacking play came when the ball was moving to the other wing.


View this post on Instagram


What a stint #WarrenGatland #WalesRugby #RugbyWorldCup

A post shared by RugbyPass (@rugbypass_) on

  1. Jarrod Evans5.5

A mixed bag from the fly-half, who was accurate with one of his two kicks at goal. He had some nice moments, including a perfectly weighted cross-field kick for Lane, although they were mitigated by lateral play in the back line and a missed kick for touch, not to mention the impact of his replacement.

  1. Aled Davies5

Started off strongly with a measured box kick, although his kicking from hand was less effective as the game went on. He wasn’t able to have the sniping or incisive passing influence he would have wanted.

  1. Rhys Carre6

The debutant had a couple of goes at John Ryan at the scrum and, apart from picking up one penalty, dealt well with the Munsterman. Carre stepped up as a first receiver and was one of Wales’ go-to ball-carriers. A decent 40 before being replaced by Rob Evans.

  1. Ryan Elias5.5

The hooker was busy in the loose, carrying regularly for his side, although first-half lineout errors blighted his game somewhat. He ended up connecting on three of his throws, with the group looking much more coherent in the second half.

  1. Samson Lee5

Lee came under pressure from Dave Kilcoyne at the scrum at the beginning and end of the first half, coughing up two penalties, although he was able to deliver a number of solid set-pieces against the in-form Irishman in between that. Only had the first half, then made way for Leon Brown. Struggled against Andrew Porter when reappearing as a result of a yellow card.

  1. Adam Beard6

The lock wouldn’t have helped his case for partnering Alun Wyn Jones in the engine room with his first half display, as he fumbled a lineout and threw a nothing offload that led to an Ireland turnover. He looked more like his usual self in the second half, though, and was an effective target on the throw and grew into the game as a ball-carrier.


  1. Bradley Davies5.5

A quiet game for Davies. He was targeted for the only successful lineout – quick throws aside – from Wales in the first half and provided reliable fringe defence without troubling the game offensively.

  1. Aaron Shingler5

A wild offload gifted Stockdale a try in the first half and the flanker struggled to impact the game positively. He grew into the game in the second half with a lineout steal and some strong tackling.

  1. James Davies6.5

One of the more impressive Welsh players on the pitch at the Principality. He latched on for two turnovers at the contact area and was busy helping deliver ball-security for Wales in attack.

  1. Josh Navidi6

Not Navidi’s best game in a Welsh jersey by any stretch of the imagination. His missed tackle on Kilcoyne will be dwelt on, although he did tackle and carry with relatively good effect.


  1. Elliot Dee6

The lineout worked smoothly with Dee on the field. He came close to a try with a clever blindside break from the maul, although he knocked on as he stretched for the try line.

  1. Rob Evans5

Not the cameo Evans would have wanted, as he knocked on shortly after coming on and was put under significant pressure by Tadhg Furlong at the scrum, including Wales conceding a penalty try following a scrum close their line.

  1. Leon Brown4

Unfortunately for Brown, he summed up Wales’ scrum problems, conceding two penalties and a yellow card at the set-piece after his half-time arrival.

  1. Jake Ball6

Brought some much-needed physicality in the tackle after coming on and was successfully targeted at the lineout. He was lucky that his risky pass in his own half didn’t end up in a try for Ireland, as Aki tackled the recipient in the air.

  1. Aaron Wainwright6

Didn’t have too much influence after arriving, although he did provide Wales with an extra lineout option.

  1. Tomos Williams6.5

Williams delivered tempo and precision after replacing Davies and helped spark Wales’ second half resurgence.

  1. Rhys Patchell8

Patchell brought excellent impact, despite spending the first 20 minutes of the second half with Ireland dominating possession. He was composed, played well on the gain-line and organised his back line well. He also tackled strongly on his own try line, kicked big touch-finders and was successful with his two shots at goal.

  1. Jonah Holmes6

Like Evans, it was a quiet outing for Holmes on the left wing, as Wales prospered more moving the ball to the right.


WATCH: The new season return of Don’t Mess With Jim – the opening episode in the RugbyPass series features Jim Hamilton previewing the World Cup, the best and worst haircuts in rugby and much more

Video Spacer

Mailing List

Sign up to our mailing list for a weekly digest from the wide world of rugby.

Sign Up Now