Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

All Blacks player ratings vs England | Steinlager Ultra Low Carb Series first Test

By Ben Smith
Rieko Ioane of the New Zealand All Blacks reacts during the International Test Match between New Zealand All Blacks and England at Forsyth Barr Stadium on July 06, 2024 in Dunedin, New Zealand. (Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

The All Blacks finished with a tight 16-15 win over England in Scott Robertson’s first Test as All Blacks head coach.


The home side constructed two tries in the first half to Sevu Reece and Ardie Savea but England stayed with them to head to the sheds 10-all at the half.

An England try took the lead 15-10, before two Damian McKenzie penalty goals got New Zealand over the line.

Here’s how the All Blacks players rated vs England:

1. Ethan de Groot – 5

The scrum conceded a penalty on the first push, giving England a shot at goal which Smith missed. Second scrum demolished England’s pack for a penalty. Conceded a free kick for an early shove on the next one. Oddly conceded early in the second half after a dominant shove. Overall the scrum was dominant, but just didn’t get enough reward. The loosehead added five tackles before being subbed off at 49.

2. Codie Taylor – 6.5

The Crusaders hooker was a force in defence. Aggressive tackles early as the tail defender at the lineout and in the midfield on short packages. Had a brilliant sideline tackle on England’s winger, before helping Jordie Barrett secured a turnover. Throwing was accurate as the lineout functioned well until the first couple in the second half. Had a silly penalty counter-rucking from the side just as England were about to kick out of their half.  Off at 64 after a disappointing second 40.

3. Tyrel Lomax – 5

Despite the All Blacks holding scrum dominance, Lomax ended up getting pinged twice. The tighthead finished with six tackles in defence.


4. Scott Barrett – 7

Had a big line break in the first half as the All Blacks started to take over. Came into the game as it wore on, offering pressure on Alex Mitchell’s kicks from the ruck, counter-rucking hard frequently and getting into it on defence. Came up with a big maul turnover in the final quarter to snuff out an England attack in good field position.

5. Patrick Tuipulotu – 7

Anchored the lineout as the main jumping option. Work horse around the park, leading the way in the carry game. Added seven tackles on defence. Off at 62.


6. Samipeni Finau – 7

Nice steal on England’s first lineout attempt, disrupting Cunnginham-South to spoil the ball. Didn’t bring the pressure on Marcus Smith that he could’ve, but played a steady game nonetheless. Got through eight tackles. Finished with a clean sheet with no penalties conceded.

7. Dalton Papali’i – 6

Got into his work on defence topping the charts for the All Blacks with 14. A disciplined performance from the All Blacks as a unit, but the defence had trouble controlling the gain line, giving up huge metres to England.

8. Ardie Savea – 7

Costly knock-on early inside England’s five on the All Blacks’ first deep raid after a stray boot knocked the ball loose. Competed hard at the breakdown as the first half wore on but for no reward. Latched onto the end of Perofeta’s break to finish the second try. Came up with a crucial turnover on defence inside own 22.

9. TJ Perenara – 7

Delivered a sound performance with the side relying on his box kick frequently for exits. Kept the tempo high as the All Blacks showed a willingness to attack for long phases. After a nasty fall just before half, succumbed to the injury and was substituted at half time.

10. Damian McKenzie – 7

Claimed his first two high balls to calm the jitters. Came under pressure from England out the back frequently, but stayed calm and executed well. Found the space for the first try with a cross-field kick to Sevu Reece after waves of All Black attack. Pulling the strings had the ball on a dime and picked the cutout ball well. Kicked well out-of-hand.

Game management faltered before the half as the England defence remained strong and the All Blacks kept playing, despite going backwards. They were pinged for holding on and gave England three points to head into the sheds 10-all. Got timed out of a key penalty attempt which could have been costly. Overall, a pleasing performance.

11. Mark Tele’a – 7.5

Proved to be a handful once again and dynamic carry option to spark the first line break with an offload from Tuipulotu. That momentum led to the first try. Didn’t see much ball in the second half but had a reliable game. Finished with 10 defenders beaten.

12. Jordie Barrett – 7.5

The lynchpin of the All Blacks set-piece attack, Barrett was the primary option maker. As always, ran straight and played the short passes nicely. Had a great nudge of the left boot in the second half. A tough showing from the midfielder

13. Rieko Ioane – 5

A nice early touch in space as England’s rush defence missed the mark. Had a couple errors slip into his game, an intercept and a drop ball. Missed a two-on-one with Tele’a down the flank.

14. Sevu Reece – 9

Was one of the All Blacks’ best on the night. Early chance to counter down the right flank after a dropped England pass. Looked dangerous with ball in hand and bagged the first try from a McKenzie cross-field kick. Kicked an incredible 50-22 after picking up another loose England ball. Had a breakdown steal after a Christie box kick. Smashed George Furbank a couple of times on the kick chase.

15. Stephen Perofeta – 8

Some good early touches on attack showing poise and control. Burst through the line after a one-on-one with Ben Earl and set up Ardie Savea for in the corner. Proved to be a difference maker and performed exceptionally well.


16. Asafo Aumua – 6 – Missed his first throw but brought some power after that, carrying strong to give some front foot ball finally.

17. Ofa Tu’ungafasi – 5 – On at 49 min. Came in with vigour and laid on a dominant hit early. Scrum dominance held with the reserves on.

18. Fletcher Newell – 5 – On at 52 min. Carried in the tight channels but struggled to get gain line against a tough England rush.

19. Tupou Vaa’i – 7 – On at 57 min. Came up with the game-winning play, winning a ruck penalty with the clock in the red.

20. Luke Jacobson – N/A – On at 61 min. Finished with three tackles in a quick cameo.

21. Finlay Christie – 5 – On at half time. First kick was not good. Had the ball pinched at the break down a short while later. Attack faltered a bit with Christie running it, but his kicking game proved pivotal in the end and he was unlucky not to be awarded a game-winning steal.

22. Anton Lienert-Brown – N/A – On at 68 min. Made a couple of critical tackles on D. One on England’s final launch.

23. Beauden Barrett – 6.5 – On at 52 min. Showed his experience and turned the screws on England with the kicking game. Valuable contribution.

Watch the exclusive reveal-all episode of Walk the Talk with Ardie Savea as he chats to Jim Hamilton about the RWC 2023 experience, life in Japan, playing for the All Blacks and what the future holds. Watch now for free on RugbyPass TV


Join free



Trending on RugbyPass


As of today you will need to reset your password to log into RugbyPass to continue commenting on articles.

Please click the ‘Login’ button below to be redirected and start the account validation and password reset process.

Thank you,


Tony 15 days ago

TJ subbed after a Nasty Fall !! what game were u watching - an unpenalised English forward tackled Scott Barrett without the ball forcing him backwards to collapse on TJ’s knee. !!Nasty Fall - I dont think so

Jasyn 16 days ago

Rieko, as he has been for quite some time now, was complete rubbish.

The usual ball security issues and lack of vision as a centre. The sooner Proctor jumps ahead of him at 13 the better.

Bob 17 days ago

I’m no expert in Rugby but the team looks like that from last year with the same problems. The lineout like last year was poor and goal kicking is under par with crucial points going astray. We were lucky to win. This team has the same problems again and they need to improve in these areas to be world beaters.

JOHN 17 days ago

Lol this Grinch shows by these ratings he is out of his depth and his rugby knowledge is so low he can’t be taken seriously. Lets just ignore him in future as his ratings are totally irrelevant. If he is the same rater as the Ireland match then he is more than irrelevant he is a joke.

Jon 17 days ago

Enjoyed the change in bench use from Razor, all really early (not that I agree with that).

Can’t really blame this reviewer for rating on what the ref rulled instead of how well the front row scrummed? There was really no recourse for awarding England any scrum penalties imo, soundly outplayed.

Also whats with rating the hooker on how well the lineout jumpers are lifted and the lineout called?

Loose trio ho hum, would minus 1 Finau for not hitting either Smiths but maybe he already was.

Dmac could have been higher if he was just used a bit more with the forward runners, whenever they played off him instead of 9 they made breaks (though perhaps still not the gainline).

Would give Talea minus - for lack of direction, seems less confident in what he wants to do that last year (still carrying an injury?)

Of course the most important rating is always missed
Razor - 7 played everything simple as possible with no time to change play structure, though you might have thought such a Messiah as he could have come up with a little more innovation in the weeks buildup
BOrthwick - 6 had his team inbetween game plans, maybe the plays took the game into their own hands just hoping to stop the ABs playing their own game. When need to inihibit much more control on his team if theyre to turn it around next week. that he was happy at the end pretty much sums up his performance.

Haami 18 days ago

Lots to work on for both sides before next Weekend, as an All Black fan the lineout was a serious problem and gave England back momentum at crucial points of the game, the halves were rushed, and some of the tactical kicking was wayward, kudos to the wonderful English rush defence in that respect, and the midfield were inaccurate, and did not provide any momentum and targets for the loose forwards to work off. England bossed the line out the breakdown, and shaded the All Blacks in aggression and intent. A lot will be made of the referees performance from both camps of fans so no need to say anymore here.

brian 18 days ago

Sadly the ref was out of his depth. At times players on both sides appeared to be utterly confused by some of his decisions and contributed a free flowing game.

Scott 18 days ago

I cannot understand how the 4 All Black props all received a rating of 5 when the All Blacks clearly had the dominant scrum in both halves. And adding 5 tackles each as a prop for 50 minutes work is pretty respectable. I thought DeGroot and Lomax deserved 7s and Newell and Ofa slightly higher at 7.5

David 18 days ago

Itoje owned the lineout just like Yokohama in 2019 so neither locks had 7 rating games.
Still waiting for Jordie to do something dramatic, like slice througb the defence or bend the defensive line like Ake or Nonu. He is not a 12.
DMac was hamstrung by poor service from the halfs and forwards being unable to provide quick ruck ball. When it did happen the backline started to hum.
Average first outing and first test for Razor. But it’s a win.
Ref was MOM.

Shane 18 days ago

All Blacks are overrated. So many players really disappointed the jersey, let's be honest. All Blacks could have (should have) comfortably beaten England.
This so called new era looks very familiar. One new All Black does not make it a new era.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

FEATURE Pressure? What pressure? How rugby sevens stars can handle the Olympic heat Pressure? What pressure? How rugby sevens stars can handle the Olympic heat