Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

FEATURE Mick Cleary: 'England had a chance. They blew it. They need to take that hurt and use it.'

Mick Cleary: 'England had a chance. They blew it. They need to take that hurt and use it.'
2 weeks ago

The Carisbrook House of Pain may have long since disappeared from the Dunedin landscape but England are still suffering  the drip-drip-drip slow torture effects of trying to win a test match down in the far south of the world. No matter how much they try to clear their mind as they head to Auckland the nagging fug of disappointment will remain. And that’s a good thing. They had a chance. They blew it. They need to take that hurt and use it, not wallow in self-pity, not take false refuge in running New Zealand so close, not believe that just because they went mano a mano with the All Blacks on their home turf that they will inevitably be able to do so again at Eden Park.

They must not be upbeat and optimistic too soon. They need to berate themselves, be it for flaky scrums, dereliction at the breakdown where too much balls were carelessly lost and, yes, for those eight points that went AWOL from the boot of Marcus Smith. The record books don’t lie. The scoreline is the only ready reckoner that matters. England have still not won in New Zealand for 21 years. That is the bottom line from the Forsyth Barr Stadium. Just as the Germans always manage to equalize in the 89th minute, so the All Blacks invariably get across the line.

That is what is meant when citing the difficulty of playing in New Zealand. It has nothing to do with the stadium backdrop as it might at an Ellis Park in Johannesburg with its seething menace and everything to do with the deep-rooted legacy of defending the jersey that infuses an All Black. If anything, Kiwi venues are the least hostile in the world in regards of noise and tumult. That said, Eden Park, does have a hold on teams, lifting New Zealand to even greater protective heights and putting the hex on the opposition. 30 years. And counting.

Marcus Smith
Marcus Smith had a fine overall game but his eight missed points from the tee proved crucial (Photo/Getty Images)

For England to win there would be a considerable achievement. All the more so given that they came within a whisker last Saturday. The fact that they didn’t close out the deal when they had a lot going for them – nagging, pressurising, destabilising blitz defence, a willingness to attack, threats out wide in Immanuel Fey-Waboso, trickery and perceptiveness from Smith (one crass grubber kick apart), physical, punchy presence from the impressive Chandler Cunningham-South (who was taken off too early), all-nuisance-value from Maro Itoje, bits and pieces cameos all over the field – means diddly-squat unless all that and more goes up another level for one very good reason.

New Zealand will be that much better in Auckland than they were in Dunedin. Take that as a given.

This was yet more evidence that England are evolving and improving. This display may have been flawed in parts but the whole was on a par with those encouraging showings against France and Ireland in the Six Nations championship.

England must lick their wounds and nurse that cussed, gutting near-miss grievance for all it is worth. England have to be edgy and antsy and anxious in the build up or they will  get belted. It happened to Stuart Lancaster’s team in 2014 who also lost by a point in the second test in Dunedin, after also almost causing a huge upset in the opening game, only for it all to come tumbling down in the final test in Hamilton where they shipped 36 points. The All Blacks don’t tend to make a habit of consecutive ho-hum performances.

So much for the caveats. The flip side is that this was yet more evidence that England are evolving and improving. This display may have been flawed in parts but the whole was on a par with those encouraging showings against France and Ireland in the Six Nations championship. That which needs to be fixed will be fixed. Joe Marler’s first-half departure was a loss in that it used up Fin Baxter’s fresh legs-and-lungs impact in the second-half. That said, the debutant Harlequin showed enough to suggest that he is ready for the big time.

Fin Baxter
Despite losing Joe Marler to injury, Fin Baxter stepped up with a creditable performance at loosehead (Photo Joe Allison – RFU/ Getty Images)

The 22 year-old may be fresh of face but there is wisdom in that boyish frame, as much grit in the set-piece as his clubmate might offer. Baxter was under the cosh but he continued to contribute. He can only grow into the role. England must hope that the officials get to grips with Ethan de Groot’s dodgy walkaround scrummaging although their prime objective is to get their own house in order first and foremost. They folded too easily and too often for comfort. If that fault line is not redressed, they can whistle Dixie to getting anything at Eden Park.

England need to sharpen up at the breakdown. They were sloppy in protecting ball, allowing Kiwi hands to infiltrate too often. That needs clearing up. It’s a game-changer if they don’t deliver there.

England’s front-row will be on fatigues at training, grafting to repair the issues. They are stretched at loosehead with Ellis Genge and now Marler ruled out. England, though, have plenty to offer in the forward pack. There may have been a couple of wayward balls on their own throw at the lineout but Cunningham-South, Itoje and George Martin helped hassle New Zealand to distraction and were prominent in those close-quarter exchanges. Martin is just the sort of gnarly, niggly lock that is worth their weight in gold.

England, though, need to sharpen up at the breakdown. They were sloppy in protecting ball, allowing Kiwi hands to infiltrate too often. That needs clearing up. It’s a game-changer if they don’t deliver there.

There are precious few selection alterations to contemplate, Marler’s absence notwithstanding.  Smith’s aberration with the boot is to be looked at (although Damian McKenzie missed four points, seven if you include his heinous effort at being timed-out on the clock with one penalty effort). Smith did plenty with ball-in-hand to be trusted with the no.10 shirt. Quite simply, he adds to England’s game, sharp in attack and canny enough with his open-field kicking, that misguided slide-through in the first half apart. It was the wrong option.

England’s big positive was the intensity of their press defence, forcing New Zealand on to the back foot and making them kick rather than run.

There was plenty to admire in the play of Alex Mitchell at scrum-half. Again, he should have been given longer. England’s bench strategy and impact was well below par. There was some concern that Mitchell might get knocked out of his stride by the attention of TJ Perenara in the manner that Bath’s Ben Spencer managed to rattle his cage in the Premiership final. Mitchell, though, was sound: sharp as ever in his eye for a gap and willingness to run and more accurate with his box kicking.

England’s big positive was the intensity of their press defence, forcing New Zealand on to the back foot and making them kick rather than run. The blitz is more co-ordinated than it was when first introduced by Felix Jones but England fans will have to get used to the fact that there will invariably be a glitch when the press is so high and so rapid.

England defence
England’s blitz defence stifled New Zealand, suppressing their attacking instincts (Photo Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

There were blemishes, Ben Earl’s missed tackle on Stephen Perofeta was particularly costly.

Above all, England need to rest bodies and sharpen minds. Gareth Southgate’s team has somehow found ways to win. Steve Borthwick’s side have to do the same.


As of today you will need to reset your password to log into RugbyPass to continue commenting on articles.

Please click the ‘Login’ button below to be redirected and start the account validation and password reset process.

Thank you,


B.J. Spratt 9 days ago

The A.B.’s are fine. Can you imagine what the score would have been; If the A.B. were playing their 16th test and the POMS were playing their first.

SITITI. . . Can’t wait to see this guy play his First Test. . .
NEWELL. . . Just starting to get the hang of Test Rugby. . . Probably needs an uppercut b4 the game. . .
RATIMA. . . how good will he be . . .
HOTHAM. . . .So quick!. . .
ROIGARD. . . Try scoring Half back with 4 tries out of six tests.
MOUNGA. . .He’ll be back. . .
DMAC. . .Doesn’t seem to click with Jordie but when he’s with BB he’s a different player . .

We have a few limitations of “context” We have no problems. Just a “heap” of potential….The best coach of all time, Wayne Smith, who’s helping the best International Coach in the World at the moment, Scott Robertson.

Razor’s S/R 100%. . . None better in the World at the moment!

What a great place to be!

Ruggerz 16 days ago

There seems to be an awful lot of attention on what England can improve to win in T2 but little on what NZ can do.

The reality is this was a near scratch team that had been together for 10 days with a new coaching group and significant changes in personnel (Whitelock, Retallick, Cane, Frizell, A Smith, Mo'unga, Jordan), half the team and 100s of tests of experience missing and the team needs to gel.

To get through against an established and battle hardened team was no mean feat.

The scrum will continue to improve, the line out will start to gel with 4 new jumpers to get better at their cohesion, the inside backs probably had never played together apart from in training and certainly Dmac and Christie would not have had time in the saddle in anger.
The biggest concern for me is at centre where Rico continues to look invisible - his pace should be one of the keys to unlocking a rush defence and allowing Reece to shine even more, the problem with having this centre combination is there is no playmaking centre just a crash bash and a whippet but no distribution ala Conrad to manipulate the rush and open the space wider.

Bob Salad II 16 days ago

I’d pour water on any suggestion (not that the article did) that Borthwick is facing his own Borthwick-Southgate conundrum in terms of selection dilemmas. Marcus has to start again. While his decision making was questionable at times, he was generally at the heart of all that England did well.

I think getting Freeman and Feyi-Waboso on the ball more could pay dividends and the bench management also needs to be tweaked. I think if England are to prevail at Eden, then they’ll need more time on the pitch from their starting 15.

finn 16 days ago

“Chandler Cunningham-South (who was taken off too early)”

Unfortunately he’s only a 60 minute player. As good as he is, I would have preferred him to start on the bench and be used as impact.

Toaster 16 days ago

The ABs will need to improve somewhat to stop this being 1-1

Its at Eden Park which is good
As I predicted the first test was very close and the ABs were lucky to escape which will serve them well I think

The ABs looked clunky in all facets and the talented English provided the threat I expected after beating Ireland and nearly France - they are very good!

The good news is the ABs dominated key stats like clean breaks, defenders beaten, turnovers and offloads
But were porous on defence in the red zone for England’s try’s so England were more accurate and more of a nuisance at the BD which is no surprise with the imperious Maro and Earl

Christie’s service was awful, slow getting to rucks but his box kicking was good

I expect Christie to be the only change with Ratima on the bench but it would be tempting to slot in the two behemoth props on the bench, proctor and Clarke on the bench too

Tom 16 days ago

Match played out almost exactly as expected, right down to England losing all momentum when Spencer and Fin Smith came on. Contrary to what the Kiwis expected with a dominant English pack, our true strength is our aggression off the ball and ability to shut down the ABs offense. The only thing which I didn't foresee was our lack of cohesion with ball in hand, we should have been better. We didn't protect the ball well enough and went back to too many silly attacking kicks. Despite Furbank’s best efforts to drag us into the match ball in hand as he did against Ireland, the inside backs looked uncharacteristically jittery (Mitchell aside).

Both kickers struggled and I'm sure Marcus will regain form. He's a good kicker who had a bad day.

I hope we will gain confidence from coming so close and throw a few more punches with ball in hand, we need to look after the ball, build phases and build pressure. I really hope we can find the mettle and energy to back up that second half defensive performance at Eden Park. That's a big if, but I believe if we can defend that well again, the attack will be improved and we will win. It's going to take a great performance though.

Only selection concerns for me are on the bench, especially the halfbacks. I like Fin Smith but he's not shown anything in an England shirt yet, he should stay on the bench unless Marcus is injured, we could also consider using Slade as the backup 10, that's a big risk but Fin hasn't looked up to the task yet. That's not to say he won't in years to come but he's been underwhelming, even his late touch finder was conservative when we needed to be taking risks.

Another big risk is bringing Randall back. I think it's necessary though, his kicking is bad but we can't afford to lose that momentum again. After Spencer came on as he did in the Six Nations we lost all tempo and didn't fire a shot in anger for the rest of the match. We need a backup 9 who can play like Mitchell, the only option is Randall. He needs to improve prove his kicking but Mitchell is the beating heart of this team and we can't afford to lose that energy when he goes off. Having a game managing 9 starting and bringing on a high tempo 9 as a finisher a proven formula, it doesn't work the other way round. You can't build your team round a Mitchell and then throw in a Spencer after 60 mins and expect it to work.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free