Many believe this year's England U20s squad is set to be the best ever assembled
The Springboks have been vanquished and so begins the challenge of devising scenarios whereby England can upset the odds and triumph over the imperious All Blacks.
It certainly could happen. Home advantage, Owen Farrell makes things happen, puncher’s chance etc etc. That said, if you like your optimism to be a little more realistic, then you might need to look at the level below the England senior side.
England went to the final of the World Rugby U20 Championship in the summer, only to face defeat at the hands of a ruthlessly physical French side, but could they go one step further this season and lift their fourth world title?
We have taken a stab at what the squad may look like this season and, for our money, it boasts as much talent as any of the sides turned out by England since the U20 classification was born in 2008.
Continue reading below…
Watch: Eddie Jones reacts to England’s victory over South Africa and Owen Farrell’s tackle.
* denotes players who may be retained by clubs during the U20 Six Nations
**denotes U18 players
Loosehead Prop – Olly Adkins* (Gloucester) and Kai Owen* (Worcester Warriors), with James Kenny (Exeter Chiefs) and Bevan Rodd (Sale Sharks) covering the U20 Six Nations
Toby Trinder and Alex Seville have both moved on from the U20s, so it’s a completely new group for England this season. In Adkins and Owen, forwards coach Mark Hopley would get to work with two players who have already shouldered the responsibility of senior rugby this season. They have both looked comfortable making that step up, with loosehead stocks at Gloucester and Worcester Warriors depleted by injury, providing them with valuable opportunities.
In terms of the cover, should both players still be required by their clubs during the U20 Six Nations, Kenny is a second-year player at this level, something which is particularly valuable in the front row, and Rodd is the dynamic player in the loose that England have been attempting to cultivate in their front rowers over recent years.
Honourable Mentions – Ben Carlile (Yorkshire Carnegie), Keston Lines (Leicester Tigers), George Head (Harlequins)
Tighthead Prop – Joe Heyes* (Leicester Tigers) and Marcus Street (Exeter Chiefs), with Alfie Petch (Exeter Chiefs) covering the U20 Six Nations
Heyes should return for a second season at this level, whilst Street would be embarking on his third campaign with the side, despite injury denying him a shot at the U20 Championship last season. Given the experience England have at tighthead, not to mention the impact Heyes has begun to make at senior level, it should be considered a position of strength this season.
Petch was a strong scrummager at U18 level, where he frequently and aggressively went after opposition looseheads. The physical demands to do that take a significant leap at U20 level, but Exeter players don’t usually want for a physical edge, especially once they have signed professional terms and commit to rugby.
Honourable Mentions – Jack Bartlett (Gloucester), Simone Elrick (Bath), Kieran Sassone (Harlequins)
Hooker – Will Capon (Bristol Bears), Samson Ma’asi (Northampton Saints) and Alfie Barbeary** (Wasps)
A really exciting group of hookers, who all offer something slightly different. Capon would probably be favourite to start, with a refined all-round game that should keep England sharp at the set-piece, but also dangerous in the loose. Ma’asi is no stranger to competing with Capon, with the two having gone head-to-head at U18 level for England, whilst Barbeary is the coming force in English rugby, having lit up U18 rugby as an U17 last season and now beginning to earn senior playing time with Wasps in the Premiership Cup.
Honourable Mentions – Jack Musk (Harlequins), Sam Elrick (Bath), Sam Riley** (Harlequins)
Lock – Joel Kpoku* (Saracens), Josh Basham (unattached) and James Scott (Worcester Warriors), with Alex Coles (Northampton Saints) covering the U20 Six Nations
Kpoku would return from last season’s side and would likely be one of the very first names on the teamsheet. He was England’s most consistent and effective player in France this summer and he has shown that he can replicate that at senior level. Josh Basham left London Irish in the summer to study in the north-east and could have a new club by February, and both he and Scott would bring experience to the group, returning for second seasons.
With Saracens likely to lose Maro Itoje, George Kruis and possibly Nick Isiekwe to England for the senior Six Nations, there’s a good chance Kpoku will be retained, opening the door for Coles. There’s no reason why, with a good U20 Six Nations under his belt, Coles can’t push for a spot in the U20 Championship squad, after injury all but wiped out his 2017/18 season. In fact, there’s a good chance he would be favoured to Basham, should the former London Irish man not be affiliated with a club.
Honourable Mentions – Cameron Jordan (Leicester Tigers), Hugh Tizard (Harlequins), Rouban Birch (Sale Sharks)
Flanker – Ted Hill* (Worcester Warriors), Aaron Hinkley (Gloucester), Andy Christie (Saracens) and Richard Capstick (Exeter Chiefs), with Cameron Terry (Gloucester) covering the U20 Six Nations
Both Hill and Hinkley bring continuity from last season, as well as well-defined roles as a power carrier and a jackal respectively. Hill also brings versatility, with his ability to cover the second row, and Hinkley’s strength and balance over the ball at the contact area looks to have really improved in his second year as a professional. Christie wasn’t involved last year but, again, looks to have improved as a player in his second year of professional rugby and offers real versatility, capable of performing to a high standard across the entire back row.
Capstick rounds out the core group of four flankers and, like Hill, also covers lock, whilst Terry’s impressive performances in the Premiership Cup could be enough to see him sneak in ahead of a very crowded field of eligible flankers, especially with his academy manager Richard Whiffin involved as attack coach this season.
Honourable Mentions – Henri Lavin (Leicester Tigers), Sam Dugdale (Sale Sharks), James Dun (Bristol Bears), Ben Donnell (London Irish)
Number Eight – Tom Willis (Wasps) and Rus Tuima (Exeter Chiefs)
This has the potential to be a very dynamic duo. Willis was a real handful at U18 level and has had a taste of senior rugby over the last 12 months, but probably didn’t quite make the impact at U20 level that he would have liked last season. Combining his power with that of Tuima, who you can hear more from here, would give England a regular source of front-foot ball and two carriers who are not only able to keep phases alive, but who actively seek to whenever possible.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IXiE1dw-l8
Honourable Mentions – Izaiha Moore-Aiono (London Irish), Rob Farrar (Newcastle Falcons), JJ Tonks (unattached)
Scrum-half – Sam Maunder (Exeter Chiefs) and Cameron Nordli-Kelemeti (Newcastle Falcons)
Another Maunder and, just like his older brother Jack, Sam is already featuring in Exeter’s senior side as an 18-year-old. As a starter, with the effervescent talents of Nordli-Kelemeti coming off the bench, this has the potential to be England’s most promising half-back one-two punch at U20 level over the last 10 years. Both are raw and inexperienced at this level, so don’t expect instant miracles, but the long-term potential is definitely there.
Honourable Mentions – Ewan Fenley (Gloucester), Gus Warr (Sale Sharks) and Conor Tupai (Northampton Saints)
Fly-half – Marcus Smith* (Harlequins) and Tom Hardwick (Leicester Tigers), with Kieran Wilkinson (Sale Sharks) covering the U20 Six Nations
It’s a no-brainer to start with Smith, who has showcased his talents repeatedly at this level and with the Harlequins senior side. Hardwick would return for a second season, not only competing at fly-half, but also covering inside centre.
There’s not a chance that Smith is released to England during the U20 Six Nations, so Wilkinson is a more than able replacement in February and March, with the potential to push for a spot at the U20 Championship, especially if Hardwick prospers at 12.
Honourable Mentions – Manu Vunipola (Saracens), Tom Curtis** (Sale Sharks), George Barton** (Gloucester)
Centre – Ollie Lawrence* (Worcester Warriors), Cameron Redpath* (Sale Sharks), Fraser Dingwall (Northampton Saints) and Harry Barlow (Harlequins), with Charlie Powell (Bristol Bears) and Oli Morris (Saracens) covering the U20 Six Nations
Just like on the flanks, the centres are incredibly congested positions this season.
The trio of Lawrence, Redpath and Dingwall are certainties to return from last season’s squad if fit and available, but the competition for the fourth spot is fierce. We have ultimately plumped for Barlow due to his versatility to also cover the wings and full-back, with an ability to play multiple positions often the key influencer in selections for squads like this, where you are limited to taking a relatively small number of players for quite a heavy workload of rugby.
If England lose just Lawrence during the U20 Six Nations, they will count themselves lucky, although it’s feasible that Redpath will have been back from his ACL injury for long enough to have forced himself into the first team equation at Sale. Should those two be unavailable, Bristol’s Powell and Saracens’ Morris are good alternatives.
Honourable Mentions – Conor Doherty (Sale Sharks), Luke James (Sale Sharks), Jacob Reeves (Gloucester)
Wing – Tom Seabrook (Gloucester), Ollie Sleightholme (Northampton Saints) and Morgan Passman (Newcastle Falcons)
With Gabriel Ibitoye, Ben Loader, Ali Crossdale and Jordan Olowofela all now too old for the U20s, it’s all change on the wing for England.
Seabrook was on the cusp of the squad last year and should take one of the spots, especially with his ability to play across the midfield, too. Sleightholme has impressed everyone with his physical abilities since turning professional and looks bigger and quicker than he did in the U18 ranks, and both he and Seabrook will be well known by Hopley and Whiffin respectively.
The final spot is a hard call and could go to any one of a number of players, but we’ve gone for Passman, whose physical presence is unique among the options. He is an intriguing prospect moving forward.
Honourable Mentions – Cadan Murley (Harlequins), Ollie Hassell-Collins (London Irish) and Jacob Morris (Gloucester)
Full-back – Tom de Glanville (Bath) and Will Simonds (Wasps)
It may be that de Glanville is looked at as a 10 or a 12 instead, but his talent is such that he is going to find his way into the team, one way or another. At full-back, he offers England the dual-playmaker roles at 10 and 15 that they have so coveted at this level in recent years. Simonds, too, offers flexibility and has been used in the centres by Wasps this season, as well as being comfortable on the wing. Between de Glanville’s ability to split the back line and his kicking game and Simond’s counter-attacking ability, England would have a complementary pairing at the back.
Honourable Mentions – Reece Dunn (Gloucester), Josh Hodge (Newcastle Falcons), Louis Lynagh** (Harlequins)
In other news: Introducing the RugbyPass Index.
Comments on RugbyPass
France didn’t lose against New Zeland in 2011, but against Joubert…
54 Go to commentsHahahaha knew the “journalist” just by seeing the headline. Not wasting my time reading it as I know it's just another toxic manifestation of the boks living rent free in this babies head.
54 Go to commentsWhen you read those facts, you can say safely that the game was handed to the Springboks by the ruling mistakes made by the Referee and TMO. Perhaps that is why South Africans were/are so “noisey” about the win….this behaviour perhaps concealing that they realise luck played a big part in the result. Certainly not a good look for the IRB going forward…pretty shoddy sadly.
54 Go to commentsI must admit to being quite surprised by all the wine-ing and hand wringing from most AB pundits; commentators and the general analysis after a classic and engrossing final. I shudder to think how the pundits would’ve reacted if the AB’s where victors with 1 point on the day.. Most Bok fans pundits; fans and commentators take a loss on the chin; congratulate the winner and move on…and till now the NZ rugby fans where the same.. Naas Botha’s famous quote has never been more apt…. Cowboys don’t cry or make excuses.. STOP IT CRY-BABIES; …..YOU LOST.
54 Go to comments4 out of 8 beats 3 out of 10 cups. Maybe NZ are bad finishers???🤣🤣🤣
54 Go to commentsBokke bokke Bokke
1 Go to commentsThe main thing you need on your side to win a World Cup is luck. ABs had their fair share of it in the 2011 final. One score game in the SF vs Springboks in 2015 means there always things you can look at and say if this thing or that thing happened then SA would/should have won that game. Smith’s try being called back broke protocol, but it was the correct decision, so I don’t have a problem with that. If it was an SA try called back in the same circumstances I don’t think many ABS fans would have a problem with it. Cane’s shot was high, it was the classic thing NZ players have been doing, and getting carded for for years - Walking around bolt upright trying to put a big hit on someone. Stupid play by someone with a poor disciplinary record. The one that was a big problem for me was Etzebeth’s obstruction. The referee just choked on this occasion. Frustrating to have the TMO in his ear all night, apart from at this moment. Minimum yellow card for Etzebeth, but a very strong case for a penalty try also. Despite all that the ABs had the opportunity to be ahead with 3 minutes to play, so it’s hard to point fingers too much. Pollard makes that kick 99/100. JB and RM make it 50/100. That’s what it came down to in the end.
54 Go to commentsBOKS had a great side in 2011 and were in kicked out by a NZ ref and Nz were very lucky to win in final against France.
54 Go to commentsBarrett's try came from a forward pass, and perhaps the Bok game plan would have been different had the ABs remained with 15 on the pitch. We will never know. But if we are living in a world if what if's, then go back to the France v Bok game. France dominated the WC, and had they gotten past the boks, would have easily beaten the ABs in the Final
54 Go to commentsRehashed articles. But this piece does not do justice to how good the Boks had to be to win that tournament, and how immense some of their players were in that final. Peter Stef du Toit played one of the greatest games by a loose forward ever. All Blacks played well but not well enough and came up short. There are a million ‘if’s’ and none of the ‘if’s’ that don’t happen will win you a footy match.
54 Go to commentsSour grapes/ face it the allblacks aren't that good anymore LoL!!!
54 Go to commentsDear Internet, This is what sour grapes look like… It wont make any difference in down playing the SA win. The scoreboard is the ultimate statistic. I agree with Johnz, I would have liked a full 15vs15 for the whole game. Could have been even better or worse. What we as rugby supporters got, was a fantastic game where the result could have gone either way. It was great.
54 Go to commentsben loser smith. I haven't read the article. Just saw the headline and knew it was him. Rugbypass surely you can do better than this clickbate loser.
54 Go to commentsIf if if….If my aunt had balls she would be my uncle
54 Go to commentsBen is right, the RWC should be taken from SA and awarded to NZ. Rugby matches from now on will not be decided on points but rather on who deserved to win the most. This will be decided by 1 journalist sitting in a bunker.
54 Go to commentsThat's quite a wind up Ben. I'm an all black fan, and admittedly the loss felt a little hollow, given how well the boys played once Cane left the field. But that's finals footy, sometimes it's cruel. Let's look at the reality though. This was a team that spent an entire year thinking about how to beat Ireland, and did so magnificently. Come final time, they started the match looking overawed, fearful and unprepared. This led them to getting behind on the scoreboard, and chasing the game, which is never a good position to be in a final. SA started better, were confident and assured. That, in the end, was the game. The comeback led by Savea was phenomenal, but not quite enough. That's how comebacks often go. The real questions should be why they looked so unprepared? Why we needed to get behind and lose our so called leader to start playing? And why the best player against SA from a month or two before wasn't even in the team? Plus give some credit where it's due, PSD was quite phenomenal and instrumental in keeping SA ahead, a performance for the ages.
54 Go to commentsMy only response is “Check the Scoreboard” nothing else matters. Ben you will not wind me up pal. Boks are 4 times RWC Champions.
54 Go to commentsThere is no place to hide in the front row. You win or lose each time and it selects for hard men/women and those who enjoy combat
7 Go to commentsThey might have won several different areas on the field but the one that ultimately counts is on the scoreboard. Ben Smith’s nonsense is still shown up for what it is following criticisings by his team’s coach claiming similar nonsenses and several other players as well. I am not an expert but I know All Blacks know that the game is won by the team with more points on the board than the opposition. Also the red card on Sam Cane is entirely his own fault. If they were aggrieved for having one less player on the pitch, that was their own fault, their own captain who possibly in a moment of forgetfulness tackled too high but either way it is a RWC Final, you cannot be having lapses of forgetfulness in a match like that. The fact that they were down a man for 64 minutes was their fault. And even if they did dominate the second half for 35 minutes, they had crossed the whitewash twice, they had several kicks at goal, the fact is they didn't maximize on all the opportunities they were given. The one try was disallowed, the two kicks at goal were missed, the opportunities not taken. Every tackle was made by the Springboks with so much more fervour than anyone had seen even in the Semi Final the week previously. Whatever Ben Smith says, most of what he says can be chalked down to a spoiled sport who has nothing better to say than whine and moan because ultimately the team he supports lost when it mattered most.
54 Go to commentsThere’s plenty I could write on this, I won’t stop if I really get going, so i’ll make just 2 important points. Don’t forget that SA didn’t have a hooker, don’t discount that fact. I would have taken MBONAMBI fit for the game over a yellow to Frizelle. Also you forget that NZ had the luxury of playing without pressure once the red came. Noone expected them to win and they could always fall back on 14 men if they lost. I’d also have taken 15 men NZ and MBONAMBI on the field over what transpired.
54 Go to comments