Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

FEATURE Why Ian Foster conundrum differs to All Blacks' past struggles

Why Ian Foster conundrum differs to All Blacks' past struggles
2 years ago

These are not unprecedented times. The All Blacks have been here before.

They have faced this sort of pressure to axe a coaching team or coach on two previous occasions and although they never actually did it, they would have in one instance had there been a viable alternative and in the other, they instigated an internal reshuffle to at least look like they were listening to the public clamour for some sort of change.

That first instance was in 1998 when the All Blacks lost five tests in a row which left head coach John Hart hanging by a thread. It was a thread that would have been cut, but the chief executive at the time, David Moffett, says there was no credible alternative to put in Hart’s place.

Graham Henry would have been offered the job after the All Blacks had lost to the Wallabies in Sydney, but he’d already decided the previous month to throw his lot in with Wales.

Hart had enjoyed two brilliant seasons as head coach in 1996 and 1997, but in 1998 he was hit by the triple whammy of losing captain Sean Fitzpatrick to retirement and long-servers Zinzan Brooke and Frank Bunce to overseas contracts. Age and injury caught up with Michael Jones and Hart, with so few options, had to ask a young and inexperienced Taine Randell to captain the side before he was ready.

Taine Randell was just 21 years old when he became captain of the All Blacks. (Photo by Photosport)

An immature group lacking natural leaders struggled – beating a terrible England twice before losing twice to South Africa and three times to Australia.

When Moffett weighed up all the circumstances, he concluded that Hart wasn’t the best New Zealand coach, but he was the best available coach and hence the decision was made to give him one more season in charge.

And then in 2009 there was nationwide angst about the state of the All Blacks and the decision to re-appoint Henry, Steve Hansen and Wayne Smith. All three men had been with the All Blacks between 2004 and 2007 and while their overall record was outstanding, they presided over the worst World Cup campaign in history.

But the NZR board saw past that failing and decided that all three would have learned from that campaign and they were kept at the helm. Not everyone agreed with that decision and when the All Blacks lost their opening game of the 2009 season against France in Dunedin and then lost three more to South Africa to sit on a record that year of having played eight, won four, lost four, the knives were out for change.

Most specifically, the media went after Hansen who was in charge of a forward pack that was not competing well at set-piece.

They haven’t built any statues for critics or wannabes yet. My job is not about listening to those people.

Steve Hansen after copping criticism in 2009

Hansen made life worse for himself when he decided to go to war with the media and bit back when he was asked to explain why the lineout kept failing. “They haven’t built any statues for critics or wannabes yet,” he said.

“My job is not about listening to those people. My job is about making sure that we stay on task and make sure we do the job we’ve got to do and do it well.

“There’s no point me getting concerned about what people are saying. This is not pressure, pressure is when you knock on someone’s door and say, ‘Sorry, your son’s just died’ or, ‘Sorry, I’ve got to take your baby who has died in a cot death away’. That’s pressure.

“This is a game. We’re passionate about it and we want to win but mistakes happen in sport.”

Shortly after he had said that, the All Blacks beat the Wallabies in Wellington – but Hansen wasn’t asked to front the media as per usual with Henry and Smith. A few weeks later an announcement was made that for the end-of-year tour, Henry would coach the forwards and Hansen would take over the attack.

Former All Blacks head coaches Sir Graham Henry and Sir Steve Hansen. (Photo by Phil Walter/Getty Images)

The change was a way of refreshing Hansen, of acknowledging that he needed to change some thinking and behaviors.

So what we have now, New Zealand Rugby under intense pressure to remove a head coach and or his assistants, is not new. And because NZR have never actually gone ahead and axed a coach mid-contract, assumptions are being made that they won’t do it this time either.

Most commentators have labelled the NZR conservative and self-protective and therefore not likely to make a coaching change a year out from the World Cup – not when Foster and his team are all locked in until the end of 2023 and it will cost anything from $3m to $4m to pay them out.

But arguably the situation is more intense than any that have gone before because there are multiple factors piling up and while NZR have never axed a coach or even an assistant before, that does not mean that they won’t do it now.

There are multiple factors at play here, starting with the fact that the Ireland series was by no means an aberration. The All Blacks have lost four of their last five tests and five of their last nine.

It’s not just results that are painting such a damning picture. Each of the last five defeats has carried a recurring theme of being out-muscled and beaten in the collision areas.

Their only big wins under head coach Ian Foster have come against South Africa once in 2021 and Ireland in the first test of this year. Other than that, they have lost three times to Ireland now, once to France and once to South Africa.

And of course, the big problem for the All Blacks is that they know they will definitely play France in the World Cup and almost certainly, given the draw, one of Ireland or South Africa in the quarter-final.

But it’s not just results that are painting such a damning picture. Each of the last five defeats has carried a recurring theme of being out-muscled and beaten in the collision areas.

The All Blacks are recidivist offenders in the art of contact warfare and the problem is not just that they are continually losing but that they are showing no discernible signs of improvement and, in fact, may be regressing.

Foster tried to put some gloss on the series loss to Ireland after the third test defeat, claiming there were some positives and areas of improvement – specifically the ability to play with some calm in the face of a rush defence – but he was careful not to overdo the positives because he knows that the story of the moment is not one of advancement.

The All Blacks were well and truly outplayed by their Irish opposites throughout July. (Photo by Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images)

As he also said: “For some reason we’re not as calm, particularly defensively. It’s more the defence where we’re getting fidgety early, we’re letting a few holes through. Ireland aren’t a team that you can allow to get behind you. That is when they play an up-tempo game. We’ve done that and it’s hurt us. We’ve worked on it but, again, they got that early momentum.

“The first half we got too loose at times. In the second half we carried, we were more direct, some of our counter-attack stuff was working well. There were a couple of times post linebreaks we couldn’t get our support quick enough on the man. Those moments hurt. We’ll dig into that.”

But the problem for Foster is that they keep having to dig into why things have gone wrong. In his tenure they have set unwelcome records: the first All Blacks team to lose to Argentina, the first to lose a home test to Ireland, and the first team since 1998 to lose two consecutive tests in New Zealand.

That can’t be sustainable for the All Blacks who, it can’t be forgotten, are also on the verge of accepting a $200m cash injection from private equity group Silver Lake.

The US fund manager has valued the business at $3.5bn but it won’t be happy about that if the losses keep mounting and the brand continues to be devalued.

Our focus now is to work with Ian and his team to understand thoroughly in advance of the Rugby Championship what is needed to improve performance and where to from here.

Comments from NZR CEO Mark Robinson following the All Blacks’ loss to Ireland

And this is why the situation is so finely balanced. The All Blacks are now big, big business. Not only are they about to have a third-party investor, but they also have around $60m of new sponsorship investment on their kit this year from Ineos and Altrad.

The stakes are so much higher than they have ever been, illustrated by the fact NZR chief executive Mark Robinson felt compelled to release a media statement on the Sunday after the All Blacks had lost the series to Ireland.

“Congratulations to the Irish team for their well-deserved win last night but clearly the performance across the series for the All Blacks was not acceptable as we know they have reflected,” Robinson said.

“We all know there is a huge amount of work to do.  Our focus now is to work with Ian and his team to understand thoroughly in advance of the Rugby Championship what is needed to improve performance and where to from here. We will begin this work immediately.”

It wasn’t quite the vote of confidence Foster was hoping for and if anything that has intensified the pressure on the beleaguered coach.

Ian Foster and Sam Cane following the All Blacks’ series loss to Ireland. (Photo by Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images)

He was, supposedly, going to be summonsed to NZR HQ after the Irish series to present a plan to the board on how he can fix things. They have asked him to confirm his selection plans and detail some of his thinking about how the All Blacks can win in South Africa where they will play two tests – one in Mbombela and the other at Ellis Park.

After that, it is expected there will be a definitive decision made by Robinson about whether to keep Foster and all of his current coaching team or make a wholesale cleanout.

And unlike 1998, there is a viable alternative: Scott Robertson, the enigmatic Crusaders coach is waiting in the wings.

He could be in the job the day he’s told he’s got it because he’s currently contracted to NZR. And so too could his likely wider team be on the ground within hours as he will probably ask his Crusaders forwards coach Jason Ryan and Blues head coach Leon MacDonald to join him, with Joe Schmidt remaining as a selector/analyst.

We are not seeing anything yet we haven’t seen before, but perhaps that will change in a few weeks when the All Blacks return from South Africa – a country in which they have only once before won a test series.


As part of a series of planned improvements, we will need you to reset your RugbyPass password from 24/07/24 to continue commenting on articles.

You don’t need to change anything until that time.

Thank you,


Dave 721 days ago

Why are Kiwi scribes so scared of addressing the elephant in the room? It isn't Foster, it doesn't matter what coach you get...NZ don't have the players, particularly the forwards. Gregor points out that they have been losing in the contact areas and seem to be if that's a surprise? When was the last time NZ won an U20 world cup? 5 years ago? Now think about the AB peak era, which was 2010 - 2017...and then go and look at the U20 results - low and behold NZ won the tournament 2008, 2009, 2010 and 2011. It's not Foster's fault, the simple fact is the AB's have not had world class players coming through the ranks. I'm pretty sure if Foster has McCaw, Read and Kaino in their prime like Graham Henry and Steve Hansen did then he wouldn't be struggling. And the reason, Gregor, that the physicality issue is not getting any better is that is not something you can fix as a coach - it depends on the athletes you have at your disposal. Etzebeth wins contact because he is a genetic freak, not because he has been coached to win collisions. NZRU has a lot to answer for in terms of getting slack with player development in junior categories...not Ian Foster.

Barry 727 days ago

Unfortunately you're right Gregor as every fan with a brain knew the moment Sir Steve Hansen opened his mouth enough to endorse Fozzie as his successor and NZR in their arrogance did nothing to indicate that they needed to be pro-actively canvassing all the the wonderfully talented coaches we could have chosen as our next Head coach even before so many of them took other jobs in compensation of the NZR obviously sitting on their hands and believing that their Knight was right!

AT the same time they also made it clear with the help of Sir Graham Henry that Scott Robertson was not ready for real consideration because he had no overseas coaching experience.......and ignored his awesome rapport and and organizational skills not to mention now six super titles in a row. RIDICULOUS ARROGANCE & and IGNORANCE!.

So loyal fans will have to wait till end of year tour at least to have Razor's long overdue expertise in the hot .seat or should a miracle happen in SA have to wait a further year for Foster to crash out in France to get vindicated

Colm 730 days ago

I'm delighted with the Ireland series win, but the All Blacks have not fallen near as far as the media is making out. 4 losses in 5 outings is not a good look, but 3 of those were to the same team, and in the other, a very tired all black got smashed by a psyched up France team at home. Ireland have a game plan that seems to smothers the New Zealand style of rugby, but even still, look at the Jordan try or the Ioane try in the 3rd test. They almost turned that test around. I expect a wounded All Black side to rip into and beat a South Africa who were not that impressive against Wales. They have to come up with a plan to beat Ireland (like they did in 2019) but calm down every one, they are still a super human side.

Warren 732 days ago

As a South African, I'm reading all these articles about the ABs and I cant help but think "Oh boy, its going to be a tough series for the Springboks". I hope I will be proven wrong, but if South Africa win, then I don't think it will be by much. I keep on thinking there could be a nasty surprise waiting for my team...

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free