Saturday night’s thrilling showdown between the Blues and Hurricanes is being seen by many fans as the passing of the torch between Beauden and Jordie as the best Barrett brother, Scott Barrett aside.


In a surreal 2020, it seems that right now, Jordie has the measure of his older brother with all the stats falling in his favour on the back of stellar performances for the Hurricanes.

Despite winning the World Rugby Player of the Year award twice, Beauden Barrett has had a rather quiet and solid but not spectacular introduction to his career with the Blues, playing at fullback as Otere Black takes the reins at first five.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer
Beauden and Jordie after the Hurricanes win over the Blues

Younger brother Jordie Barrett has also settled into the fullback role at the Hurricanes, and quickly become one of the team’s most important players.

Early in the season, his long-range goal kicking was put in the spotlight when he smashed a 60-metre penalty against the Jaguares. He then stepped up against the Chiefs in Hamilton in Round 7 to nail an injury-time penalty to steal a 27-24 win.

Another long-range kick was replicated on the halftime buzzer when the Hurricanes returned to Hamilton in Super Rugby Aotearoa.

When asked to take the tee from Otere Black, the older Barrett has kicked at 50% with one make and one miss in both the games he has taken over the kicking duties. Jordie is kicking at 74% after taking over all the duties following his brother’s departure.


It was Barrett’s missed conversion that only put the Blues five points up on Saturday, allowing Jordie to edge his side ahead when the Hurricanes hit back with a try of their own.

Jordie Barrett’s ball playing out wide has resulted in many tries for the Hurricanes, with the 22-year-old fullback setting up three tries in five games in the original Super Rugby season.

Since returning from injury in Super Rugby Aotearoa, he has added three more try assists in three games, with the Hurricanes undefeated since his return.

That’s a total of six try assists in eight Super Rugby games this year.


Beauden Barrett has yet to register a try assist for the Blues in five Super Rugby Aotearoa clashes, whilst he logged his first try of the year against the Hurricanes.

His running game has been less effective than usual, going without a clean break for three matches before registering one against the Crusaders. He has only beat more than one defender in only one game so far, against the Chiefs in Hamilton.

Beauden Barrett has been less effective due to the Blues preference for playing territory, with Barrett asked to kick away a lot of possession, adding to his limited impact with ball in hand as well as Otere Black running the show from 10.

With Jordie playing a more prominent role in the Hurricanes attack, the fans are confident that the younger Barrett has, in fact, surpassed his older brother as the better player.

Right now in a vacuum, it is hard to argue against Jordie in the better Barrett brothers debate, but the season isn’t finished yet and a return to the black jersey could see a return of the Beauden that the fans are used to.

Mailing List

Sign up to our mailing list for a weekly digest from the wide world of rugby.

Sign Up Now