Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

How the Mitre 10 Cup is shaping up as New Zealand's most important provincial competition in years

Du'Plessis Kirifi, Tima Fainga'anuku, Sam McNicol and Kaleb Trask. (Photo by Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images)

Fans should get behind Mitre 10 Cup more than ever in 2020, and not just because All Blacks will be putting on their provincial stripes for a much longer stint than has become the norm.

ADVERTISEMENT

Now that the North vs South glorified All Blacks trial is out of the way, focus should quickly turn to what is shaping up to be the most meaningful season of Mitre 10 Cup rugby in some time.

It’s easy to point to the fact that some of the country’s top All Blacks are set to play provincial as the key reason for increased excitement this year, but as always, it’s about far more than that.

Video Spacer

Blues winger Caleb Clarke talks to Karl Te Nana following the North vs South match and shares the story of how he broke the news to his family that he had made the All Blacks.

Video Spacer

Blues winger Caleb Clarke talks to Karl Te Nana following the North vs South match and shares the story of how he broke the news to his family that he had made the All Blacks.

Despite the ever insistent push of high performance into rugby at certain high schools of popular pedigree, Mitre 10 Cup is still the first big step into the professional environment for so many of the youngsters that will get what’s being marketed as a privilege to play alongside some of their idols who they’ve only ever seen on TV in the black jersey.

But who’s privilege is it really? One could argue it is the privilege of those All Black players themselves, because this might be the one and only time in their careers that they can make a genuine impact on the game at a community level.

That, of course, will come down to how much New Zealand Rugby (NZR) and the unions themselves are able to work in that area while also ensuring that the competition retains something close to appointment viewing each week despite delivering it in a scenario still foreign to all.

Mitre 10 Cup has especially struggled in recent years from the all-important aspect of mindshare and hasn’t been marketed particularly well by either New Zealand Rugby or certain unions themselves.

ADVERTISEMENT

That factor has been a massive shame because the quality of what’s been on show in Mitre 10 Cup has always deserved far greater importance, be that for the hardcore rugby fan or the casual. For a while now, those responsible in the Mitre 10 Cup marketing department appeared to not understand that, even now, this particular competition (once simply called the NPC) sits deep in the hearts of many rugby fans in the all too often forgotten rugby heartlands.

In fact, provincial rugby is the thing for these rugby fans year in year out.

There are rugby fans, larger in number than many in the rugby punditry space would realize, who care more about their club and provincial sides than whatever is happening in Super Rugby and regardless of how successful the All Blacks are.

It’s easy, perhaps even understandable, for many of us to look at provincial rugby and the pride of the game in the heartlands through rose-tinted glasses when there is so much else to consume on the rugby front each year.

Furthermore, don’t forget one very important fact. None of the rugby at the provincial level, Mitre 10 Cup included, actually happens without the respective finances coming from Super and particularly everything that brand All Blacks trickles down.

ADVERTISEMENT

COVID-19 and its disruption to the normal rugby calendar may have thrown competitions such as the Mitre 10 Cup into increased difficulty on that financial front, it’s also given the competition an all-important attention lifeline which can only come from having some of the sports’ biggest names being a part of it.

That aspect has been needed for some time, but don’t underestimate the financial difficulty many provinces are in right now.

The apparent limitless buying power of teams such as Tasman and Canterbury don’t paint an accurate picture because many provinces have been hit massively in terms of finances as a result of the pandemic. Like NZR themselves had to, many provinces let go a sizable chunk of their operating staff in 2020, and if you were to take a look at the books, you’d realise just how close it came to there being no Mitre 10 Cup at all in 2020.

With crowds set to be ruled out for at least the first week of competition due to New Zealand being in Level 2 restrictions, the financial returns that would’ve been hoped for are already taking a serious hit whilst hope remains that Sky Television bring in sizeable viewership counts to somewhat lessen their costing scenario to broadcast all the games at different venues around the country.

It’s hard to see how the unions themselves can have any financial targets for as long as no crowds are permitted through the turnstiles.

But for as grim as the financial situation will remain, and despite all the other uncertainty, fans should be doing all they can to get behind the Mitre 10 Cup in this, a rugby season like no other.

The players certainly have, the likes of Liam Messam and Nasi Manu have dropped a lot of other priorities to come back and play for a fraction of their worth, and they’re doing that because they’ve got nothing more to do other than give back. Messam has spoken highly of his drive to give back to the Waikato and once some of the current All Black stars get a chance to don their provincial stripes over the next few weeks, you’ll find that many of them will treat it as a breath of fresh air.

We, as rugby fans if nothing else, should treat this competition with the same gusto.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 2 hours ago
Boks and Pumas lead southern charge, but the north are ahead of the game

I don't think that's the case at all, particularly lock is a very bad example to make the point with anyway.


For eg; LSL would likely be the only local player (lock) in the side. There would be no Frost, or Williams, so no 'development'. If aussie had different selection policies the locks would all be overseas players, Skelton, the Arnolds, players I've seen from youth leveling up in Japan and qualifying for them instead, and no doubt there is a plethora of others that hit some good form in England or France, and who if included in a Wallaby environment at the time, might continue have played to their peak instead of turning into 'just' journeymen. I don't follow aus rugby enough for examples of this context but I reckon it would crowd out a position like lock (but is a good positive for the idea of selecting from offshore in general). Essentially there would be a lot of good players that left aussie shores upon making a name for themselves that would continue to remain in the national side, all but removing the need to blood young and unready local talent.


It of course would not be the same for every position, perhaps blindside would be the only other position where the amount of quality that is offshore compared to home would lead to the exclusion of local talent, and it wouldn't exclude rotating in the types of young player like Frost and Williams, but would Bell have become an international success so young? Other positions would be more where the gain of say including an experienced 10 or outside back would be dividends. But then you've also got to factor in whether the players those veterans would be trying to impart there global experience on would still be playing in Australia? Would Jorgensen be enough of a talent for a big French club to snap up? Or hungry for props like Bell and Tupou? Would they see how Ireland made use of Hansen and gun for Wright or one of the other very good Brumbie outsides? What's the point of having an experienced pro like Hodge in the squad when Wrights already overseas now in this new 'world' learning what there is of the French style himself?


The thing is your 'small' talent pool, suddenly becomes very 'large' selecting from offshore. The disconnect is it taking upto 3 times as long for people to flying back home, than say from Japan (or from EU to SA), along with the typical style mismatch's, not so much an ego thing. But with a lack of a DNA like SA, it might mean a lot more 'battles' between the respective styles and practices players are bringing back to camp. Can be only a positive in the right environment.


I think what they have now is the best of both worlds. There might be like 4 or 5 players they bring back, no disruption, no battle of the best way to play. You may have an important front rower like BPA, a world class player like Skelton, any number of veteran 10's, and a backline rock like Kerevi (not saying all these players would have been fit and ready to play international rugby, just imagine them at their peak for arguments sake). And that's what they have. It's what they'll likely go back to doing (if they get lucky with those generational players) for the next WC, even from now for the Lions. So I just don't think the 'picture' yuo outlined would be like reality, that's not to say I don't think there wouldn't be enough positives elsewhere to outweigh the negatives. Certainly going to another franchise for just 2 or 3 years before coming back would be a good development, but that idea is based on money that is not in the game at the moment.

254 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING Rieko Ioane responds to Johnny Sexton’s claims with social media post Rieko Ioane responds to Johnny Sexton’s claims with social media post
Search