Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global

Why Quinn Tupaea is the man for the All Blacks No 12 jersey

Greg Fiume /

What to do with the All Blacks No 12 jersey?


The fact that David Havili was amongst the chosen 11 to fly early to Cardiff ahead of this weekend’s test with Wales is a solid indicator that he will slot into the second-five position then, as he has done to, mostly, good effect for much of 2021.

Quinn Tupaea is just five tests and three starts into his young All Blacks career but already he looks the man to start in the internationals against Ireland and France later on this tour.

Video Spacer

All Blacks react to 104-14 victory over USA Eagles

Video Spacer

All Blacks react to 104-14 victory over USA Eagles

Jack Goodhue may come again when back from injury in 2022 but, for now, Tupaea looms as the best man to punch holes in the opposition line and help break down the rush defence that so exposed the All Blacks against the Springboks.

Funnily enough, 12 is not even Tupaea’s favoured position. That is centre, but Anton Lienert-Brown and/or Rieko Ioane are first cabs off the rank there in black.

Havili has acquitted himself well for the All Blacks this season, especially against the Wallabies. He is light on his feet and distributes nicely, but he is not the penetrator/distributor the All Blacks have wanted and needed since Ma’a Nonu moved on in 2015.

Ngani Laumape was that man, even if his passing game was still a work in progress, but the All Blacks missed his power over the gain line against the Boks. Stade Francais will instead get to enjoy Laumape.


Peter Umaga-Jensen is filling that role to a tee with the Wellington Lions in the NPC, and may again wear black in 2022-23.

The All Blacks like to move the ball wide and, for the most part, that is a fair tactic when you have X-factor and pace on the outsides.

But you do need to hold the defence with a change of angle or some valuable metres up the guts. Havili cannot provide that. Tupaea can.

This is not some knee-jerk reaction to Tupaea’s direct, effective running against the hapless Eagles on the weekend. He scored a try and made some impressive post-contact metres. Well played.


Granted, the defence was little better than club standard, but it’s an indication of how the All Blacks might want to play with their second-five, especially against bigger packs and pressing defence lines.

Ireland and France have penetrators in midfield, though Robbie Henshaw, so strong for the Lions in South Africa, is rehabbing an injury. So the rugged Bundee Aki and Garry Ringrose will lead the charge there.

France has Gael Fickou and Virimi Vakatawa, two big men who can surge through the line and offload.

That is not to say that Tupaea is one-dimensional. Far from it, but for what the All Blacks need right now, he is the man to do the job.

Second-five has been a vexed position for the All Blacks since the exit stage left of Nonu and Sonny Bill Williams, two very different players whose skillsets allowed the All Blacks to change things up if needed.

If Tupaea can show all his wares against Ireland and France, running off the silky Richie Mo’unga, then the All Blacks could be onto a winner.


Join free

Japan Rugby League One | Bravelupus v Eagles | Full Match Replay

Big Jim Show | Guinness Six Nations | England v Scotland

Vancouver SVNS - Day 2 - Full Replay

Vancouver SVNS - Day 1 - Full Replay

Life on Tour: 4

Wolfhounds v Clovers | Celtic Challenge 2024 | Full Match Replay

Boks Office | Jesse Kriel reveals the hardest team he had to play at the Rugby World Cup

Big Jim Walks and Talks with Handré Pollard


Trending on RugbyPass


Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

finn 9 hours ago
Why the world needs a reverse Lions tour

I think there’s a lot of reasons this wouldn’t work, but if we’re just proposing fun things how about a “World Series” held the june/july following a world cup. The teams competing each four years would be: the current world champions The Pacific Islands The British & Irish Lions The World XV Barbarians FC to ensure all teams are fairly evenly matched, the current world champions would name their squad first; then The Pacific Islands would name next, and would be able to select any pacific qualified players not selected by the world champions, including players already “captured” by non-pacific nations who would otherwise have been eligible for selection (eg. Bundee Aki); the Lions would select next; and then The World XV and Barbarians FC would be left to fight over anyone not selected. Some people will point out that 5 teams is too many for a mid-year round robin, particularly as it would be nice to have a final as well; and they would be right! But because we’re just having fun here we’re going to innovate an entirely new format for rugby, where the round robin is played in one stadium over the course of one day, with each game lasting just 40 minutes with no half time or change of ends. The round robin decides the seedings for the knockouts, which are contested by all 5 teams in one stadium over the course of one day, according to the following schedule: Knockout Round 1: seed 5 v seed 4 (contested over 1 half of indetermined length, finishing when one team reaches 7 points) ~ 10 minute break ~ Quarter Final: winner of Round 1 v seed 3 (contested over 1 half of indetermined length, finishing when one team reaches 7 points) ~ 10 minute break ~ Semi Final: winner of Quarter Final v seed 2 (contested over 1 half of indetermined length, finishing when one team reaches 7 points) ~ 10 minute break ~ Final: winner of Semi Final v seed 1 (played as a standard 80 minute rugby match) for the round robin, teams would name a 15 man starting lineup and a 16 man bench. Substitutions during games can only be made for injuries, but any number of substitutions can be made between games. The same rules apply for the finals, except that we return to having a regular 8 man bench, and would allow substitutions as normal during the 80 minute final.

22 Go to comments
FEATURE Is New Zealand in danger of giving trade secrets to main rivals? Is New Zealand in danger of giving trade secrets to main rivals?