Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
NZ NZ

Which World Cup winning team overcame the toughest challenge?

By Daniel Gallan
South African Rugby captain Siya Kolisi (C) holds the Web Ellis Trophy during the South African Rugby World Cup winner team's last stop to parade the Web Ellis Trophy on an open top bus in Cape Town, on November 11, 2019. (Photo by David Harrison / AFP) (Photo by DAVID HARRISON/AFP via Getty Images)

Every World Cup winning team deserves its place in rugby’s pantheon. These nine squads, captained by eight men, representing just four nations, are totems of excellence. They are the grand masters of their sport. But they are not necessarily equals.

ADVERTISEMENT

To put it another way, not every title run is the same. If one of Ireland, France, New Zealand, South Africa or Scotland lift the Webb Ellis Cup in Paris later this year, they’d have accomplished the greatest challenge this game has ever presented. Their side of the draw resembles Mordor while the other half, one containing England, Wales, Australia, Argentina and Japan, is The Shire by comparison.

With that in mind, and at the risk of angering fans around the world, I’ve ranked each World Cup winner according the hardships they faced in the tournament according to a simple scoring system, awarding one point for each of the following:

    • If the World Cup was away from home.
    • If the World Cup was outside of region (eg. European team in the southern hemisphere)
    • If the team beat the previous champions.
    • If the team beat best ranked team (author’s discretion)
    • If the team beat hosts
    • If the team beat reigning Five/Six Nations champions
    • If the team beat Tri Nations/Rugby Championship champions
    • If the team emerged from group of death (ie, three quality teams)
    • For any victory over a tier one team (competing in that year’s continental competitions)

New Zealand 1987 – 4*
Admittedly, the very first champions would always lose out on some of the above points on offer, but the All Blacks’ march to victory was hardly Hannibal crossing the Alps.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

They whipped Italy, Fiji and Argentina in the group stage, scoring 30 tries along the way, and then made mincemeat of Scotland, Wales and France in the knockout rounds.

Buck Shelford signs
Former All Blacks player Wayne ‘Buck’ Shelford signs his caricature at a 2007 reunion luncheon for the 1987 World Cup champions (Photo by Sandra Mu/Getty Images)

David Kirk’s team pick up three points for these wins, another for getting the better of the reigning Five Nations winners in the final, but that showpiece game was the first real test for what was clearly the best side in the competition.

*Admittedly, this tally needs a caveat given the parameters of the scoring system.

Australia 1991 – 9
The Wallabies under Nick Farr-Jones might not rank alongside future iterations in terms of greatness on the field, but there can be no denying the arduous slog they had to endure to lift Australia’s maiden World Cup.

ADVERTISEMENT

Rugby World Cup

They beat Wales in the group stage before edging Ireland by a point in the quarterfinals. Next they beat the reigning champs and favourites, New Zealand, in the semi-finals, and proceeded to get the better of the Five Nations holders, England, in the final.

David Campese finished as the tournament’s top-try scorer and southern hemisphere rugby had officially underlined its status as the game’s epicentre of excellence.

South Africa 1995 – 5
There’s a reason the Springboks’ win just a year after the country’s first democratic elections is the only rugby story to get the Hollywood treatment. It defied belief and was a living example of what is possible when a nation’s divided people can come together for a single purpose.

ADVERTISEMENT

Too bad it doesn’t score highly here. Francois Pienaar’s men lose out on points as their tournament was contested on home soil. They were also fortunate in that they played Western Samoa in the quarterfinals, rather than an established tier one nation.

Stransky recalls 1995 World Cup win
(Photo by Media24/Gallo Images/Getty Images)

But that was a consequence of beating the reigning champions Australia in the opening game in Cape Town. They pick up another point for edging France in a thriller in Durban and then the mighty All Blacks, unquestionably the tournament favourites.

Australia 1999 – 9
Another Australian victory across the world earns them four points and they collect another two for squeezing past the previous winners, South Africa, in the semi-finals thanks in large part to Stephen Larkham’s first ever drop goal.

George Gregan (L) and Tim Horan celebrate the Wallabies’ World Cup-winning triumph in 1999. (Photo by WILLIAM WEST/AFP/Getty Images)

Avoiding pre-tournament favourites New Zealand helped, but this was no simple stroll to the final. They beat three tier one teams along the way, including Ireland in Dublin, Wales in Cardiff and the reigning champions, South Africa, before they met France at the end of the road.

Once they got there, they took advantage of a knackered French team that had emptied the tank against the All Blacks the week before. Australia scored two tries and Matt Burke kicked 27 points in a one-sided affair.

England 2003 – 8
Martin Johnson’s side arrived in Australia as the supreme team on the planet, which served them well but isn’t helpful here. They’d already claimed a Six Nations grand slam and boasted several players who were the leading figures in their respective positions.

Professional Rugby highs lows
(Photo by Steve Cuff/EMPICS via Getty Images)

They made light work of South Africa in the group stage and then steamrolled Wales and France in the knockouts. Facing the hosts in the final would prove no easy task, especially as the Wallabies had just vanquished the All Blacks by 12 points in Sydney.

It was a tight affair which was settled by the second most famous drop goal in rugby history. Eight points on this chart is a decent haul, but it’s not good enough for a win. No doubt Jonny Wilkinson is fuming.

South Africa 2007 – 6
Like England in 2003, the Springboks of 2007 had a claim to being the most complete outfit around. 2009 was the team’s zenith, but an indomitable tight five, a dynamic back row, pace out wide, the world’s best scrum half in Fourie du Preez and Jake White’s simple game plan meant they had the tools to beat anyone on their day.

The South Africa players celebrate victory at the end of the 2007 Rugby World Cup final. (Photo by Julian Finney/Getty Images)

It’s a shame they weren’t better tested. Two wins over England – 36-0 win to start and then 15-6 in the final – hands them four points for beating the previous champions, but that’s as challenging as it got for the Boks as they avoided any other Six Nations or Tri-Nations team (Argentina, who were beaten 37-13 in the semi-final, hadn’t been included yet).

The Springboks would prove their pedigree two years later when they won both the Tri-Nations and a British & Irish Lions series. But at this World Cup in France, they hardly had to leave second gear.

New Zealand 2011 – 4
The All Blacks were on home soil. The All Blacks were the number one ranked team on World Rugby’s metrics. And though the All Blacks were beaten by Australia in the year’s Tri-Nations, the All Blacks were expected to finally end their World Cup drought.

So they did, but they made it far more difficult than it should have been, especially in the final where they almost bottled it (again) against France, clinching a one point win.

World Cup
(Photo by Phil Walter/Getty Images)

They first emerged from a treacherous group which included France and a spirited Tonga, but this was not the tournament’s group of death. They were blessed with a favourable draw in the quarterfinals against Argentina before seeing off Australia in the semis and then France in a nail-biter at Eden Park

New Zealand 2015 – 7
By now the All Blacks were firmly established as the greatest rugby team that had ever existed. They were in the midst of a 509-week stretch as World Rugby’s top-ranked side and could still call on the services of a large chunk of the squad that won the title four years before.

That’s not to say their victory was guaranteed as they’d need to travel across the world to England to reclaim their crown. They cut their teeth with group stage wins over Georgia and Argentina, now part of the Rugby Championship, before thrashing France in the next round.

World Cup
Richie McCaw lifts the Webb Ellis Cup after the All Blacks’ World Cup success in 2015. (Photo by Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)

A gruelling two point win over the Springboks in the semi-finals was the ideal tune-up for the main event against the Rugby Championship holders, Australia. It was there in Twickenham that Dan Carter, Richie McCaw, Ma’a Nonu and the rest cemented their legendary status as the first team to claim back to back World Cups with a comprehensive win.

South Africa 2019 – 8
That South Africa were even contenders at the World Cup four years ago was a testament to the work done by Rassie Erasmus and his deputy, Jacques Nienaber, who inherited a disjointed team and turned them into champions.

They arrived in Japan with the Rugby Championship locked away in the cabinet but were reminded of the challenge they’d face when they lost their tournament opener to New Zealand. If they were to leave Asia with more silverware, they’d have to become the first team to drop points en route to the final.

Faf de Klerk of South Africa and teammates at the changing room after the Rugby World Cup 2019 Final. (Photo by Juan Jose Gasparini/Gallo Images/Getty Images)

Japan’s heroics in the group of death resulted in a relatively kind draw for the Boks who still had to perform to beat the hosts in the quarters. A scrappy win over the Six Nations champions, Wales, set them up for a final against England, who had just produced one of the most complete rugby performances in living memory, beating the All Blacks 19-7. Some pundits and former players were already etching England’s name on the trophy.

Instead it was Siya Kolisi who hoisted the golden trophy as his pack obliterated the English and Cheslin Kolbe turned Owen Farrell into a Ferris wheel.

Final standings:

Team – Year Points
Australia – 19919
Australia  – 19999
England – 20038
South Africa – 20198
New Zealand – 20157
South Africa – 20076
South Africa – 19955
New Zealand – 19874*
New Zealand – 20114
ADVERTISEMENT

Join free

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

25 Comments
A
Adam 449 days ago

I was in Brisbane for England's 2003 1/4 v Wales. I don't think anyone would say they steamrollered Wales. England were rocking, Jason Robinson's break for Greenwood's try and bringing on Mike Catt saved them

G
GrahamVF 454 days ago

It would be interesting to work out a scoring system for the most successful team at the RWC. Points could be allotted for win/loss ratio semi final and final success ratio etc. If that is taken into account South Africa are the only team to to have won the cup who have never lost a final. England, Australia and New Zealand have all lost finals.

C
Chris 454 days ago

1995 will always be a 10/10. Those men are living legends in SA, There's a good reason it's a movie too. Joost played the final with broken ribs, Andre Joubert with a broken hand in a specially made glove. The coach had terminal cancer at the time. Kitch Christie. It was his first time as Springbok Coach and he would be the only Springboak coach to go undefeated. Those boys showed blood and guts to beat probably the best All Black team of all time. I'll never forget Joost tackling Johan Lomu at full pace front on. Basically putting his body on the line for his country. That day they were willing to die for that victory. 1987 All Blacks got whipped really badly a year earlier when they came over to SA as the Cavaliers. Took record defeats 3-0. so 1987* champions. The 1991 Wallabies granted they were good, but who knows.

L
Lindsay 454 days ago

This is a ridiculously flawed methodology. For example beating the hosts is a different matter when the hosts are a tier 1 nation compared to beating Japan. To get a true picture you’d need to rank each team and give points for wins based on the rank of the opponent. Pool play is almost irrelevant, it’s only the three knockouts that count. In this respect NZ in 2015 would probably top the list having to beat France, SA and Australia, all ranked in the top five, while SA in 2007 and 2019 would be at the bottom beating Fiji, Argentina and England, all outside the top five; and Japan, Wales and England, only one of which is top 5.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

F
Flankly 1 hours ago
Resilient Irish will test Springboks despite provincial setbacks

The Bok kryptonite is complacency. How did they lose to Japan in 2015, or to Italy in 2016? There are plenty of less dramatic examples. They often boil down to the Boks dialing back their focus and intensity, presuming they can win with less than 100% commitment. This can be true of most teams, but there is a reason that the Boks are prone to it. It boils down to the Bok game plan being predicated on intensity. The game plan works because of the relentless and suffocating pressure that they apply. They don’t allow the opponent to control the game, and they pounce on any mistake. It works fantastically, but it is extremely demanding on the Bok players to pull it off. And the problem is that it stops working if you execute at anything less than full throttle. Complacency kills the Boks because it can lead to them playing at 97% and getting embarrassed. So the Bulls/Leinster result is dangerous. It’s exactly what is needed to introduce that hint of over-confidence. Rassie needs to remind the team of the RWC pool game, and of the fact that Ireland have won 8 of the 12 games between the teams in the last 20 years. And of course the Leinster result also means that Ireland have a point to prove. Comments like “a club team beating a test team” will be pasted on the changing room walls. They will be out to prove that the result of the RWC game truly reflects the pecking order between the teams. The Boks can win these games, but, as always, they need to avoid the kryptonite.

11 Go to comments
FEATURE
FEATURE Why Joe Schmidt cannot rely on the Brumbies' creaking tight five Why Joe Schmidt cannot rely on the Brumbies' creaking tight five
Search