Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

The All Blacks' first choice 23 makes a big difference but Ireland won't care

By Ben Smith
Jordie Barrett of New Zealand runs with the ball during the Rugby World Cup France 2023 match between New Zealand and Italy at Groupama Stadium on September 29, 2023 in Lyon, France. (Photo by Catherine Steenkeste/Getty Images)

They were beaten by the better side in their opening pool game against France, but there is no doubt that at full strength the All Blacks are a much better unit.

ADVERTISEMENT

With a handful of starters returning to the line-up who missed France, notably Jordie Barrett, Shannon Frizell, and Brodie Retallick, who came off the bench in Paris, the All Blacks put forward a clinical showing in the 96-point demolition.

While Italy’s defence is not comparable to that of Ireland or France, they could not deal with the precision and speed of the All Blacks.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

The maul was used to bag the second try through Aaron Smith but then was often a guise to confuse the Italian forwards, with the fringes of the maul on either side targetted frequently with a variety of peels and wrap plays.

Ardie Savea was offered ball directly off the top by Frizell on one occasion. Italy’s guard, openside Michele Lamaro, could not sight the ball and fell for the fake maul, committing to attach for the counter shove.

That split second decision gave Savea a free lane to come around the corner and run through hooker Giacomo Nicotera defending in the 10 channel.

Savea is a former schoolboy centre who can probably explode through the first 10 metres in an estimated 1.5-1.6 seconds. The half-second hesitation by Lamaro was the difference.

ADVERTISEMENT

Aaron Smith hit the blindside maul defence the next time around, dummying inside two sliding defenders to score his double after Taylor peeled off the back down the short channel.

His third came from a beautiful line by Jordie Barrett running off Richie Mo’unga’s shoulder off a pod screen. The second five-eighth came from a long way to link with Mo’unga and a clever delay of hand by the No 10 put the hard-running Barrett through.

It was Jordie Barrett’s second assist of the night after a stabbing kick pass was used in the 6th minute to provide for Will Jordan.

Another maul try came for Savea’s second, breaking off the back from a metre out to crash over.

Attack

190
Passes
166
135
Ball Carries
98
492m
Post Contact Metres
248m
20
Line Breaks
6

That was just the first half. In the second, the All Blacks executed their counter-attack skills by pouncing on Italian errors.

ADVERTISEMENT

A Scott Barrett charge down led to a Retallick try. An overthrow led to Dalton Papalii’s five pointer. Will Jordan and Ardie Savea combined for a brilliant try after a ruck turnover.

And the set-piece strikes continued to rain down points on Italy.

Dane Coles had a scamper from another maul paul down the blind side. Damian McKenzie burst through a wrap play from a midfield scrum. Cam Roigard exploded inside Coles another maul variation before setting up Anton Lienert-Brown.

Italy head coach Kieran Crowley was right in his assessment that it was a “glorified training run” as the set plays were working with such a success rate as if they were an unopposed walkthrough.

Ruck Speed

0-3 secs
52%
64%
3-6 secs
35%
24%
6+ secs
8%
2%
70
Rucks Won
67

The All Blacks had done their homework and looked to target Italy’s maul defence. Captain Ardie Savea alluded to as much with his post-game assessment, there was space they had identified and they went after it.

But that space and those opportunities will not present against an outfit such as Ireland. This was a one-off masterclass in starter plays built for Italy.

Ireland know not to turn the ball over and offer the All Blacks the chance to counter and their set-piece defence is not as brittle either.

There is nothing from this game that would instill fear into Ireland’s ranks, and the 17 points scored by Italy will perhaps bring forth a wry smile. If Italy’s attack can land two tries, what could Ireland’s do.

But neither Pool A or Pool B are finalised in terms of who is going through and in what position.

France vs. Italy and Scotland vs. Ireland still have influence while South Africa’s clash with Tonga is also part of the equation.

All Blacks head coach Ian Foster made it clear he does not have a preference for a quarter-final opponent and wouldn’t start worrying about it until it is determined.

If Italy tip over France, New Zealand could top the pool and still play South Africa. If Scotland force their way through with two wins they could be the assignment.

The chips will fall and determine the path forward. While Ireland is likely, it isn’t yet confirmed.

There is still a chance for the All Blacks to play the Springboks yet.

 

ADVERTISEMENT

Join free

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

USER NOTICE:

As of today you will need to reset your password to log into RugbyPass to continue commenting on articles.

Please click the ‘Login’ button below to be redirected and start the account validation and password reset process.

Thank you,

Comments

43 Comments
E
Euan 299 days ago

If Scotland beat Ireland well, then NZ could be playing SA....

M
Mark 299 days ago

Ireland should be worried, only boks had an off game they would have lost quite easily.If abs click it will be a replay of first game at Eden park last year,most irish fans wont like hearing that but its the truth.Good news for them is they might not click, but if anyone knows Ireland's weak spots its Joe Schmidt, he built that team then handed the keys over to Farrell, and stepped in to take charge of team during first test last year when Foster had covid.Abs to win by 15 points, (if Ireland make it to the quarters)

D
Driss 299 days ago

Training run ?? Ireland won only 34-20 vs Italy in 6 nations. Why did not they do ??
Ireland never exists in 1/4 in one World Cup !
All blacks will eat them , they have psychological advantage vs them .

A
Another 299 days ago

Ireland will care if the All Blacks play like that because, if they do, Ireland will get beaten.

K
Kerry 299 days ago

Oh yes they do care -Dont believe the Irish mind games -they are getting skittery over the thought of NZ kicking them out - its happening by the way NZ have only one thing on their mind avenging the series loss - thats motivation alone and by God they have the 23 to beat all challengers if they bring their A game

G
Greg 300 days ago

Not to mention kicking a restart out on the full!

G
Greg 300 days ago

The biggest positives for the ABs were for the work done by the pack - I think the AB scrum, for instance, will be getting a lot more attention from the Irish. But our defence was repeatedly exposed by an Italian team that had sweet fa ball, but still created big problems for the ABs by using a similar 'deep pod' system to the Irish - but not nearly as well as the Irish will do! The biggest defensive problem is Beauden - as illustrated by the Italian try at the death. The man cannot tackle, a huge deficit for our so called 'last line of defence'. With Jordie back, kicking for Jordan's try and kicking for touch, and Richie kicking for goal, what actually is BB still there for? His kicking out of hand was aimless, his contribution in attack was limited to a pass to put Telea away... The Irish eyes will be smiling all right, at the prospect of BB at fullback. And if that weren't enough, by forcing Jordan to the right wing, we lose Leicester's impact and have to play Telea on the wrong side! WTF?

e
edward 300 days ago

I think NZ would prefer to have SA in the quarter. With everyone fit, available and in form, NZ can play a game that will beat SA. I dont know if that is true of Ireland

I
Ian 300 days ago

The all blacks have at long last learned their lesson of being the best team outside the world cp and under performing in it. They are peaking at the right time. The series loss to Ireland last year is irelevant. There is more chance of Scotland taking down Ireland next week than the Irish getting past the all blacks in a quater final.

P
Pecos 300 days ago

Italy won't "tip over France". Get real.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

FEATURE
FEATURE Pressure? What pressure? How rugby sevens stars can handle the Olympic heat Pressure? What pressure? How rugby sevens stars can handle the Olympic heat
Search