Beauden Barrett is clearly the All Blacks’ best option at fullback

All Blacks fans aren’t always loyal to their players. For supporters who expect so much from their rugby heroes, it’s almost impossible for them to keep the faith when the going gets tough.

Time after time, we see New Zealanders turn on their own when rugby results don’t fall their way. But the intensity, scrutiny and expectation on these mere mortals goes up another few notches at a Rugby World Cup.

The All Blacks are expected to win, always. There are no ifs, buts or maybes, the fans draw the line of failure below the familiar feelings of victory and triumph.

But that didn’t happen this time around against France in Paris. For the first time ever, the All Blacks lost a Rugby World Cup pool match and New Zealanders began to pin the blame on players.

After 18 months of disastrous results, which included losses to Ireland, South Africa and Argentina, last Friday’s defeat has seen Kiwis hit the panic button.

Changes must be made, and former New Zealand cricketer and rugby commentator Ian Smith wants Damian McKenzie back in the team.

“I certainly have got to have Damian McKenzie in there,” Ian Smith said on SENZ.

Fixture

Rugby World Cup

New Zealand

71 - 3

Full-time

Namibia

All Stats and Data

“I keep going back to the commentators saying ‘these guys are on their knees’… if you’re on your knees defensively that’s where it hurts, and who’s the best stepper in terms of exposing that? Damian McKenzie is clearly the best stepper.

“If Will Jordan is at fullback we’ll see 50 per cent of the kicking from the back that we’ve been witnessing so far.”

Out with the old and in with the new, some supporters would agree that All Blacks selectors need to move on from two-time World Rugby Player of the Year Beauden Barrett.

With the Ferrari that is Damian McKenzie waiting in the garage, of course, it’s tempting to grab the keys.

But remember, Damian McKenzie and Will Jordan were both poor in Bledisloe II in Dunedin. Jordan failed to fire at fullback, and McKenzie struggled to make an impact from first five.

Big call – but I would drop Beauden Barrett. Jordan had a poor game but he is a good player and can makes things happen. And, perhaps wasted on the wing. I would move Jordan to FB. As good as Telea is, I would move to the bench, and have Clarke and Leicester on the wings

— Dan O’Shea (@DrDanOShea) September 9, 2023

The All Blacks problems and confusion starts and finishes with Beauden Barrett. Get rid of his meddling and poor kick/decision making they will be a lot clearer!

— Simon Odlum (@simonodlum) September 10, 2023

Hey Fozzie!! Well done on giving Beauden Barrett free license to kick the ball back into France’s arms all night, it was a masterstroke in tactics, you are a rugby genius and you are finding new ways to play this game…

— PH (@ArmchairVilla) September 9, 2023

Beauden Barrett. Have you watched him play the last 4-5 years? He’s a one dimensional, kick obsessed player. Move to the Blues was his worst career decision, and he’s a shadow of his 2016 form after the concussion. Foz has been too loyal.

— Sir Bob Dobilina (@DrFeelgood1977) September 9, 2023

Barrett kicked the ball a lot on a scorching night at Stade de France. The Rugby World Cup winner would’ve been placed inside the AFL’s top 15 for average kicks in a match by any player with that one display.

Fed up with the mixed night off the boot, one fan even sent a text into Ian Smith’s show saying that they’d be “turning the TV off” if Barrett kicked at all against Namibia.

Barrett has retained his spot at fullback, and there’s a lot resting on this game for the veteran in the eyes of fans.

But let’s all just take a deep breath. Inhale, now hold for five seconds and exhale.

It’s easy to obsess over something when it doesn’t go to plan. The All Blacks and Les Bleus were locked in a kicking duel last week and France won.

But Barrett did what every other fullback in Test rugby would do.

If anything, on a humid night in Paris, Barrett had an ace up his sleeve by sending unpredictable torpedoes either towards the touchline or to an opponent. It seemed to trouble the French at times, too.

But has anyone looked at what else Barrett did? Watch the tape or crunch the numbers and you’ll see that the fullback was actually one of the All Blacks’ best.

Barrett led the way in attack with a game-high 24 carries for 123 metres. No player on either team bested the playmaker, who also made at least as many tackles as the likes of Anton Lienert-Brown and France No. 15 Thomas Ramos.

Before Mark Telea’s try inside the opening two minutes, Barrett was also seen telling his teammates that the ball was going wide. The fullback got the ball at second receiver and set up the wing with a cross-field kick.

Barrett is also the best backfield defender in the world. With simply electric pace off the mark, the 32-year-old has almost singlehandedly saved the All Blacks from scoreboard pain – but there’s no stat for that. Just take a look at his foot race with Antoine Dupont near the sideline last week.

Remember that World Cups are won or lost by moments of brilliance. Experience can’t be bought, but rather forged within the crucible that is Test rugby.

In a tight Test against the likes of Ireland, South Africa or France, Barrett is so obviously the All Blacks’ best option at fullback that this shouldn’t really be a debate or talking point.

It would be great to see McKenzie come into the team on a regular basis, but it won’t be a straight swap for Barrett.

The foundations of the All Blacks’ legacy is built on passion, unity and mahi. If you really want to get behind the All Blacks at this World Cup, then keep the faith and show your support.

These players are a long way from home, and the last thing they need is more criticism.