20-minute red card trial should be scrapped, not expanded - Andy Goode
World Rugby should be scrapping the 20-minute red card trial, not rolling it out globally, and should finally review the disciplinary process while they’re at it.
It has done some good work in recent years in terms player welfare as well as working towards adjusting player behaviour and attitudes and there’s no doubt this is a retrograde step in that respect.
Intent doesn’t and shouldn’t come into it and there needs to be a proper deterrent to reckless acts that endanger the safety of another player.
World Rugby CEO Alan Gilpin says he wants to see whether the 20-minute red card “strikes the balance between safety and spectacle better” but, in reality, it is putting the latter before the former and that should never be the case.
We all want to see a good spectacle but the narrative that red cards ruin games isn’t a helpful one and World Rugby should be doubling down and ensuring players aren’t guilty of as many red card offences rather than seeking to lessen the punishment.
Clearly, Charlie Ewels’ red card a couple of minutes into England’s game against Ireland is a recent high-profile example that gets mentioned a lot when this topic comes up but few people mention the other player involved in that incident.
James Ryan hasn’t played since. External observers often only see the 80 minutes on the field at a weekend and you can see why they might call for things to be changed as a result but World Rugby should know better.
Concussion is a huge issue in rugby and one that has rightly been focused on a lot more in recent years. James Davies became one of the latest in a long line of players to retire because of it this month. This law trial is a backward step in making the game safer.
Of course, it doesn’t mean that players will go out trying to hit someone high and not be bothered if they get sent off but it doesn’t send out the right message and if there’s less of a deterrent, then there’s less of an incentive for players to properly change their behaviour.
Admittedly, it isn’t a big enough sample size and World Rugby wants more data but there have been seven red cards in the last 12 Super Rugby games, where this new law is being trialled, so it doesn’t look good.
When you add into the mix that the recently retired most experienced referee the sport has ever seen, Nigel Owens, is calling it “totally wrong” and suggesting that “rugby is going to be in trouble” if it is brought in more widely, I think that tells World Rugby all it needs to know.
If the sport’s global governing body wants to change something, then it should start with the disciplinary process because how bans can be cut in half almost as standard due to a clear disciplinary record and guilty plea is beyond me.
Axel Muller’s suspension being reduced from 10 weeks, the lowest possible sanction already in the 10 to 52 week top end bracket, to five weeks is a particularly bad example given the severity of his hit on Ben Harris but this has been an issue in the sport for a long time.
Tolu Latu even got his ban reduced from 12 weeks to 10 because he pleaded guilty, before it was increased by just one week for his poor disciplinary record. He has two red cards and six yellow cards this season alone.
There’s a lot of things that can be brought in to improve the game but the 20-minute red card isn’t one of them. A lot of the red card offences we’ve seen in recent years have been for players being too upright in the tackle and I think the laws around the maul have a part to play.
Ireland were famous for excelling at the ‘choke tackle’ going back a number of years and it’s still part of the game now. The name says it all really, probably not something you want to advertise to the wider world when you’re promoting the sport, and players were coached to go high because of it. Rewarding the team going forward would soon help in that respect.
All in all, as well as sending the right message to current players, we want more kids to be taking up rugby and parents to feel comfortable with them doing so and this doesn’t send the right message to them either if they have any concerns with regard to safety.
World Rugby have made progress in terms of player welfare and changing behaviours in recent years and now is the time to be reinforcing that, not doing anything that could undo the work they have done.
Introducing a 20-minute red card is a backward step. It sends completely the wrong message and they should be scrapping the trial rather than looking to expand it.
Comments on RugbyPass
We had during the week twilight footy, twilight cricket, tw golf plus there was the athletics club. Then the weekend was rugby 15s plus the net ball, really busy club scene back then but so much has changed and rugby has suffered. And it was all about changing lifestyles.
6 Go to commentsIn the 70s and 80s my club ran 5 Senior sides plus a Vets. Now it is 2 sides with an occasional 3rd team. Players have difficulty getitng to training now, not sure why and the commitment is not there. It seems to me more a problem of people applying themselves and not expecting to turn up and play whenever they want to.
6 Go to commentsROG’s contract is until 2027. The conversation about a successor to Galthie after RWC 2027 may be starting now. We can infer that Galthie’s reign stops then. He is throwing the Irish Coaching Job angle in because he is Irish. The next Irish coach MUST be Leo Cullen. As well as being the best coach available, coaching the vast majority of Irish Internationals week in week out, he has shown incredible skill at recruiting the best coaching staff for the job in hand. That was a failing in France. Cullen is a shrewd guy and if there is a need for foreign coaches underneath him he won’t hesitate. Rightly so. Ireland does need to start to bring Irish coaches through. Not just at the professional level but we need to train coaches to man new pathways for developing kids from schools/clubs up through the divisions.
7 Go to commentsNo Islam says it must rule where it stands Thus it is to be deleted from this planet Earth
18 Go to commentsThis team probably does not beat the ABs sadly Not sure if BPA will be available given his signing for Force but has to enter consideration. Very strong possibility of getting schooled by the AB props. Advantage AB. Rodda/Skelton would be a tasty locking combination - would love to see how they get on. Advantage Wallabies. Backrow a risk of getting out hustled and outmuscled by ABs. Will be interesting to see if the Blues feast on the Reds this weekend the way they did the Brumbies we are in big trouble at the breakdown. Great energy, running and defence but goalkicking/general kicking/passing quality in the halves bothers me enormously. SA may have won the World Cup for a lot of the tournament without a recognised goalkicker but Pollard in the final made a difference IMO. Injuries and retirements leave AB stocks a bit lighter but still stronger. 12 and 13 ABs shade it (Barret > Paisami, Ione = Ikitau, arguably) Interesting clash of styles on the wings - Corey Toole running around Caleb Clark and Caleb running over the top of Toole. Reece vs Koro probably the reverse. Pretty even IMO. 15s Kelleway = Love See advantage to ABs man for man, but we are not obviously getting slaughtered anywhere which makes a nice change. Think talent wise we are pretty even and if our cohesion and teamwork is better than the ABs then its just about doable.
11 Go to commentsCompletely agree. More friday night games would be a hit. RFU to make sure every club has a floodlit pitch. Club opens again Saturday to welcome touch / tag. Minis and youths on Sunday
6 Go to comments1.97m and 105Kg? Proportionately, probably skinnier than me at 1.82 and 82kilos. He won’t survive against the big guys at that weight.
55 Go to commentsThe value he brought to the crusaders as an assistant was equal to what he got out of being there. He reflected not only on the team culture but also the credit he attributed to the rugby community. Such experience shouldn’t be overlooked.
7 Go to commentsGood luck Aussie
11 Go to commentssmith at 9 / mounga 10 / laumape 12 / fainganuku 14
55 Go to commentsBar the injuries, it’s pretty much their top team …
2 Go to commentsDon’t disagree with much of this but it appears you forgot Rodda and Beale, who started at the Force on the weekend.
11 Go to commentsExcept for the injured Zach Gallagher this would be Saders best forward pack for the season. Blackadder needs to stay at 7, for all of Christies tackling he is not dominant and offers very little else. McNicholfullback is maybe a good option, Fihaki not really upto it, there was a reason Burke played there last year. Maybe Havilli to 2nd five McLeod to wing. Need a strong winger on 1 side to compliment Reece
1 Go to commentsTo me TJ is clearly the best 9 in the competition right now but he's also a proven player off the bench, there's few playmaking players who can come off the bench as calm and settled as he is, Beauden can, TJ can and I doubt any of the scrumhalves in contention can, if they want to experiment with new 9s I want him on the bench ready to step in if they crumble under the pressure. The Boks put their best front row on the bench, I'd like to see us take a similar approach, the Hurricanes have been doing similar things with players like Kirifi.
55 Go to commentsROG has better chance to win a WC if he starts training and make himself eligible as a player. He won’t make the Ireland squad but I reckon he may get close with Namibia (needs to improve his Afrikaans) or Portugal. Both sides had 1000:1 odds to win the RWC in 2023 which is an improvement on ROG’s odds of winning a RWC as a coach. Unlike Top 14 teams, national teams can’t go shopping and buy the best players - you work with the available talent pool and turn them into world beaters.
7 Go to commentsthat backline nope that backline is terrible why would you have sevu Reece when he’s not even top 5 wingers in the comp why have Blackadder when there’s better players no Scott barret isn’t an automatic the guy is more of a liability than anything why have him there when you have samipeni who’s far far better
55 Go to commentsAh, good to find you Nick. Agree with everything about Cale. So much to like about his game
55 Go to commentsNot too bad. Questions at 6, lock and HB for me. The ABs will be a lot stronger once Jordan and Roigard return. Also, work needs to be made to secure Frizzell back for next season and maybe also Mo’unga; they’re just wasting time playing in japan
55 Go to commentsOn the title, i wonder for many of those people it is a case something like a belief in working smarter, not harder?
1 Go to commentsForget Sotutu. One of those whose top level is Super Rugby. Id take a punt on Wallace Sititi Finau ahead of Glass body Blackadder.
55 Go to comments