Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
NZ NZ

The Nigel Owens verdict on the du Toit 'dangerous play' red card

By Liam Heagney
(Photo by Sydney Seshibedi/Gallo Images/Getty Images)

Nigel Owens has given his verdict on the red card that resulted in Springboks back-rower Pieter-Steph du Toit getting banned for three matches following his red-carded eleventh-minute breakdown collision last Saturday with France’s Jonathan Danty.

ADVERTISEMENT

The French midfielder was struck by du Toit in Marseille, an action that Owens described as dangerous play. However, his review of the clash in the latest episode of his Whistle Watch programme also posed an interesting question – might Springboks teammate Jasper Wiese, who pushed du Toit forward into the ruck, have been red-carded if the incident was viewed differently by referee Wayne Barnes?

On the replay showing the build-up to the collision near the French ten-metre line, Springboks No8 Wiese is seen placing his hands on the buttocks of the stooped du Toit and propelling him forward into the breakdown.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

“Let’s make one thing clear, this is dangerous play,” began Owens when reviewing the footage of du Toit clattering into Danty. “When you look at the actual incident itself, the head contact, it is dangerous play, it is a red card.

“There is no doubt about that but the interesting thing is this, if you look just before the contact there is a push by a fellow South African player into du Toit which causes him then to maybe land up with this action, so the interesting thing here is who gets the red card?

Related

“Does du Toit get it? Does the player who pushed him get it? That basically comes down to your interpretation on the day as the referee. So, to wrap it all up for you, it is a red card. If you feel that du Toit goes in the position, nothing he could do about it, it’s a red card to du Toit. If you felt that the push caused it then you would be quite right in giving a red card to the player [Wiese] who pushed him. So there you go, dangerous play, red card.”

At his disciplinary hearing, du Toit denied that he had committed an act of foul play worthy of a red card. However, the judicial committee determined otherwise, finding the play by the Springboks forward to be reckless.

ADVERTISEMENT

They added: “Although there were some external factors identified with respect to the incident, they were not, on the evidence before the judicial committee, of a sufficient degree to justify a reclassification of the offending to below red card.”

The heading resulted in a suspension entry point of six weeks that was reduced to three, leaving du Toit suspended for this Saturday’s match versus Italy, the November 26 game against England and one other yet-to-be-confirmed fixture.

That unconfirmed third match of the ban can be scratched, though, if du Toit applies to take part in the coaching intervention programme, which is essentially World Rugby’s tackle school.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Join free

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

10 Comments
m
martin 583 days ago

Im quite sure it was kwagga smith that gave the push

j
john 584 days ago

Rugby in general is becoming a joke!!

F
Frankie 584 days ago

What are you talking about?
There was no push from number 8, but there was definitely a push from 12...which would be a strange jersey for Jasper Wiese to wear even if he was on the field, which he wasn't. Please hire a journalist who watches rugby next time Rugbypass.

G
Godfrey 584 days ago

No guys you are being harsh on Nigel. He was a great referee and although might have got the guy who does the pushing wrong, he has a point. By the way the SA commentators thought it was Damian de Allende who did the pushing and the number 12 can be seen on the back of the player going down next to PSDT.

L
Lawrence 585 days ago

Haha Jasper Wiese didn't even play. Wow this journalism should really be better - its a rugby site
. Kwagga Smith was 8thman.

J
Jan-Charl 585 days ago

Nigel Owens has become world rugbys lapdog. He is being appointed head of the new referee evaluation board while the problem is not the referees but the absolute lack of accountability from world rugby makes rugby a laughing stock. #boycottrugbyworldcup

R
Robert 585 days ago

Pretty harsh on Wiese considering he wasn’t even in the match day 23.

L
Luc 585 days ago

Sorry Nigel, but if you look closely to the images (what I have done) you can see clearly that Wiese has no impact on Du Toit move.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

FEATURE
FEATURE Gareth Thomas: 'I’ve always thought I was a bit like Dan Carter.' Gareth Thomas: 'I’ve always thought I was a bit like Dan Carter.'
Search