Northern | US
78 - 14
FT
U20
32 - 38
FT
U20
31 - 38
FT
34 - 27
FT
U20
38 - 21
FT
U20
31 - 33
FT
25 - 24
FT
U20
45 - 15
FT
U20
104 - 7
FT
U20
90 - 22
FT
U20
28 - 20
FT
52 - 14
FT
Tomorrow
02:00
U20
Tomorrow
02:00
U20
Tomorrow
04:30
U20
Tomorrow
04:30
U20
Tomorrow
07:00
U20
Tomorrow
07:00
U20
Tomorrow
09:30
U20
Tomorrow
09:30
U20
Saturday
00:10
Saturday
01:40
Saturday
03:10
Saturday
06:10
Saturday
08:40
Saturday
10:00
Saturday
12:00
Saturday
12:10
Saturday
15:00
Saturday
15:15
Saturday
18:00
Saturday
18:00
Six Nations

Nigel Owens calls for law rethink after incident during Italy-Scotland


Referee Nigel Owens gestures to France's prop Jefferson Poirot (R) during the Six Nations international rugby union match between England and France at Twickenham stadium in south-west London on February 10, 2019. (Photo by Adrian DENNIS / AFP) (Photo credit should read ADRIAN DENNIS/AFP via Getty Images)
Comments
5 Comments

Revered retired rugby referee Nigel Owens has voiced his concerns over the current rugby law relating to holding a player up over the goal line.

ADVERTISEMENT

The incident in question occurred at the Stadio Stadio Olimpico when Scotland’s Duhan van der Merwe lifted and held up Italy’s fullback Ange Capuozzo in Scotland’s dead ball area, winning a goal-line drop-out for Scotland.

According to the Laws of the game “When a player carrying the ball is held up in-goal, so that the player cannot ground the ball or play the ball, the ball is dead. Play restarts with a goal line drop-out or a 5m scrum, depending on how the ball entered.”

Video Spacer

‘Ireland’s true test will come in July’ – Boks Office | RPTV

The Boks Office crew dispel the notion that Ireland are the best team in the world right now. Watch the full show exclusively on RugbyPass TV

Watch now

Video Spacer

‘Ireland’s true test will come in July’ – Boks Office | RPTV

The Boks Office crew dispel the notion that Ireland are the best team in the world right now. Watch the full show exclusively on RugbyPass TV

Watch now

Owens – who retired in 2020 – isn’t a fan of the law.

Owens criticized the goal-line dropout rule for players being held up, arguing that the law favours defensive play over attacking efforts. He stated, “That is why I don’t like the goal line drop out held up law. We should be giving the benefit of the doubt and rewarding the attacking team not the defence. The game is far too much defence-oriented already.”

His comments have ignited a conversation about the balance between attack and defence in rugby on X, with many supporting Owens’ call for a reevaluation of the rules to encourage and reward attacking play when these incidents occur.

Related

Fissler Confidential: Elton Jantjies back in play, Pat Lam exit

The Lions could move to sign Elton Jantjies for a third time after WADA suspended the accreditation of the South African Doping Control Laboratory in Bloemfontein.

Read Now

 

Get the RugbyPass App 📱

Follow the biggest matches with live scores, line-ups, news and analysis, all in the RugbyPass App.

Download Here
On Apple IOS, Android, and Tablet.
ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

1

Exeter Chiefs left counting the cost of their Gallagher Prem Final defeat

2

'It's a bad injury': Elrigh Louw called up as Springbok injury crisis worsens

1
3

EPCR announce significant rule changes to Champions Cup and Challenge Cup

13
4

Bought not built: Rassie's importing has sacrificed the identity of Bok rugby

76
5

'Lacked a bit of detail': Quade Cooper on All Blacks' troubles and new coach Rennie

4
6

Rassie Erasmus doubles down on Henry Pollock verdict

4
7

Springboks' place at top of world rankings comes under threat

6
8

Antoine Dupont pulls out of France's Nations Championship

26

Comments

5 Comments
Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

LONG READ

Meet the college wrestling star propelling the USA towards Rugby World Cup 2027

Cory Daniel only took up rugby at 24, but has cemented his position as a dynamic and vital back-row forward for the USA Men's Eagles.

LONG READ

Will Marshall mellow for Galthie's strengthened France?

Les Bleus came in for criticism when arrived in New Zealand with a fallow side a year ago but this French team is a different proposition

2
LONG READ

Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

A Six Nations statistical deep dive suggests the European nations are no longer trailing their Rugby Championship counterparts.

34

Comments on RugbyPass

N
NoLongerARuck 7 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

I think hes done plenty of articles before about speed of game, ball in play time, pens etc in the Southern context and the North are now seemingly ahead in terms of key metrics that determine the quality of game especially those that World Rugby are after in terms of creating more value for fans

32 Go to comments
C
Conrad 8 minutes ago
Where's the power? And what to do with Sua'ali'i? The key questions facing the Wallabies

Plenty would say that. When he first came to Leinster the guy ended careers. Overnight.

32 Go to comments
N
NoLongerARuck 8 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

England were really awful on defence that game, were shellshocked half way through it

32 Go to comments
C
Conrad 10 minutes ago
Where's the power? And what to do with Sua'ali'i? The key questions facing the Wallabies

Toner was treated terribly. Nobody would call him world class but he had to have been one of the most improved players as test level for a period. He was the only reason the 2016 SA tour was even close. Awful treatment in the end.

Henshaw has spoken about being the 24th man early on and accompanying the sqaud on tours. Schmidt would still expect non-playing sqaud memebrs to be able to talk him through all the set plays when he asked them. If you couldn't, it was never overlooked.



...

32 Go to comments
G
GrahamVF 10 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

In all fairness the ref backed off giving penalties and after the pack had marched the Irish pack backwards on the double for ten meters then folded he tol the Bok scrummie “Play it.”

The psychological advantage of being so comprehensively dismantled in the scrums is huge. You can fix missed tackles and sloppy attack - even fix high ball skills - but it’s far more difficult to fix an entire scrum when they are that comprehensively beaten. And that’s what Rassie’s aim was - not necessarily scoreboard dominance but to send the message if you want to play on the same field as us you had better fix your scrum. Like I said - not so easily done.



...

32 Go to comments
N
NoLongerARuck 12 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

How do you judge the North South battle and if the North is catching the South? I think theres a couple of categories to consider. In the early 2000’s the South was ahead on almost every category that determines the quality of rugby playing region. I would say the categories are:

Coaching



...

32 Go to comments
G
GrahamVF 16 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

“Having opened it up coincided with a massive uplift in the success of the Springboks.” That and the development of black and Coloured players. A huge previously untapped resource to the Springboks.

32 Go to comments
G
GrahamVF 18 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

“The North arguably offers more in terms of entertainment than the South at club level as well. The Prem, the Champs Cup, URC and Top 14 all feature plenty of scoring and different playing styles while Super Rugby seems to be the same thing game in game out. While the South tries to speed up the game artificially with new trials and law variations the North has shown you can do it with good refereeing which penalises cynical play harshly and encourages positive actions on the field.”

Great para and sums it up perfectly. In SA we were sooooo tired of the endless 26 phase going nowhere or backwards cycles of Super Rugby the URC came as a breath of fresh air. We were back to the various elements that make rugby stand out from league. Scrum, ruck, lineout, maul - variety fGs



...

32 Go to comments
N
NoLongerARuck 26 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

The Six Nations produced so many compelling games and so much of action packed moments that you can only conclude that its the best international comp out there at the moment except for a world cup. If Wales improve it will be even better especially given the strides Italy have made in recent times. The Rugby Championship is now taking a hiatus in a year it really should be building toward something better which is terrible considering the competition was so tight last year. The Nations Champs promises much but one gets the feeling that the 6 Nations teams will not be at their peak given its at the end of their long season. In terms of rugby quality and entertainment Id rather watch the 6 Nations over everything else other than a world cup right now. The North arguably offers more in terms of entertainment than the South at club level as well. The Prem, the Champs Cup, URC and Top 14 all feature plenty of scoring and different playing styles while Super Rugby seems to be the same thing game in game out. While the South tries to speed up the game artificially with new trials and law variations the North has shown you can do it with good refereeing which penalises cynical play harshly and encourages positive actions on the field. In terms of entertainment the North wins. In terms of winning? They are making strides but until they win another world cup or get a team to rank number 1 again for an extended time again they cant really say they are better than the South.

32 Go to comments
C
Conrad 27 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

Agree. In the end, they had to resort to starting off the ball stuff at 77 mins to rattle Ireland and run the clock as it was only a two score game - which is insane given their dominance.

I suspect Rassie may have gone hard on them afterwards.



...

32 Go to comments
C
Conrad 29 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

Agree. Tournament play or a knockout game I’m sure they would be nailing their kicks instead.

Even conservatively, they left 12-15 PTS behind which is strange as they should have been worth double that by getting their opponents down to 12 players.



...

32 Go to comments
C
Conrad 32 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

It’s noticeable that most NH test teams now refuse to kick for goal until maybe the 3rd or 4th time of asking across the same phases of play. It’s such a trend that they have to be coached that way now.

I think the amended rules around playing the 9 - or not being able to - have helped things as the teams seem to prefer kicking 50/50 constables or going multi-phase in the opponents 22. The 6N teams generally have tempo 9’s that are hitting 70+ rucks a match, so it suits them.



...

32 Go to comments
C
Conrad 40 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

I view it that way also. In most cases advantage for the home teams across both July/Nov legs. The Boks are obviously the exception and poor old Fiji never seem to get to to play at home.

The NH teams rarely went into these July windows having to pick full strength to lock horns with 3 Tier one’s on the bounce.



...

32 Go to comments
D
DC 43 minutes ago
Why the Wallabies-Ireland rematch won't look anything like last time

Ireland should win handily. Even if they are subpar these days - and with an incompetent 10 in Wonderboy. SH rugby is poor ‘and always has to rely on the incompetent refs to even be worthy oppo.

7 Go to comments
C
Conrad 43 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

Exactly right Mzi! If LSL is in that squad I think it’s a long old evening for us.

I don’t really see us going 6 in a row so I do think a fast starting WB’s take this one.



...

32 Go to comments
C
Conrad 46 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

Very in-depth!!!

Some of the stats are very interesting. Still not sure how Ireland putting 42 PTS on england without a scrum can be explained!



...

32 Go to comments
N
NoLongerARuck 46 minutes ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

South Africa sometimes get carried away when the going is good. They lost to Australia that way and they should have won by way more against Ireland but they were more interested in battering and brutalising their opponents than being clinical.

32 Go to comments
T
Tom 1 hour ago
Losing to Henry Pollock would be unbearable

Absolutely. England are unlikely to out-Bok the Boks. I say only unlikely because they did nearly do it in the 2023 world cup which was a hell of a performance by the forwards (until Dan Cole got benched).

If England go into the game and try to win an armwrestle I'm gonna be p*ssed off. The Boks are a fantastic side but they have shown occasional frailty when sides take them out of their comfort zone. If England play into their hands, they lose.



...

12 Go to comments
R
RT 1 hour ago
Losing to Henry Pollock would be unbearable

As an Englishman i fear the worst for Saturday , very tough afternoon in store .

12 Go to comments
L
Lou Cifer 1 hour ago
Losing to Henry Pollock would be unbearable

One feels there is too much media pressure to, at a bare minimum, include him in the matchday 23. A hype-monster has been created & some days it’ll work in England’s favour and some days it won’t. Only time will tell which outweighs the other….

12 Go to comments
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Search Timezones
Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close