Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global

'Very, very poor' - Former Scotland coach slams performance of English refs in Champions Cup

By Josh Raisey
Press Association

Former Scotland coach Matt Williams has not held back when criticising the “over-officious” performance of the English referees in the Heineken Champions Cup final.


Speaking to Virgin Media Sport after Toulouse’s victory over La Rochelle on Saturday, Williams slammed the performance of referee Luke Pearce, his assistant referees Wayne Barnes and Matthew Carley, and television match official Tom Foley.

In a hectic first half, where La Rochelle centre Levani Botia was rightfully sent off for a dangerous tackle, the Australian also accused Pearce of losing control.

Video Spacer

Spirit of Rugby | Episode 2 | RugbyPass

Video Spacer

Spirit of Rugby | Episode 2 | RugbyPass

“The English referees in the quarter-finals, semi-finals and finals have been very, very poor- over-officious,” Williams said.

“I’ll give you an example, the 68th minute, when [Gregory] Alldritt was penalised for being off his feet at a ruck, they could have pulled that penalty out 65 times in that game, and they pulled it out once. It’s the inconsistency of that.

“The refereeing of the scrums, we just saw so much of the English referees, so much of them talking to TMOs, it really got out of control.

“I thought the second half, Luke Pearce did better. I thought he’d lost control in the first half. It was so mad, and he found it difficult to keep up with it. But it did get better in the second half, I think that’s because the players actually played a bit of rugby, and started to get tired.


“Our officiating at the top level is having such an impact on the game, and slowing the game. We’re seeing far too much of referees, and not enough of our great athletes. That has to change. World Rugby has to act on this. It’s not just here, it’s all around the world. We saw it up close in the quarters, the semis, and finals.

“In particular, the English referees are way, way over officious, and they don’t have a great feel for the game. That’s why we got the sort of game we had today.”

Former Italy international Ian McKinley also picked up on the speed of the match as an area of concern.

“It was 52 minutes that first half went,” McKinley said.

“So from a player’s point of view you want a quick game, you don’t want stop-start.

“In terms of Luke Pearce, Wayne Barnes seemed to be reffing that game a bit more than he did. As a player, if you see the touch judge or TMO is reffing it more than the main man in the middle, you might question his authority.”


Join free



Trending on RugbyPass


Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

Shaylen 1 hours ago
Jack Willis' Champions Cup masterclass proves English eligibility rules need a rethink

If France, Wales, England, Scotland and Ireland got together and all changed their eligibility laws in the same way SA has it would be absolutely bonkers. All players from all nations involved in Europe would be fair game as would their coaches. The investment in rugby would be supercharged as teams would rush to create dream teams. Transfer markets would be super charged, salary caps may change, private investment would grow as rich backers first buy clubs and then put money into their clubs in an effort to land the best players. The richest clubs and franchises would benefit most but money and players would move across borders at a steady flow. Suddenly countries like Wales and Scotland would have a much larger pool of players to select from who would be developed and improved in systems belonging to their rivals within superstar squads while their clubs receive large sums in the transfer market. The Six Nations would experience a big boost as the best players become available all the time. The Champions cup would become even more fiercely contested as the dream teams clash. Fan engagement would grow as fans would follow their favourite players creating interest in the game across the continent. Transfer markets and windows would become interesting events in themselves, speculation would drive it and rumours of big transfers and interest in players would spread. All of this is speculation and much of it would not eventuate straight away but just like in football the spread of players and talent would create these conditions over time. The transfer markets in European football is proof of this. Football had the same club vs country debate eons ago and favoured an open system. This has made it the largest game in the world with global interest and big money. Rugby needs to embrace this approach in the long run as well

12 Go to comments
Jon 7 hours ago
Waratahs 'counter-culture' limits Wallaby options for Joe Schmidt

This is a bit dramatic for me, I think the Rebels and Force cultures would be very strong, and if a player is chosen from either, you can be confident they are in a good head space and ready. Whether they quite have the technical or tactical foundations of the other two states is where one would way their risk of selection. I see no need for Schmidt to worry about that risk in this squad. The main reason I could see a predominance of players from Brumbies and Reds, is simple cohesion. What might the coaching group make of what’s lacking in the Tahs, and to a lesser extent Rebels and Force’s, franchise? Certainly sides (players) that are running irish plays like we saw from that lovely McDermott long ball with have a head start. I hope the players can continue it at International level. Really liked what I saw of Wright (don’t know player focus and just hadn’t seen a lot of him anyway) in that game, can see him being a glue in a Wallaby side too. A with the similar worry of selecting players like Ryan, I think it unfounded to worry so much about forward balance at the moment. Including both Wright and Skelton in the same lineout is not going to lose you games gainst Wales. Nor will any unknown weakenss Wales might find in Ryan be exploited to any great extent. It is the perfect time to introduce such a young player. What other shortcuts might Schmidt want to make now, just a year out from hosting BIL? When Gamble came on the scene I thought he had a Pocock ability to break game apart along with performing the role of a openside well. I would be very keen to drop Leota/Hooper for Gamble, and in your squad make up, include Uru as a lock. Did you forget to remove Vunivalu from your team? Would you have Meafou in your squad if you could?

114 Go to comments
FEATURE How Leinster should learn from Dan Carter after toughest Champions Cup 'lesson' of all How Leinster should learn from Dan Carter after toughest Champions Cup 'lesson' of all