Pourquoi les joueurs sont restés figés sur le terrain pour le Ecosse-France
La France a battu l’Écosse 20 à 16 lors de la deuxième journée du Tournoi des Six Nations. Mise à part la décision polémique de l’arbitre vidéo en fin de rencontre, ce qui a retenu l’attention pendant le match, ce sont les séquences de ping pong qu’on ne voyait plus guère.
Cette pratique – il faut le dire, agaçante – a connu une résurgence ces derniers temps, avec l’apparition de ce qu’on a appelé arbitrairement « loi Dupont » car c’est le demi de mêlée du Stade Toulousain qui a eu la malice d’exploiter une faille du règlement.
Cette lacune de la règle relative au hors-jeu permet aux joueurs de disposer d’un temps considérable pour exécuter leurs coups de pied en profitant du fait que leurs adversaires sont hors-jeu (c’est-à-dire placés devant le botteur) – un scénario qui s’est déroulé péniblement à Murrayfield et que l’Ecosse avait déjà exploité la semaine précédente face au Pays de Galles.
Le temps est suspendu
Les joueurs se trouvant en position hors-jeu risquent en effet une sanction s’ils interfèrent avec le jeu ou s’ils avancent vers le ballon. Dans l’attente, ils donc doivent rester immobiles sur le terrain jusqu’à ce que le joueur qui a récupéré le ballon avance de cinq mètres, le passe ou effectue un coup de pied, leur permettant ainsi de participer au jeu sans être considérés hors-jeu.
Ainsi, pendant de longs temps de jeu, les botteurs (Thomas Ramos et Finn Russell) n’avançaient pas de cinq mètres et ne passaient pas le ballon, ce qui maintenait les joueurs adverses en position de hors-jeu. Cette tactique, bien que légale, a conduit à une paralysie.
Le temps est alors comme suspendu, le rythme cassé, les joueurs se transformant en statues comme jadis dans la cour de récré, le temps que les deux botteurs en aient fini avec leur partie de ping pong.
« C’était intelligent de la part de Dupont et tout le monde le copie maintenant, mais c’est un domaine qu’ils (les autorités) devront changer », avait plaidé Bernard Jackman à l’émission Against the Head de RTE en début de semaine.
‘It was smart by Dupont and everyone is copying it now, but it is an area that they (authorities) will have to change’ – @bernardjackman explains the ‘Dupont law’ and its impact on the game #AgainstTheHead pic.twitter.com/pG4OYkCZOM
— RTÉ Sport (@RTEsport) February 5, 2024
L’ancien arrière irlandais Rob Kearney s’est également indigné de l’exploitation de la règle. « C’est une règle qui ne montre pas le rugby sous son meilleur jour et il faut changer quelque chose », avait-il déclaré sur Virgin Media Sports.
L’analyste de RugbyPass Sam Larner a écrit sur X que : « Je soupçonne que ce pourrait être le jeu qui tue la loi Dupont à 5m….. L’Ecosse se montre intelligente avec cette loi ».
L’immobilisation à Murrayfield, perçue par beaucoup comme une mauvaise image pour les spectateurs, incitera sans doute la fédération internationale à reconsidérer et éventuellement à réviser la règle afin d’empêcher une telle exploitation.
Comments on RugbyPass
The game was changing too much with teams trying to role the dice drawing fouls. Would be better if scrums and the adjudicating problems were resolved but this is a good immediate fix.
37 Go to commentsLike many here I am encouraged by this post. Our forwards are where the real rewards and improvements must come from. With a 50/50 pack against any opposition, our backs could ensure more than 50% of the games will be won. We need Valetini at 6 and Cale at 8 to make the most or a good tight 5, McWright will add to the effectiveness of the pack BUT must get a very good tight 5 out there first.
97 Go to commentsThe key point I think that is missing is that if Joseph wants to guarantee a Lions spot, he really has to play wing in his first year. He is easily going to nail down whatever he wants to do, but with just half a season, how much of a factor he proves to be in the Lions series could be dictated by this initial choice of playing position.
8 Go to commentsthe game was 2 weeks before the challenge cup final. I really don’t believe they needed to rest that many players.
1 Go to commentsI really feel like neither of the Vunipolas is given the respect they deserve. I would have liked to see both of them get a few more caps than they have gotten in the past couple of years, but unfortunately the fact that they both peaked young has meant that for a number of years they have been perceived as disappointments. When they are both retired, in the cold light of day they will be recognised as two of the best players of their generation of any nation.
2 Go to commentsthis generation of saracens players could produce some really incredible coaches. When Farrell retires he could walk into any premiership team as a defence, attack, or kicking coach. Itoje could make it as a defence or a lineout coach, and Jamie George as a lineout or scrum coach. The problem the Vunipolas are going to have is that its not clear what their coaching speciality would be. Neither are great in the set piece, and while they were good in attack and defence, they were never tactical masterminds. Perhaps contact skills would be their ideal brief? Mako perhaps could work in strength & conditioning, but Billy has a bit of a reputation for not taking that side of the game seriously.
2 Go to commentsA very good player.We are finally getting some balance in our team. Plummer..Heem ..Lam a solid..experienced combo who take the sensible options consistently. Clarke was a grt impact of the bench option until Lam moved to 13 to replace an injured Reiko. Cotter is doing a grt job building his team. .
1 Go to commentsSaturday was last straw. Terrible record in Premiership since Jan 23. Capitulation against Bath at home. There are 3 conclusions. Players aren't good enough. Coaching team aren't good enough or combination of both.
2 Go to commentsAs you say in your article Brett, the point was Hamish and his vanity - plain and simple. The crazy bit is that sua’ali’i has to be probably twice the player of mark N, no easy feat, just for RA to get their money's worth!?! And as you say, tahs aren't short of wingers, props on the other hand id like to see $1.6m spent on. I still shake my head at the absolute carry on in the media and comments section around the boon of getting sua’ali’i and the revenue it'd generate. It was all such hogwash imo and short sighted, real sugar hit stuff. And wasnt Waugh (and others) on the board at the time this money was spent? You say silver bullet, I'd say sugar hit but without the flavour.
8 Go to commentsNZR should play hard all a bit with some of these players and make them sign up to the next world cup. If they won’t, offer it to someone who will. Because what happens is the NH (especially France) swoop on a bunch of nz players coming off contract, weakening their depth, and nz scrambles less than 2 years out trying to get replacements up to speed.
1 Go to commentsNo thanks. Savea almost always leaves easy points out there and goes for the corner, no matter how many times it’s not working. He claimed he took “the learnings” from this when he kept making the same mistake against the Boks a few years ago. Then went out the very next week and did the same thing and SA snatched victory because of it. Years later he still does it, right up to and including the world cup final. Great player, not so great rugby nous.
10 Go to commentsIt certainly wasn't a rhetorical masterpiece coming from big E …. (just as a side remark: Eben is the better player, Siya by far the better talker - maybe that's why they don't seem to like each other very much) …. but could we please move on?
63 Go to commentsMan who wasn't there and hasn't held a conversation with those who were present weighs in on dead rubber debate and is presented as representative of the Irish Rugby Union’s spokesperson on subject he has no apparent knowledge of whatsoever.
63 Go to commentsanybody who bends at the waist when they tackle
4 Go to commentsThe evidence is not strong that this is necessary. Mounga choked on clutch kicks in the WRC final and lost the match by not performing his core goal kicking role to the level required. He also choked in the Semi final against England and was targeted as the weak point in the defence allowing them to score. Not a test great frankly. Why bend the rules for a player that is competent but not brilliant at test level?
11 Go to commentsDear Robbie, Please return to the Crusaders next season. Sincerely, Scott
1 Go to commentsDid the big E call the Irish the ‘White Can’ts’? That would’ve been good
63 Go to commentsDalton Papalii will be lucky to be selected on the Matchday 23. Ardie Savea, Ethan Blackadder, Luke Jacobson, and Peter Lauki are all as good or better openside flankers
10 Go to commentsScott Barrett is a lock and they have a much longer shelf life than a loose forward. Far more likely that Barrett will still demand a starting position based on performance at age 33 at RWC 2027 than Savea, whose explosive athleticism will have declined and he will in all likelihood have been surpassed by Hoskins Sotutu, Wallace Siti, Peter Lauki and Brayden Iose.
10 Go to commentsExtremely frustrating to get yet more speculation over whether or not Eben actually counted 12 players or not, but honestly big respect to McCloskey for keeping it classy and not pointing out Etzebeth’s hypocrisy. The Irish are a popular team outside of Ireland because they do their talking on the pitch, and its honestly a PR masterclass that they’re keeping it that way following Etzebeth’s provocation.
63 Go to comments